• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

Let me guess: a new Star Trek with a sexy young cast.

(Which is what they have said we needed for thirty years.)

That does seem to be a popular solution to many movie studios. My money is they will soon reboot TNG. I feel like it's a idea they are just waiting for the right time to do.
 
I don’t understand why Lower Decks ended after 5(?) Seasons. It was a cartoon. And a good one.

Was it just a case of “always leave them wanting more”?

What happened?
It was too good and was making the other series look bad by comparison.

Not the other Star Trek series, just other TV series in general.

If I had to make a real guess, I'd say that the numbers weren't on its side, but which numbers I don't know.
possibly just they can't be lower deckers forever, possibly "lets get out of this while we're still a good show"
Five years is now the cutoff for Trek shows. That's what everyone means when they say "five is the new seven."
As to why shows don't run as long, it's just the new standard of the streaming platforms. The old syndication model was about "stripping" a show to run five days a week, so the magic number was >100 episodes. The built-in cost increases inherent in a long-running show tend to lower the profit margins the longer a show goes, so unless it's a mega-hit that could pull in top ad revenue on a network, there's a point at which making new episodes just doesn't help the bottom line. Streaming is a different model that, apparently, doesn't require six seasons of 24 episodes.

It's always about money.
 
A TNG recast I will say will likely have a younger cast than the OG show. Though I guess TNG's cast will kind of young as well I think. I mean people sort of always think of Picard as being old but I think most of the cast were in their 20's or early 30's.
 
No, not really. They all played older, with the exception of Siddig. They were far from their teenage years in their performances.
Did they? I don't recall them ever saying the characters were older than the actor.
No idea what the second sentence even means. Some younger actors can act rings around older ones.
 
Did they? I don't recall them ever saying the characters were older than the actor.
No idea what the second sentence even means. Some younger actors can act rings around older ones.
I will say this: on his web show, Dominic Keating said that studio executives and Berman told him that they did have youth and sex appeal that would lead to Enterprise replacing TNG in the movies (unlike DS9 and Voyager). It was very clear they were going after an audience.
 
I will say this: on his web show, Dominic Keating said that studio executives and Berman told him that they did have youth and sex appeal that would lead to Enterprise replacing TNG in the movies (unlike DS9 and Voyager). It was very clear they were going after an audience.
Well. yeah.
 
In fact the Augment Virus solves all Klingon makeup changes if there have been unsuccessful attempts to fix it via genetic engineering or surgery. It's the explanation that keeps explaining.
Any explanation also has to account for the Disco Mirror Universe also having Disco Klingons.
 
Last edited:
Any explanation also has to account for the Disco Mirror Universe also having Disco Klingons.
As with the same people on a ship called the Enterprise and the acid stain on McCoy’s desk, it happened there too, for different reasons. (Since remember, the MU isn’t a divergent timeline, it’s a weirdly parallel dimension where a lot of the same things happen, darkly reflected.). And in both, the Augment virus screwed up a lot of Klingon genelines, which went off in multiple “deformed” directions throughout the Empire. (Good chance that in the MU, the Terrans dumped it on the Klingons on purpose, hoping it would genocide them, but no such “luck”.) About 120 years later, House Mo’kai finally figures out how to fix everybody. There, solved.
 
Exactly.

This is how Kasidy Yates got pregnant at the end of DS9. (Ben didn't take an injection that Bashir reminded him about, but was so busy with everything going on in the war that he forgot.)
A bit implausible. Even with 2025 technology either slow-release hormones or an IUD could have been put in when they had their first date and still been working when Ben joins the prophets.
 
People sometimes (often?) do dumb things with regards to sex. I find it hard to believe that will change by the 24th century.
More like "surprise" babies are seen as an interesting plot device. Alexander, too. What are the odds on a medium-sized space station?
 
More like "surprise" babies are seen as an interesting plot device. Alexander, too. What are the odds on a medium-sized space station?
Yeah, it’s drama. It’s like in old movies where the wife tells the husband she’s pregnant and, while deliriously happy, he’s also completely surprised.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top