• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Were Klingons Based On Arabs?

bbally

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Red Shirt
Were Klingons Based On Arabs? (Fake/Parody Article)

I've found this site that's a spoof of right wing Christian sites that had an interesting "joke" Star Trek article:

Can The World of Star Trek Help Americans Understand Muslims and their Culture of Terror?


True Christian Star Trek fan, and Sunday School teacher, Geoffrey Mullins, thinks so. Most fans of the popular television series, Star Trek, are already aware that the show's creator, Gene Roddenberry, gathered ideas for his fictional Klingon species during a trip to the Holy Land in the late 1960's. After only a cursory viewing of an early episode of Star Trek, Landover Baptist Pastors were shocked at how closely Roddenberry's Klingon characters resembled Arabs, in both their features and mannerisms. "I'm not a big fan of Mr. Roddenberry," says Landover Baptist Pastor, Deacon Fred. "But our opinions are very similar when it comes to Muslims. Being a Jew, Mr. Roddenberry knew first hand what it was like to be persecuted by such a filthy, backward race of warmongers. My guess is that he couldn't come right out and say what he felt in public, so he used the television series, Star Trek, to get his views across. Only an unsaved idiot would have a hard time seeing how obvious it is that Star Trek's, Klingons, are actually Arabs in disguise. I understand it's harder to tell with the new series, because they started to get politically correct and had to change the makeup so it wasn't so obvious. Well, you don't need a degree in Theology to see how clear it still is. In fact, I think the new makeup does an even better job of bringing out the demonic nature and character of the Arab people."

Sunday School teacher, Geoffrey Mullins, has incorporated several Klingon-filled Star Trek episodes into an eight-week Bible based media study on Muslim culture and behavior. Landover Baptist is the first church to use Geoffrey's study in their senior high school Department. "Our Christian children are getting most of their information about Arabs and Muslims from the media," says Mullins, "and the media is biased toward Muslims. It often paints them in a positive light. What we like about Star Trek is that they just tell it like it is. The show's writers don't tip-toe around the negative facts about Muslim behavior. They don't even try to hide how silly the Muslim religion is, or how Arab people, for the most part, are nothing more than a pack of bloodthirsty dogs, hell-bent on destruction. Star Trek even accurately depicts the Arab language as something that sounds more like a baboon trying to hack up a ball of phlegm than it does someone trying to communicate using words."

Students are coming away from the Sunday school program with fact-based knowledge about Arabs that they can use in the real world. They are excited about what they are learning and are very vocal about it. One student remarked, "Arabs drink wine made from blood, and they are always talking about killing people, and how much they hate everyone else, and how glorious it would be to die in battle. Osama Bin Laden does the same thing, only he doesn't have a funny shaped forehead." Another student argued, "Arabs won't ever change, not even a million years from now. They will always be uncivilized. They eat platters full of live snakes, for crying out loud! Yuck!" Yet another student pointed out, "Even after an Arab like "Worf" was integrated into civilized culture, he still struggles with his basic animal instincts and he has all sorts of stupid religious baggage he can't let go of. I don't see how the rest of the crew can trust him; they act like a bunch of liberals. I'd never turn my back, if I was on that ship."
Studies show that Mullins' Star Trek seminars help keep the short attention span of Christian high school students in check. Students are so interested in the television show, that horseplay during Sunday school has decreased by nearly 87%. Mullins reports that nearly all students attending his classes can successfully answer over 100 complicated questions about Muslim behavior and mating habits after the program is over.
http://www.landoverbaptist.org/news0203/startrek.html
 
Last edited:
You could have at least tried to get some proper formatting into place. And tried to foster some kind of discussion.
 
It's nonsense religious propaganda.

Only an unsaved idiot would have a hard time seeing how obvious it is that Star Trek's, Klingons, are actually Arabs in disguise.

That alone should make it obvious how close minded and pretentious the author is.

Plus, you know, portraying all Arabs as an alien species driven by violence and honor is rather audacious.
 
Horrible, racist claptrap. The comments about Arabs those people make in that quote are disgusting.


EDIT-- Misfit Toy sheds some light on the subject, thankfully.
 
^ ^ Not really Clint - Dark Journey is (as far as I know) correct that TOS Klingons were supposedly based loosely on the Cold War era Soviet Union - for TNG they were reworked and given all that Viking-style honor stuff. I doubt if the comparison was ever direct (though I agree that there are some similarities). Arabs never came into it at all. Your "right-wing Christian site" is just rewriting history to suit its own world view, Bbally.
 
Klingons were intended as a Soviet analogue, but their TOS look was based on Genghis Khan.

In TNG they became a cross between Beserker Vikings and Samurai.

the closest race to Arabs would be the Bajorans - religious, oppressed, living in refugee camps like Palistinians. Although the Bajorans are also reminiscent of the Jews in WWII
 
I've found this site that looks like a right wing Christian site claiming this:

http://www.landoverbaptist.org/news0203/startrek.html

What's the verdict on this? I'm hoping some old school Trek fans could confirm if this is true or not.
It's a joke. The website is a parody.

Well, the joke's on me:alienblush:, sorry for wasting everybody's time.

Oh, that's OK - at least you asked about it before forwarding the link to every human being that you know! ;) If only my sister or one of those other people who are always forwarding me crap would do as much.
 
The OP's story and link are a prime example of equine fecal collection... in context however, it's humorous.


Why humorous? Because Landover Baptist is to church sites what The Onion is to newspaper web sites.
 
Anyone who thinks that the Islamic world -- with its diverse strains of Islam, its numerous ethnicities, and its competing states and organizations -- possesses a uniform culture, let alone a "culture of terror," is not only a bigoted ignoramus, but someone who also does not understand the essential message of Star Trek -- that tolerance and acceptance are better than racism, and that peace is better than conflict, and that mutual respect is better than hegemony or domination.

And, no, Arab culture has never been cited by the creators of Star Trek as an influence upon their depictions of the Klingons. The early Klingons were clearly based on the Soviet Union politically and upon certain European-American-created visual stereotypes of Asians. Later depictions of Klingons were, according to creators, influenced by Viking and Japanese cultures.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top