• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Wear your Classic Who with pride!

All-Seeing I

Commander
Red Shirt
There's no denying it, back in the dying days of the classic series, Dr Who was regarded as a bit of a joke by the general public. And I won't deny that my loyalty wavered briefly during season 24 (although I stuck with it), but most of the time I would defend my favourite show in the face of withering criticism, even in those dark days when being a Dr Who fan could make you a target for ridicule. It wasn't helped when various light entertainment TV shows gleefully presented clips of our favourite show at its most naff and wobbly, usually to the mild embarrassment of their interviewees, past Doctors, companions and guest stars alike. Frazer Hines turn on This Is Your Life comes to mind, and his time on the show is represented by a clip from Tomb of The Cybermen, with Toberman swinging a quite obvious dummy wearing the Cyber-Controller's costume above his head, much to the amusement and derision of Hines' guests. Also, during an interview with Martin Clunes, a clip of him in that admittedly ridiculous Federator's costume is dragged out, a low point in an otherwise quite scary story, with an impressive early performance from Clunes.

I know, I know, move on, I hear you say, but back in those days when you silently squirmed in front of the TV, I bet you too wished that they would select better clips, more representative of the (occasionally) brilliant show we loved so much. It might a performance, a speech, a special effect, or a bit of comedy - something that made you proud to be a Dr Who fan in those wilderness years of the late Eighties, Nineties and early Noughties.

My choices? A few, just off the top of my head: the swoop-in on the Time Lord space station at the start of Trial of a Time Lord; the Doctor's defiant "Worth it" when being threatened with death by the Cyberleader in Silver Nemesis; the third Doctor's 'death' scene; the fifth Doctor's noble sacrifice in Caves of Androzani; the fouth Doctor's and Davros' "Would you do it?" discussion in Genesis of the Daleks; City of Death - too innumerable to mention; Ian and Barbara's first encounter with the Doctor in the Totters Lane junkyard; the second Doctor hopping and jumping and yelling as he runs from Cyber-gun explosions in The Invasion, followed by him posing for a photo in the aftermath, affectedly adjusting his bow-tie; the special weapons Dalek firing its gun for the first time in Remembrance of the Daleks; the reveal of the Valeyard as a future Doctor in Trial of a Time Lord; the Cyberleader calling the Doctor's bluff in Earthshock when threatening Tegan, exposing his compassion as a weakness, and the fourth Doctor's line in The Invasion of Time, after Major Stor of the Special Sontaran Space Service has introduced himself. "The SSSS? Isn't that taking alliteration a little far?"
 
It's a bit sad that it seems to be a bit marginalized these days...In the US, a lot of the old DVDs are out of print for rental or purchase apart from the animated episode reconstructions, and the classic series has pretty much been pulled from a lot of the streaming services as well. I realize that it's kind of hard to upscale or convert the originals to HD/Blu-Ray quality due to most of the series being on video (or some in unfortunately degraded quality), but perhaps as extras on future new series DVD releases? That seems to be what they did with the recent monster compilations ones I think, the Cybermen one came with Earthshock.

I mean there's still a lot of classic series love-Titan's comic series for example, the Big Finish audios etc. and of course the occasional references in the TV show itself. But still it kind of stinks a bit.
 
If they would upconvert (even a little) all the classic episodes and put them on blu-ray (if only for saving space), I would buy them for sure.
The idea of buying 1 episode per DVD was always a big turn-off for me. I only have The Five Doctors and Shada on DVD like that.
 
I don't think it was quite as bad in the US because (one) the show was little-well known outside of the sci-fi community and (two) there was a little more acceptance towards "campy" or low-budget things here at the time. Sure, you couldn't compare the special effects and production values of Doctor Who to something like Star Wars, but I think few did because of the aforementioned reasons back then. Today is a different story, especially since the show's revival.

As a kid watching Doctor Who on my local PBS station in the '80s, the coolest thing wasn't the special effects, but the Doctor himself. Regardless of the incarnation, there was a style he had when facing monsters and bad guys that made him unique and that was what lured me in each week. No guns, no magic powers. All he usually had was his wits (and an occasional fancy screwdriver) to defeat the most nastiest of villains--and usually on their own turf.

Although there were many profound moments in which the Doctor stared down and denounced evil--even while substantially outnumbered and with many weapons aimed at him--the moments that resonated the most with me were ironically the regeneration sequences in which we said good-bye to the a Doctor. A few of those final stories had a somewhat funeral or death-knell tone to them because these were the stories in which we knew the current Doctor wasn't going to survive them--but he still was going to put up the good fight to the end.
 
I think that was actually part of Michael Grade's justification for cancelling the series-that it couldn't compete with American production values and imports.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top