Since it seems clear where this is heading, let's move to -2 and +2
Chakotay (5)
Tuvok (5)
Paris (2) -2
Kim (2)
Kes (1)
Neelix (5)
Samantha Wildman (39) +2
Saved
1. Janeway
2. Seven
3. Be'lanna
4. Seska
5. The Doctor
Least favourite
1. Naomi Wildman
2. Icheb
3. Ayala
4. Chell
5. Vorik
6. Carey
Chakotay (5)
Tuvok (5)
Paris (2) -2
Kim (2)
Kes (1)
Neelix (5)
Samantha Wildman (39) +2
Saved
1. Janeway
2. Seven
3. Be'lanna
4. Seska
5. The Doctor
Least favourite
1. Naomi Wildman
2. Icheb
3. Ayala
4. Chell
5. Vorik
6. Carey