• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll USS Discovery after retrofit

Will Discovery still be recognizable after 32nd century retrofit?

  • Yes, no exterior changes at all

    Votes: 20 27.0%
  • Mostly, few doohickeys attached

    Votes: 25 33.8%
  • More or less, some recognizable elements will remain

    Votes: 25 33.8%
  • No, complete external makeover

    Votes: 4 5.4%

  • Total voters
    74
IMHO, DSC season 3 should never have mentioned ‘V’Draysh’ or Zora. Calypso should have just been its own thing unconnected to anything else.

It could still be its own thing unconnected to anything else.
Think of it as an 'alternate reality' (or 'unrealized reality) that never occurred... although it still could through a number of different ways (if the writers decide to go into that direction - but I suspect they won't and that Calypso may tie into Season 3 or Seaon 4 in a similar - but different capacity.
 
IMHO, DSC season 3 should never have mentioned ‘V’Draysh’ or Zora. Calypso should have just been its own thing unconnected to anything else.
But that's the problem. Nothing can be separated anymore with Star Trek. Everything has to have a reason and be connected to everything else. I would much rather have the little self-contained things, the little mysteries, the things that each viewer's imagination can fill in the blanks with.

But for some reason, everything now needs to be explained or have a reason behind something else.
 
But that's the problem. Nothing can be separated anymore with Star Trek. Everything has to have a reason and be connected to everything else. I would much rather have the little self-contained things, the little mysteries, the things that each viewer's imagination can fill in the blanks with.

But for some reason, everything now needs to be explained or have a reason behind something else.
Calypso has no reason to be. It is the best example of a "bottle show" within the current format. There is no reason to try to peg it in to current stories beyond brief references. It just is.
 
Calypso has no reason to be. It is the best example of a "bottle show" within the current format. There is no reason to try to peg it in to current stories beyond brief references. It just is.
I agree with you. However, there has been an increasing need to tie everything together with everything else with Star Trek, so at some point someone is going to manufacture a link to it, probably a lame one, just for the sake of explaining every single thing that happens in Star Trek.
 
I agree with you. However, there has been an increasing need to tie everything together with everything else with Star Trek, so at some point someone is going to manufacture a link to it, probably a lame one, just for the sake of explaining every single thing that happens in Star Trek.
Indeed, yes, and it is unfortunate.
 
I agree with you. However, there has been an increasing need to tie everything together with everything else with Star Trek, so at some point someone is going to manufacture a link to it, probably a lame one, just for the sake of explaining every single thing that happens in Star Trek.

Because loud segments of the fan base whine like babies if they don’t.
 
The ship's name is Enterprise. It has no letter designation after it. The registry number has the letter.

Wrong, actually.

We've heard other Enterprises referred to by name and letter (such as the C and D in "Yesterday's Enterprise"). This is just one more example of that.

It's just that normally this doesn't come into play because we rarely see two ships with the same name together. But when we do, the name includes the letter.
 
Wrong, actually.

We've heard other Enterprises referred to by name and letter (such as the C and D in "Yesterday's Enterprise"). This is just one more example of that.

It's just that normally this doesn't come into play because we rarely see two ships with the same name together. But when we do, the name includes the letter.
Not wrong. Look at the name on the ship's hull. Does the name "U.S.S. Enterprise" contain a letter after it?

In conversation it will, on the registry it won't.
 
^ Ah, but you just said the ship's name "has no letter designation after it". If it ever comes up in conversation, which you also admitted it does, then it DOES.

Maybe not on the damn hull, but if it comes up anywhere at all, the end result is the same.
 
^ Ah, but you just said the ship's name "has no letter designation after it". If it ever comes up in conversation, which you also admitted it does, then it DOES.

Maybe not on the damn hull, but if it comes up anywhere at all, the end result is the same.
No, I agree with you, but I was only pointing out that the hull doesn't have it. The damn hull.
 
Anyway- controversial Star Trek opinions: Season 7 of DS9 was just as good as the rest of the series. Just finished my first full series rewatch in a decade and I thoroughly enjoyed it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top