dont confuse my two ideas, the Jackson Lake idea is a one or two parter.Wamdue, I'm sure we'd have heard by now if David Morrissey were going to be a (semi-)regular in Who.
The *cough*Farscape*cough* idea is part of a series long arc.
Two Doctor's(series 6 spoiler)
- Thread starter Samurai8472
- Start date
The *cough*Farscape*cough* idea is part of a series long arc.
The Tardis has a baby Tardis? It's a machine, mon
. And how does the Doctor get cloned? And why would some aliens mistake Jackson Lake for the Doctor? Why would any of this happen? If the Doctor got cloned and couldn't tell which was the real him, then surely they'd be exact clones and the idea of a real him becomes less meaningful. So why wouldn't one regenerate? And would each identical Doctor really go "fair enough, let's split; one can go off with River and one with Pond" rather than sort it out? I'm not getting it. The Tardis and the Doctor effectively each get cloned for some strange reasons, and each end up traveling and...Still, RTD came up with worse.
The Tardis has a baby Tardis? It's a machine, mon
Still, RTD came up with worse.
ok can I just be clear about this
I aplogise I should have been more clear.
As you your questions
Idea 1, I was me making a small refrence to Farscape, which also had a clone of its lead character for a series, splitting the crew across two ships.
and Jackson Lake, would be cloned, as he is mistaken for the Doctor, after all he was running around London pretending to be the Doctor. Think about it, the Doctor is a man of many faces, it is very possible that history could record a man pretending to be the Doctor, as a real Doctor. Even someone like Captain Jack could not say for sure, he isnt a future regeneration of the Doctor.
Or past, for that matter. The Jack abandoned on the GameStation, resurrected, and then stranded in the 1880s wouldn't likely know which Doctor followed which. As the decades passed and he started tracking the Doctors' comings and goings in England, he still might not have enough to work out an order. How is Jack to know that Hartnell precedes Eccleston?
I worked out an outline for a Who/Torchwood novel that followed Jack and the amnesiac eighth Doctor from the EDAs across the decades and how their paths crossed. It's utter fanwank, and there's absolutely no reason anyone would want to read it and BBC Books wouldn't ever buy it so there's no reason to ever write it.
it is possible that as a Time Agent, Jack would have been briefed on the Doctor, and his faces, but even that would probaly be second hand information, and may not have been correct.
I bet Sarah Jane would struggle to put the Doctors in order.
^ The Atraxi seemed to have a pretty good idea of the order, assuming that was their own information and not read from the Doctor's mind.
Ahhh! (facepalm) I'm not doing too well am I?
unclear where the Atraxi go there Doctor montage, possibly from his mind.
Also the Cybermans info stamp had it correct, I always figured they got at least some of that information from Torchwood Tower, someone is more likely to have it right.
You cant assume that every alien species, and other group of Doctor Who hunters or fanboys will have enough knowledge to get it right, L.I.N.D.A. , had differnt theories for the Doctor.
Am I the only one who noticed that article referred to the mysterious big bad as "The Silents" as opposed to "The Silence" which we've known it as?
I have to love the intelligence of people in the fan community. I'm not intending to flame the OP as much as give him a bit of a kick in the backside. And other fan forums and venues are also guilty of this so I'm not picking on one person.
But if you're going to start a thread about a major spoiler? Don't put the ******* spoiler in the subject header, huh? Jeez.
Alex
But if you're going to start a thread about a major spoiler? Don't put the ******* spoiler in the subject header, huh? Jeez.
Alex
They got it from the Daleks
I thought that, but then it's so ridiculous that if it actually happens I might give up watching anyway.
I assumed something similar.
Namely that the OP had just awoken from a coma they'd been in since late 1984.
Of course, this raises the question of how they knew enough about the internet to post a thread about it here.
But I quickly decided to ignore what I felt was a pretty minor flaw in an otherwise impeccable hypothesis.
no, i noticed that too. added to my confidence it was total sphericals.
oh, i hope they do it now...
I assumed something similar.
Namely that the OP had just awoken from a coma they'd been in since late 1984.
Of course, this raises the question of how they knew enough about the internet to post a thread about it here.
But I quickly decided to ignore what I felt was a pretty minor flaw in an otherwise impeccable hypothesis.
I just thought they were making a Matt Smith episode that was a sequel to that one, but I like your version better.
You petty man.
Yeah I have to say I agree!
Dak, two Matt Smith's is unacceptable...I demand two Amys! (At least one of which should be in her WPC outfit!)
Similar threads
