Troi or Crusher
- Thread starter indycar
- Start date
I liked both but I preferred Deanna Troi. Her centric episodes tended to be dull but as part of the ensemble cast I liked her. She's probably the nicest character in the entire Star Trek universe and we share a devotion to chocolate.
Beverly Crusher didn't get that much development as a character until the last few seasons but I liked her as part of the ensemble too. She had a few centric episodes that I really liked and worked well as a command officer.
Beverly Crusher didn't get that much development as a character until the last few seasons but I liked her as part of the ensemble too. She had a few centric episodes that I really liked and worked well as a command officer.
I liked Crusher more, Troi is more interesting. I enjoyed the episode where Troi loses her powers and she ain't happy.
Troi is super sexy.
I voted for Crusher but I love both. Troi is so nice and she does add to episodes [despite the 'stating the obvious' jokes].
However, I really like Dr Crusher. She is so warm and I wish they had done more with her [particularly a romance with Picard]. I enjoy Bev centred episodes and I think she adds an interesting dynamic to the show.
However, I really like Dr Crusher. She is so warm and I wish they had done more with her [particularly a romance with Picard]. I enjoy Bev centred episodes and I think she adds an interesting dynamic to the show.
I prefer Crusher. I think her strident humanitarianism contributed more to the moral center of the series than Troi. Troi was good in ensemble scenes but she was usually used as a widget to state the obvious.
I like both, but if I have to choose I think Troi is more interesting.
Dr Crusher is my favourite TNG character so definitely her.
Ditto.
You gotta go Crusher. Doctor and aspiring play-write? Love it. Deanna always got on my nerves. I love her mom, though.
I'd like to quote this as it's a great point. Sometimes Crusher was a dissenting voice in a sea of harmony on the Ent-D. She would frequently emphasise situations from a humanitarian standpoint [and she wasn't always 'right'] and I felt that added something to the show. Some might argue Troi did the exact same but I think she differed slightly and wasn't as beligerent.
I preferred Troi - but mainly after she started wearing a regular uniform, and in other episodes that took her out of her comfort zone, like the episode where she woke up in the Tal Shiar.
I really wish they had kept her original character concept as a different kind of counselor - more of a political officer.
I really wish they had kept her original character concept as a different kind of counselor - more of a political officer.
I took it to be about their characters, but it seems to have been left open enough that if you want to regard it as a beauty contest, then I think that's fine, too - unless the OP wishes to clarify otherwise?
Similar threads
