• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TOS Enterprise - need opinions on 3D model (picture heavy)

lomitus

Lieutenant
Red Shirt
This is a re-post from the TOS section of the forum...I thank everyone for their comments and my apologies for posting to the wrong forum.

_________________________


Greetings one and all!
I'm new to the forums here, so please forgive me for jumping in like this, however I could use a few opinions.

I'm a digital artist and my interests include photography, music, vector work and 3D modeling & animation. I'm working on a 3D animation of the TOS Enterprise...this is actually my second Enterprise animation and the 3rd version of the ship I've created. This little project is mainly for my own amusement as well as learning and practice (I use Autodesk's Maya, so I'm ALWAYS learning, LOL). This new animation is not only going to include the Enterprise herself, but a second ship, the U.S.S. Hathor (Saladin Class Destroyer), the shuttlecraft Galileo and space station K-7 (although I'm still debating that part of the project).

To come to the point here, I could use some "educated" eyes to look over my model of Enterprise. I do have similar posts going in 3D modeling forums regarding geometry, lighting and renderings questions, however I could also use the help of some folks who KNOW Trek. I know we Trekkies (or Trekkers, whichever you prefer) can be a persnickety lot when it comes to details and such...which is exactly what I need.

On that note - please don't feel as though you need to know 3D modeling or anything. If you do, GREAT, if not...it's not important for my needs here. My main concern is if I missed any details regarding this ship herself.

Likewise, please be aware that this is a "mixed era" rendition of the Enterprise...she's not intended to specifically represent Pilot I, Pilot II, etc., as much as simply my idealized vision of this grand lady.

As such, I'm attaching some othergraphic views of the model, as well as a couple of beauty shots...the lighting and rendering are pretty basic in (most of) these shots. Basically I'm just concerned with the details of the ship here. For the sake of reference, this model is created from a variety of reference material including (but not limited to) TOS blueprints, my AMT model kits, stills from the show...and a slight degree of artistic license (such as the running lights and body textures). I am still tweaking a few things...still playing with the textures a bit, need to tweak down those bussard's a bit, need to rig the shuttlebay doors for animation, etc., and I hope to be upping my game when it comes render time...so now is the time to be looking for anything I may have missed.

Again I would like to emphasis that this project is strictly for my own amusement and learning experience. I mean absolutely no infringement of intellectual property here...at most, this should simply be considered as "fan art" and nothing more.

So with no further adieu, I give you my all new 2016 version of the U.S.S. Enterprise...


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%20ortho%20side%20-%2001a.png


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%20ortho%20top%20-%2001a.png


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%20ortho%20bottom%20-%2001a.png


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%20ortho%20front%20-%2001a.png


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%20ortho%20back%20-%2001a.png


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%20beauty%20shot%2001a.png


Enterprise%20Test%2003%20-%2001a%20AC.png



I'm grateful for any comments, opinions or suggestions...I'm not a kid and I have very little ego left to bruise (my wife beat it out of me years ago, LOL!), so please feel free to give my work here a brutally honest critique if you'd like! If I missed something or you think something doesn't look right, please lemme know!

Thanks!
 
Looks like your off to a great start, I see that the bussards and formation lights need some toning down a bit but I'm not a modeler or texturer. Keep at it :techman::techman::techman:
 
Oh, they moved your first thread here, you didn't need to start a whole new one. A Moderator will likely close this one.

--Alex
 
Oh, they moved your first thread here, you didn't need to start a whole new one. A Moderator will likely close this one.

--Alex


Yea, I had re-posted before I realized it was moved. If any of the moderators happen to read this, please feel free to delete THIS version of the thread, as the other version has some very useful info in (both for myself, as well as anyone else who may be interested in such things)...thanks!
 
A few quick things:

I think the nacelles are too low. The round front part from is usually more visible from the front of the ship.
The little rectangular attachments at the bottom of the front of the nacelles look a bit small.
The side rectangles on the sides near the deflector seem to be coming out sideways too much.
The rear light of the shuttle deck bay is usually only at the top with nothing below.
The round deck above the light on the bottom of the primary hull should have some stuff sticking out of it (for phasers).
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top