• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

To those who own the HD-DVD sets...

Dar70 said:
Plum said:
Wait... let me get this straight. Some poor slob buys Season 1 of TOS Remastered, which is only available in HD-TV, and now he's told everything will be Blue-Ray in the future?

Just wanna be clear here.


That seems to be the case. Really though, they arent poor slobs. Everyone knew it was a crapshoot from the beginning to side with one format. So no one should really be angry or bitter.
Exactly. People knew what they were getting into. I don't want to say I told you so, but I'm glad I didn't choose sides; of course, had I chosen sides, I would have still chosen Blu-Ray, but that's irrelevant.
 
O'Realy? Everyone knew? O'really? Though, I get your point, let the buyer beware.
 
like I stated before..it matters not a whit..there are combo players available for HD DVD and Blu-ray...that's what I'm gettin..


format war..who gives a tinker's damn..
 
goldbug said:
like I stated before..it matters not a whit..there are combo players available for HD DVD and Blu-ray...that's what I'm gettin..

Why? HD-DVD is a dead format. If you don't already have discs that use it, why bother getting a player that does? You're not seriously saying you're going to BUY discs for a format you know is dead, are you?

I am damn sure getting rid of my HD-DVD player as soon as certain films, such as Apollo 13 and Transformers, come out in Blu-Ray.
 
Babaganoosh said:
goldbug said:
like I stated before..it matters not a whit..there are combo players available for HD DVD and Blu-ray...that's what I'm gettin..

Why? HD-DVD is a dead format. If you don't already have discs that use it, why bother getting a player that does? You're not seriously saying you're going to BUY discs for a format you know is dead, are you?

I am damn sure getting rid of my HD-DVD player as soon as certain films, such as Apollo 13 and Transformers, come out in Blu-Ray.
Not to mention the fact that combo players will (are?) likely a couple hundred dollars more expensive than a stand alone Blu-Ray player.
 
Anyone who did any research knew Blu was going to win the war by the Spring of 07.

Hd-DVD got a few months of life support by buying Paramount/Dreamworks. Had things developed naturally the war would've been over before xmas.
 
Maybe its a pipe dream, butttt...wouldn't it be great if the Blu-Ray version, when they recode it, offered up two versions? One would be the wholly redone eps we've been seeing piecemeal in syndie. The second would be a more restrained remastering : Just strings, obvious doubles, and like that removed, with maybe cartoony phasers retraced just a bit. As Spock would be like to say :"Just because one can do something, it does not always follow that one should."
 
Babaganoosh said:
goldbug said:
like I stated before..it matters not a whit..there are combo players available for HD DVD and Blu-ray...that's what I'm gettin..

Why? HD-DVD is a dead format. If you don't already have discs that use it, why bother getting a player that does? You're not seriously saying you're going to BUY discs for a format you know is dead, are you?

I am damn sure getting rid of my HD-DVD player as soon as certain films, such as Apollo 13 and Transformers, come out in Blu-Ray.

So you're gonna buy those disks again?..if you already have HD DVD disks (as I have) then a combo player makes economic sense due to the expense of RE-PURCHASING the Blu-ray disks for HD DVDs you already own..
 
goldbug said:
Babaganoosh said:
goldbug said:
like I stated before..it matters not a whit..there are combo players available for HD DVD and Blu-ray...that's what I'm gettin..

Why? HD-DVD is a dead format. If you don't already have discs that use it, why bother getting a player that does? You're not seriously saying you're going to BUY discs for a format you know is dead, are you?

I am damn sure getting rid of my HD-DVD player as soon as certain films, such as Apollo 13 and Transformers, come out in Blu-Ray.

So you're gonna buy those disks again?..if you already have HD DVD disks (as I have) then a combo player makes economic sense due to the expense of RE-PURCHASING the Blu-ray disks for HD DVDs you already own..

Two problems with that: 1) I have not heard good things about either of the combo players on the market (the LG or the Samsung). 2) If I can get all my movies on Blu-Ray, which I eventually will, then why bother supporting any other format? Sony makes a great Blu-Ray player, and someday that'll be all I'll need.
 
We have a Toshiba HD/DVD player; it plays regular DVD's just fine, and the HD/DVD's look wonderful.
 
Mike Farley said:
bryce said:

I noticed that in the remastered "Trouble With Tribbles" canteen scene, that now the Klingon hit first.

And, of course, throughout the entirety of the remastered episodes, all phasers have been replaced with communicators

Nazis and tribesmen have been replaced by Ewoks too :p
 
I have season one in HD-DVD and a Toshiba HD-DVD player. Now it looks like I will need a PS3 for seasons 2 & 3.
 
Are you kidding? Its good times right now for HD owners.

I just bought a 1080p player at Best Buy for $119.00. This player also upconverts regular DVDs to great quality. I also got 2 free movies in the box, 2 in the store and a mail in rebate for 5 free movies. These movies were retailing at $29 each..and still are for blu-ray...not to mention the cheapest blu-ray player is still $399. That's just too much money. It won't be long before the basic HD players will be available for $50. That's when I'll pick up a back-up.

Also, with Toshiba pulling the plug, retail outlets and online stores are blowing out their HD inventory left and right. Trek season 1 can now be had for as little as $79 if you shop around. Hollywood Video is selling off HD movies 2 for $20. Amazon and Deep Discount is selling HD titles for 50-65% off. Blu-ray won, and as an HD owner, I couldn't be happier! But it's getting crazy...I'm almost to the point where I can't afford to save any more money!!
:beer:
 
I'm still on the fence whether to dump the few HD-DVD's I have and the player (take the money hit) and go all Blu-Ray. Or just hang on to it all for now. My TV does have plenty of HDMI inputs.
 
I'm still on the fence whether to dump the few HD-DVD's I have and the player (take the money hit) and go all Blu-Ray. Or just hang on to it all for now. My TV does have plenty of HDMI inputs.

You won't be able to sell your existing player and movies for enough to re-buy them on blu-ray so you might just look at picking up a cheap player (many can be had for under $99 now) for a future HD back-up and just keep what you have. Then you can continue to enjoy it with the peace of mind of knowing you won't have to buy all the movies again at the higher Blu-ray cost when you pick up a blu-ray down the road.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top