• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 7x19 - "Genesis"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
Genesis.png


Yeah, yeah, another long break. I’ve got things going on, okay!

We cold-open in sickbay where Nurse Ogawa is treating Riker for injuries he received while making out with a subordinate in arboretum and he rolled over onto an alien cactus that skewered his back. Ouch! And, jeeze, Riker! Take that stuff to the holodeck!

We slip past that and watch as Barclay neuroses his way with Crusher complete with his own diagnosis he got from WebMD:24c Edition, I ask again why this guy isn’t medicated or something. People with various personality and nervous/social orders today can get help and be put on medication that allows them to lead a regular life. Now, sure, depending on the healthcare status of the area you live in it may be hard to get that treatment, or psychological disorders may not be treated as seriously; but here we’re in the 24th century. Put the guy on some Valium or something.

It appears to be a busy day in the sickbay as Ogawa switches between dealing with Riker and another patient, a background staff person deals with yet another patient and while Crusher deals with Barclay Data comes in carrying his cat, Spot.

It seems at some point in the last few episodes/seasons/whatever Spot had a gender-identity crisis that was identified and treated including giving spot a uterus implant to allow him to be completely female. Because, you see, Data’s cat previously referred to with male pronouns is pregnant. Data has come in to have Spot given a check-up because he, ahem, SHE seems to be showing early signs of getting ready to give birth. Crusher, whose job duties extend into the veterinary field, confirms that Spot will be giving birth soon, Nurse Ogawa also chooses this moment to reveal she is also pregnant and Data offers to give advice to Ogawa because watching over a pregnant transgendered cat Is the same thing as offering help to a pregnant female human or offering insights to her human(oid) husband.

A diagnostic test Crusher set-up for Barclay completes and she looks over the results still WebMDing his concerns (Valium, seriously. And maybe block some websites on the guy’s log-in) and she diagnoses him with having some alien form of the flu. This form most humans are immune to but that gene in Barclay is dormant so she gives him a hypospray shot that should activate that dormant gene and allow his own immune system to fight off the virus naturally. Which…. Isn’t how viruses work, exactly, people can and DO die from the flu without some form of treatment and is generally why vaccinations are suggested and seeing a doctor early when you have symptoms. But, whatever, futuristic T-Cells.

Sometime later the Enterprise is conducting tests on some upgraded weapons systems in an asteroid field, they launch a volley of torpedoes and while two of them strike their targets one of them veers off course. They attempt to remotely detonate the torpedo but cannot make contact with it, it goes out of range precluding them from tracking it or hitting it with phasers so it’s decided to chase after it.

Data warns that the asteroid field is unusually dense (well, unusually dense for an asteroid field in a sci-fi setting) so the Enterprise cannot go after it herself. Picard decides he and Data will take a shuttle to chase down the torpedo; before leaving he admonishes Worf for the torpedo’s failure.

Before leaving, Data checks in with Spot leaving her in the trust of Barclay as other crew members have had poor encounters with Spot, Barclay is surprised and honored by Data’s request and seems to be one of the few Spot takes kindly too, and Barclay reciprocates showing himself to be a true cat lover, even being able to deduce where Spot has picked to give birth. (The Spot Spot, if you will.) It’s actually a nice little scene with Barclay. I give the character a hard time but Dwight Shultz does do a good job with him and the character is enjoyable.

Data and Picard depart the ship via shuttle.

As soon as they are away things appear to already go wrong on the ship, Worf is going over the torpedo system and having bursts of frustration and anger causing him to be relieved by Riker. We next see Worf in Ten-Forward tearing into a plate of food filled with various greenery, turkey legs and octopus tentacles. He’s eating into the dish savagely like, well, a Klingon but usually Worf tends to have table manners more on par with humans. Troi wanders up to him upset that they’d agreed to have lunch together, Worf yells that he is hungry. Troi carries with her a glass of water which she soon empties, and for lunch she orders a double-order of caviar. Worf questions this, and Troi says she’s in the mood for something salty and then questions if the environmental system is faulty because the air in the ship feels dry. As the caviar arrives Worf, in an almost animalistic way, leers at the chest of the server and then leers at Troi as she eats her caviar with a spoon like it’s ice cream.

She thinks Worf is under stress and recommends he takes it easy, he agrees and storms off. “Not now,” Troi muses to herself as she continues into the caviar and a server brings her a fresh glass of water, which Troi eagerly drinks from.

That night Worf rouses from a slumber with a roar, the soundtrack takes on a great eerie tone with drum beats in it to represent the pounding of Worf’s heart. He climbs out of bed and darts around his quarters seemingly exploring it like an animal in a cage, he collects a few items and spills them on the floor; he then goes to his mattress, rips it open and pulls out some of the padding inside of it dumps it on the floor in a pile; he curls up almost like a fetus in his improvised “nest.”

The next day in Engineering Geordi, Riker and Barclay are going over the weapon system problems, or something or another, and Barclay is rambling on about his diagnosis of the problem like Neil deGrasse Tyson on crack; he speaks so fast Geordi has trouble keeping up with him but Riker shows much more of a struggle as he shakes his head in confusion looking over the problem on PADD and tells them to just get to work. An alert comes up which Barclay quick identifies and runs off with equipment to work on it, Geordi follows.

On the Bridge, the helmsman seems to struggle at his console as Troi rocks and, twitches, and stirs in the captain’s chair, rubbing her arms as if she’s cold. She gives the computer an order to raise the temperature on the bridge, as well as the humidity. Worf circumvents the order and tells the computer to return everything to normal. You’d think the computer would know who is in charge and who to listen to. Deanna orders the computer to reinstate her orders, she sits there for another moment before disgustedly saying she feels she needs a bath; she leaves the bridge to Worf and walks off.

In a Jefferies Tube Barclay and Geordi come up on the problem, which Barclay quickly gets to work on, Geordi acts tired and exhausted but notes the problem was caused by an corrosive organic material of unknown origin. Barclay says he’ll look into it and tears off as Geordi slumps to rest in the tube.

On the bridge the helmsman reports that Starfleet wants a report on the new weapon systems, Riker doesn’t seem to understand the question. The drum beats of heart palpitations start up again as Riker thinks up an answer.

Troi is in the tub in her steamy quarters, bathing in her uniform no less, as Worf enters and orders her out of the tub. She refuses to get out and attempts to drink a glass of water when Worf attacks her, biting her on the cheek.

We cut to sickbay where Troi is being treated on a bio bed, shivering under her futuristic shimmery sheet. Ogawa notes other crewmembers have complained about temperature (in both directions), Crusher orders for Ogawa to contact the other doctors on the ship as it seems a viral infection if on the ship. Oddly, of note, she’s not healed the bite wound on Troi’s cheek. |

She goes over to deal with Worf who is being watched over by a security officer, he walks off as Crusher begins asking Worf about any symptoms he doesn’t respond to her questions, nor does he seem to even understand her. She attempts to begin the test when she notices two sacs on either side of his jaw, as she begins to inspect them closer and (quite stupidly) stands right in front of Worf and asks him to open his mouth. As he does, a spray violently erupts from his mouth and hits crusher in the face.

In a chilling performance from either McFadden or a stunt double she lets out a terrifying scream, covers her face and begins writhing violently on the floor in pain. Worf runs off as Ogawa and others rush over to treat Crusher.

A tense music sting takes us to the next scene where Ogawa briefs Riker on Crusher’s status, she was put in stasis before the paralytic effects of the venom could take effect. She needs reconstructive surgery but otherwise should be fine. Ogawa uses her fists a lot for indication and takes on a more ape-like posture.

Barclay, still speaking quickly in a higher pitched voice, reports that the venom from Worf was similar to acidic compound found in the Jefferies Tube.

Riker continues to struggle with the big words and focus his concentration as Barclay hovers over him menacingly, Ogawa thinks a serious infection is on the ship. Geordi arrives, strangely symptom free, and says the sensors struggle to track Worf and recommends a higher security alert. Riker, really struggling, goes along with it mostly by prodding Geordi into making the call.

As everyone is dismissed, Geordi walks off…. Normally. Barclay rushes out the door quickly and Ogawa pushes herself up from a seated position using her fists, pushing herself along the table a bit before walking towards the door with a slightly mannish stance.

Riker begins to ask the computer to send out the security/emergency call for Starfleet but cannot think of the security codes when the computer asks for them.

On the shuttlecraft three days have passed between now and the shuttle’s departure. Data and Picard have recovered the torpedo and headed home but the Enterprise is not at the pre-arranged coordinates. Scanning the area, they find the ship two light-years away. Which, good, given the shuttle is limited to full impulse, which means the shuttle will get there, going full impulse, in about 8 years.

Luckily they slip through a wormhole between locations because they come upon the ship shortly and find it adrift in a lateral spin. They cannot identify any specific lifeforms on the ship, though there are life signs. They match the ship’s spin and manually dock the shuttle.

(In one of those “geek moments” that bothers me we see the warp engines of the ship a glow which you’d think they’d be off if the ship’s gone several days without the warp engines being maintained; an automatic shutdown you’d think would have occurred.)

Inside the darkened, messy, shuttlebay Picard and Data try and to get information on the ship but find main power offline and need to get to the bridge to get the info they need. On their way in a corridor they hear various animal noises around them and come across a sheet of shed skin. Data notes no species on the ship sheds skin in such a manner. Later, they pass by Counselor Troi’s quarters which has condensation on the exterior of the door jamb. They go inside to find more condensation on the walls and a foggy/steamy atmosphere to the room. Picard notes the environmental changes.

They enter Troi’s bathroom and find her lying motionless in her filled tub; when Picard lifts her out she reacts strangely, not speaking or seeming to notice what’s going on around her. Data scans her and Picard notes the changes in her appearance, which is more amphibian including the ability to metabolize water and air for oxygen. Fundamentally, Data notes, she’s no longer human. Well, Data, actually…

They also note she’s been bitten and the bite wound contains Klingon DNA. They continue to the bridge to get the ship under control and to investigate.

On the bridge the helmsman is dead in his chair behind the exploded console, Data notes the helmsman also shows signs of the DNA change but appears to have been killed by an animal before any change could take hold. At his console Data finds there’s 1,011 life forms throughout the ship, that of the Enterprise population and it’s all transformed into more animalistic signs. The signs are scattered around the ship, though there’s concentrations in the arboretum and aquatics bay.

Picard regains attitude control of the ship but they still cannot regain main power, they interrupted by a series of noises coming from the Ready Room.

Inside they find Riker, looking like an early ancestor to humans, pacing around the room trying to get inside the Picard’s aquarium, now housing a jellyfish, they attempt to communicate with him on some level but the smaller brain of the proto-human cannot understand them and he begins to attack. Data knocks him out with a phaser and continues his scans.

Later, in sickbay has gone over Riker, Troi and other crewmembers and his reached a conclusion on what is happening and this is where we have to pick our boots up.

Somehow a virus on the ship is spreading which is activating dormant T-Cells in the DNA of the crew, these reactivated T-Cells are causing dormant genes in the crew to “de-evolve” into earlier forms of life related to their home worlds.
 
Last edited:
Here’s the problem individuals do not evolve! Species evolve over a long, long, time that evolutionary process guided by the needs and wills of the surrounding environment for the subject. Evolution has no set path backwards or forwards. While there’s a slight genetic connection between all life on Earth there’s nothing to “mutate” a person, humans being mammals, into, say, an amphibious creature. There’s not *that* much in common between the two. It’s often said how much DNA a person has in common with other animals, like Dolphins, but a 1% difference is enough to go from an aquatic mammal without arms or legs and is seemingly unable to learn, think and create to being the dominant species on the planet that’s created a living, breathing, advanced civilization.

This problem goes even further when we find Barclay has “de-evolved” into a spider. There’s not enough “dormant information” in our genetic code to turn a human being into a completely different class of life. There may be dormant cells but not all of the information needed to turn a human being into a completely different animal like an arachnid.

And even if it were possible it certainly wouldn’t happen over the course of a few days. It takes the human body the better part of 7 years to completely remake itself. Organs, bone structure, skin, everything. So if you were to change your DNA it’d take 7 years for that change to happen and then we have immune systems for the expressed purpose of getting rid of foreign DNA which is why people who receive organ transplants have to take immune suppressants to prevent the immune system from rejecting the organ made of foreign material.

Look, there’s suspension of disbelief that allows you to accept warp-travel, transporters and sentient androids. There’s turning your brain off to accept an entire, massive, race of cybernetic humanoids intent on taking over the galaxy. But then there’s just plain stupidity that one absent minded shot from Crusher sets loose a virus that causes a human being to “de-evolve” into a spider. For me, that’s too much and one of the problems I have with this episode.

The other problem is how… “well behaved” these animals all seem to have been. Consider that they don’t have the capacity to ask the replicators for food and there’s not exactly and abundance of wild animals running around the ship and animals hardly have the capacity to think “well, I’ll eat tomorrow. NBD.” Why has only or two people on the ship died? Shouldn’t there be a much greater loss of life? Shouldn’t more vulnerable life forms have been killed by the carnivorous crew members like the children? Or, say, a blind animal?!

The last problem(s) we’ll get to later.

Data notes how Picard is also “infected” by this virus and has already began to change and has 12 hours before the beginning changes start. Data suspects Picard will also “de-evolve” into an earlier form of primate like a lemur.

This can “almost” make sense that a human being would “de-evolve” into some form of primate considering we evolved from a form of ape. But…. Why did Barclay “de-evolve” into a spider? Why didn’t he de-evolve into a primate? Riker de-evolved into a caveman, Ogawa de-evolved into some form of ape, why did Troi de-evolve into an amphibious/lizard creature? She’s half human, sure, but from what we see of Betazoids it’s not too much of a stretch to assume they also evolved from an ape-like animal in their distant past.

And, okay, Riker de-evolves into a proto-human who’s said to have a thicker cranial plate and a much smaller brain. Isn’t this devastating to him? If they can restore him to a normal physical form, great, but how do you regain that lost information from the brain material that was lost and now regained? There’s no way he just “regrew” the knowledge, experiences, memories, and other neural connections in the parts of the brain lost and regained. Stuff like this is what makes this episode utterly stupid for me.

It has a great atmosphere to it, the cast does a great job of acting as the animalistic forms and there’s even good make-up work done. But the episode is wrecked by this attempt at an explanation. It would have been better if the cause of it wasn’t ever revealed beyond “something alien” rather than suggesting just some shot from a hypospray is all that stands between 1014 normal people and 1014 animals of various types. And if the episode somehow reasoned and justified the animalistic changes somehow preserving the person/brain inside. Remove the mentions of proto-Riker’s thicker skull and smaller brain and you’ve got it. Say, “his brain is intact, but it’d seem the connections between it and the rest of his body is preventing him from acting in a usual manner. I believe he may not even be fully aware of us, in effect making him completely proto-human.”

Data and Picard begin to work on a way to reverse the process, the main computer has been damaged but for some reason the computer in Data’s quarters has an independent computer core. Which? Why not?! Why even make that excuses necessary? Would we really have been questioning things if the computer happened to be working?

In Data’s quarters they hear the meowing of baby kittens, which Data notes. They find “Spot” in her birthing spot behind a chair. Spot has changed, completely, into and iguana, while the kittens are perfectly normal. Oddly, the omnivore iguana Spot, in a situation of being short on food resources, hasn’t eaten the kittens. (Though, maybe iguanas are predatory in their food search or “Spot” realized she was still the kitten’s mother or incapable of eating the kittens? You’d think in a hunger situation she’d go for it.

Data concludes the kittens were immune to the “T-Cell” virus due to being Spot’s womb when the outbreak occurred (this immunity extending past when the kittens were birthed and removed themselves from the placenta) reasoning that the womb is designed to protect offspring from cases like this. Because offspring never gets infected by the diseases that infect the parent.

Data thinks he can create a “cure” for this T-Cell virus using a pregnant humanoid like Nurse Ogawa. They decide to go in search for her when the ship rocks due to a warp greeble. They go there first to fix things.

Man, from the shuttlebay on Deck 13 in the secondary hull, to Troi’s quarters on Deck 9, to the Bridge on Deck 1, to Data’s quarters on Deck 2 or 3, to Sickbay on 12 in the saucer, to deck 36 for main engineering. They’re just all over the place considering the turbolifts can’t be working that well.

Data fixes the problem at the master system display while Picard goes to check on the warp core in the Chief Engineer’s office. While in finds the room filled with shredded cotton Halloween “spider web” decorations and he’s soon jump-scared by an arachnid Barclay jump against the observation window.

He shouts for Data, who quickly arrives and calms Picard, noting the flight-or-flight instincts of Picard’s animal transformation may be beginning to assert itself since small animals often have heighten awareness of predatory carnivores…. and spiders.

The problem fixed they return to sickbay (back to Deck 12!) but not before going to the arboretum (Deck 17) to get Nurse Ogawa!

A sleeping, apish/primate, Ogawa is analyzed by Data and he finds that her embryo is unaffected by the T-Cell virus. He believes he can extract some and synthesize a retro-virus. It shouldn’t take long but the sickbay computer needs to be gotten back online.

Suddenly there’s a series of knocks and bangs on one of the sickbay doors, Data uses a tricorder to determine it’s a very large animal with Klingon DNA. Worf.

He’s banging on Sickbay’s door -causing dents in it with his forehead ridges- wanting to get inside. Data is uncertain a phaser will be effective in stunning him and a higher setting could harm him. They try to think of a way to lure him away from sickbay but are unsure how until they recall the bite on Troi.

They surmise the bite may not have been done to harm Troi but to “mark” her as a mate to ward off others. Proto-Klingon Worf is acting on an instinct to protect his mate -based on her pheromones rather than wanting to fuck a completely different species. Data’s able to synthesize a stronger form of Troi’s pheromones and plans to use them to lure Worf away, but Picard offers to go so Data can work on the cure. Data is uncertain of Picard’s safety, but Picard assures him he’ll be fine.

Picard leaves through another sickbay exit and begins spraying, via hypospray, the pheromones in the air which leads the Proto-Klingon Worf away and to pursue Picard.

In effect, Proto-Worf is chasing Picard through the ship because he smells like Troi and Worf wants to fuck him.

We see the Proto-Klingon Worf and, again, it’s great make-up and costume design by the show’s staff (but also of note the dents from Worf’s ridges aren’t on the outside protion of the door)

Picard runs down a corridor continuing to spray the pheromone as Worf runs in pursuit. Picard reaches a T-junction and sprays the pheromone down two of the paths and goes down the third. Worf reaches the junction and looks around in confusion for a moment before seeing Picard trying to enter a turbolift.

Inside the turbolift car Picard attempts to order it to another deck but it doesn’t respond (I guess some of the turbolifts were working?) he manages to use the panel to shut the doors before Worf can get to him and then uses the hard-to-reach tubolift escape hatch to get out of the car, dropping his phaser and the pheromone spray.

In sickbay, Data appears to have successfully produced the retro virus and is testing it on Ogawa.

Picard crawls through a Jefferies Tube with… Worf still in pursuit?! Did Proto-Worf climb through the tubrolift tube too? Somehow track Picard to this Jefferies Tube by another route?

Apparently, Worf is in a space above the tube Picard is in as when Picard reaches his hand in a junction some of Worf’s venom/saliva pours down from him and the acid burns Picard’s hand.

The retro-virus Data is working on seems to be working.

Picard continues through the Jefferies Tube, now having to favor his good hand, in pursuit of Worf. He reaches a dead-end and uses a panel to shield himself from the grating of the tube’s floor as Worf crawls towards him. Picard then uses a power-junction he pulls from the Jefferies Tube panel opening and uses it to electrify the tube’s floor which electrocutes Proto-Worf. Luckily the thin piece of metal Picard got was not only non-conductive but had enough resistance in it to make it a suitable shield for the high-powered conduit. Also luckily the electroshock was enough to simply make Proto-Worf pass-out and not die.

….. So a high stun setting risked killing Worf but sending untold levels of electo-energy into him is just fine?

Passed out Worf lays there with labored breathing as Picard cowers, promising when Worf wakes up he’ll be a new man.

In sickbay, Ogawa has returned to normal (a lot faster than she “de-evolved,” by the way, and Data says he’ll release the retro-virus through the ship’s atmospheric system. Picard okays this and confirms when Data notices Picard’s rather labored and panicked tone.

Epilogue: And my other problem with this episode.

Picard logs that the retro-virus has worked and everyone on the ship has returned to normal and that the problem was caused by Crusher’s “cure” for Barclay’s alien flu.

Crusher explains to Barclay in sickbay that the problem wasn’t his fault but hers (congratulations on your seamless recovery, Crusher and how it doesn’t seem to have affected you in any way) since her cure activated all of his T-Cells instead of the targeted one. Again, an errant hypospray shot caused all of this. This has never happened before so the condition will get named after Barclay since he was the first one to be diagnosed with it. He ponders this and leaves. Troi walks up and says she may have to clear her schedule given that Barclay de-evolved into a spider and now gets a disease named after him.

Ha-ha-ha, the man has severe emotional and psychological issues and people died! Ha ha ha.

That’s the other problem I have with this episode, it ends with the Braga trope of everything ending all normal and fine with an effective “reset button.” Nevermind that everyone on the ship were changed into animals for a few days, or that crew members died, that this “virus” impacted the civilians and children on the ship everything is all hunky-dory again. Just. Like. That.

And this would become the big problem with Voyager particularly in the show runners not taking their predicament seriously enough and this kind of BS would happen in every other episode. Radical, drastic, serious things would happen in the episode but by the end, everything is all happy and back to normal.

I mean, how could you even work alongside these people so soon after all of this? Crusher was disfigured and nearly killed/paralyzed! But here she is all normal like nothing happened. Troi de-evolved into an amphibian and all is okay. Worf ran around the ship like an animal and possibly killed people, Riker’s “Brain got much smaller” and he likely killed as well.
But everything goes back to normal at the end. And that’s my biggest problem with this episode and sort of the problem Trek would have going into the future, minus DS9 which took its events and the ramifications from them more seriously.

In some ways the episode is good and has probably some of the best makeup effects of the entire series. There is something of a good and interesting story here and the cast does a good job acting as their animalistic forms. But the episode, for me, is largely ruined by dumb stuff in it, the story ending in a way that doesn’t make sense and isn’t treated seriously. The very sloppy even pseudo-science to it.

In the end, I’d probably say the good and bad pushes against one another and we end up with an “okay” episode though maybe slightly “bad” because the “bad stuff” is a little strong and isn’t well presented for that suspension of disbelief to hold. Suspension of disbelief is earned, not given just by this being a sci-fi series. And even then some things you aren’t going to get away with.

But, given the quality of this season “Genesis” is probably one of the “better” episodes of the season, in the top 13, but doesn’t even rank for the entire series.

Till next time.
 
Okay, I know that the science of this episode just don't make a lot of sense, but I confess I loved this episode when I first saw it in 1994, and still enjoy it greatly now.

Gates McFadden does some very interesting things with her direction of the story, the pacing and tension was well played. It's always fun to see the ship in a dishevelled or unusual state.

I thought the make-up job on both spider Barclay and the Worf creature was well done.

All in all, definitely one of my highlights of season 7.
 
Genesis seems to be harkening back to the Sci-Fi flicks of the 1950's, like Creature from the Black Lagoon, and shit like that. The "creature" being touted as the "missing" link (!!!) between Man ... and fish. And I'm sure that, even way, way back then, the audience recognised that there was a wink in there, and just went along for a fun ride. And that's really what I get from Genesis. Sometimes, it's fun to just have an "anything goes" episode, where its appropriate - when it's a new situation.

In established settings, where we know the drill, to suddenly go out on a limb with an "anything goes" show ... it doesn't work. Audiences don't want to see that, fans in particular. Genesis was also a far better homage to its reference(s), than Q'pid was, for example. There, they had women (Bev and Troi) just sitting around, acting helpless, like in an Erol Flynn picture, when we know - when it's already been established - that they'll, at the very least, defend themselves. It's really only times like those, where they take the "it's just a TV show" thing too far and make it hard to have fun with playing with that bit.
 
Good recap, thanks again!

This is another reason over explaining everything is not a good thing. I think an alien virus that causes wild mutations would have been a much better reason, but there's more than just that. The whole weapons test thing was a poorly conceived reason to get Picard and Data off the ship. What kind of weapons test doesn't have any kind of fail safe? And they have to actually bring the dangerous object back to the ship instead of exploding it harmlessly? I think the people that wrote this are the one that are devolved. Are we not men? We are Devo, D-E-V-O. Oops, sorry. Where was I?

Again, as ridiculous as the shot causing it, it's compounded by the baby animals being immune? Really? And I have the unfortunate first had experience to tell you, my cat had 7 kittens and she ate them all, and there was no food shortage. Maybe the evolved sensibilities of 24th century animals are far superior to the 20th century animals and these all were very respectful of each other. Right.
 
Yeah, the thing with the torpedo was a weak way to get them off the ship; it'd make sense the torpedo would be designed to self-detonate if it lost contact with the ship or something. Hell, even Riker is perfectly okay with Picard going off with Data in a shuttlecraft to recover a stray, defective, photon torpedo. Couldn't they have been off the ship going to one of the 10,000 conferences and conventions Starfleet holds over the course of the year and then came back to this disaster? The stuff with Spot established through dialogue between Picard and Data in the shuttlecraft. Data rambling about Spot's pregnancy and Picard being indifferent and sort of half-listening to Data.

Again, I think this episode (and a few others in S7) just shows the weaker writing that was starting to take over as the better writers went over to DS9 leaving behind writers like Braga who'd go on to write for Voyager and later Enterprise and this sort of box-story telling with the end-episode reset button to everything literally going back to normal would become more common.

Massive, drastic, life-altering events occur, lives put greatly in danger, lives lost, people impacted in numerous ways. And then, "Oh we fixed it. Life goes on."
 
There's plenty of precedent to recovering the subject objects of weapons firing tests. Hell, in WWI, some sub skippers even recovered their precious live torpedoes if they failed to hit the target - by swimming to them and physically dragging them back to the sub!

As for failsafes, the test had plenty of those: an abort switch, a "subspace detonator", and the ship's own phasers. It's just that the failsafes, well, failed. Doesn't mean the torpedo would have remained dangerous. For all we know, the warhead automatically becomes harmless over time, the antimatter leaking out in a controlled manner or being consumed by the engine till the last drop.

Why deliberately go for boring? Surely something new, anything new, would be better than "off to a conference in a shuttle" - a much less sensible concept, considering how slow and uncomfortable these shuttles are supposed to be. Hell, for all we know, every conference trip was of the same sort we saw in "The Neutral Zone", with the mothership doing all the serious flying and the shuttle just spanning the planet-to-fringes-of-system distance. This works fine for things like "Parallels", but not for "Genesis" where the mothership just plain cannot be at the fringes of a star system that could provide help.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Forced/engineered/accidental evolution is a very common theme in science fiction, and therefore the precedent as a scifi "theme" does not make the appearance here seem especially egregious. Some examples include: 2001: A Space Odyssey(Starchild), Outer Limits: The Sixth Finger, The Architects of Fear, et al, Dune: Spacing Guild, David Brin's Uplift saga. It's really not especially unbelievable as other commonly accepted near-impossible speculations in ST such as warp drive.

As a standalone story, it's actually not bad, succeeding
better at it's "horror" elements than the avg such STNG/ST plot. The production design and make-up are excellent. In fact, if I had any qualms it's the one that was expressed in the review that there might have been a slower wrap-up to tell us the implications of their mental stability..though I gather they didn't remember much.
 
Oh, the "horror" elements are, indeed, very well done. The music, the tone, the makeup is all very, very, well done. I just struggle with the "evolution" aspects being so manhandled, though it is indeed a common sci-fi trope. But even then usually handled with some extraordinary element being involved. God-like aliens, more advanced aliens, unknown highly advanced technology, stuff like that. This was a errant hypospray shot in sickbay from a "regular" human doctor. It almost implies this sort of thing was just waiting to happen. Everyone was one bad alien flu, a recessive gene, and a hypospray shot away from a "de-evolution virus" running rampant and taking out populations. Seriously, had Data not been there (another case of where Data's simple existence saves the day) things would have turned out very, very differently.

But, for me, probably the biggest problem is the instant, "happy ending" wrap-up.

But, I still end up mostly liking with this episode.
 
Also, is anyone kind of curious, but also not, on how spider-Barclay strung those spider webs in the Engineering office?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top