• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 7x15 - "Lower Decks"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
LowerDecks.jpg


We open with Troi and Riker sitting in Ten Forward with PADDs, sigh.... Doing crew evaluation reports. Didn't they just do these? Were the writers on this show so hard-up to give the characters idle work to do that they all they could think of on a starship 100s of years in the future was to give people beuracratic bullshit to do? Certainly there's more interesting things they can be doing.

"Didn't we just do crew evaluation reports?" Riker asks, doing my job for me.

"Three months ago." Troi responds.

So three months passed between this episode and Sub Rosa?

Riker, through a yawn, says it feels like it was three weeks ago. Well, that was the last time I did a recap, so maybe he's onto something. Oh my God, is Blu-Ray Riker self-aware?! He suggests they just give everyone a promotion and call it a night, confirming with "Commander" Troi. (Uh-uh-uh! She has to pass a special test first!) Troi agrees with "Captain" Riker.

We now focus on the other side of the room to a group junior officers sitting at another table in the lounge playing Space Othello (or something), one of them (whom we'll call Lil Riker) wonders aloud why the senior officers doing performance reviews in the middle of a public lounge are in such good moods. With him at the table is Nurse Ogawa and Ensign Sito (last seen in "The First Duty" as a disgraced Starfleet cadet held back a year due to a fatal accident she was involved in) and a Vulcan junior officer.

Lil Riker wonders how he can relax when his career is being decided on the other side of the room, and he has a point. Sito tells him to relax and to continue the game. Lill Riker crosses his fingers and hold them to his temples as he closes his eyes and does the "wishing really hard" face as he tries to summon a promotion from across the room.

Vulcan does an Vulcan eye-roll (where you roll your eyes at someone without actually rolling your eyes) and asks if Lil Riker really thinks what he is doing will work. Lil Riker sort of glares at him a bit before retreating back to his childhood self wishing for an ice-cream cone or something.

Ogawa says its sort of a "tradition" for people to do such a thing, Sito points out that (Bajoran monks) do the same thing for the benefit of her people. Vulcan sort of looks to her and says, "considering the history of your planet, that doesn't exactly validate what he is doing." Yikes! That got ugly fast. Way to go there, T'Dick! Way to remind a fellow crewmember of the holocaust and near-genoice of her entire race. Man, I know Vulcans are supposed to be unemotional but they DO know about tact, don't they?!

Lil Riker finishes his little relapse into childhood, finishing that he wants a promotion so he can have a new roommate. T'Dick seems "shocked" by this, saying that Lil Riker can ask for a new room assignment if he's unhappy with the current one and doesn't get his promotion. The Enterprise is pretty big, they really need to double people up in the rooms? Ogawa laughs a bit as we cut back to Riker and Troi.

They're still going over the promotions, considering who should be the new night OPS officer, Riker's debating between Lavell (Lil Riker) and Sito; they're brought new drinks by a Ten Forward waiter (Benny) and decline deserts.

Benny goes over to the kids' table and fills them in on the "gossip" at the adult table. Another good reason why these crew evaluations probably shouldn't be done in public.

End our cold-open, which sets up the premise of this episode. Instead of focusing on the main cast and our heroes we're going to focus on this group of junior officers (and, uh, a Ten Forward waiter) and see life on the ship from a different perspective. Should prove interesting.

We come back to a battle simulation on the bridge, Sito is at the tactical console being overseen by Worf while Lil Riker sits at the CONN (Data at his usual position at OPS) and Riker is in the command chair giving orders, he orders a change of course and for Sito to fire on their "target" it happens and the "target" is destroyed. When the simulation is over he remarks that they were slower than the previous drill and wants to know what happened. Sito says she had to re-lock the target after they changed course, Riker recommends she lets the targeting bracket "float" so she doesn't have to unlock and then relock... which seems kind of obvious and reasonable. And why isn't the computer automatically doing this stuff?! And why is this a trick that has to be told about and isn't taught at the Academy?!

Riker wants a report from the Engineering team and Geordi delegates it to T'Dick -apparently on the engineering career path- and then orders Lil Riker to resume their previous course. Lil Riker responds with an, "Aye, aye." Riker glares at him a bit before saying, "One aye is enough." Sheesh, Riker. Who pissed in your Cheerios this morning?

Picard comes out onto the bridge and orders a course change and says he explain in the Observation lounge. (Humorously, Lil Riker responds with a single "Aye" to Picard) Sito takes over at OPS as the command crew go off to the lounge. We don't follow and watch Sito and Lil Riker discuss what's going on, the place they've been ordered to being close to the Federation/Cardassian border.

They have a causal conversation about the drill they just had, Lil Riker feels that Riker has it in for him, Sito isn't so sure. Then why is he not sitting at OPS, he wonders.

Uhhh... Because someone has to drive?

In Engineering T'Dick calls Geordi over to look over his simulations of a new warp field design, Geordi looks it over and points out some problems, but T'Dick says they're intentional and that they result in better efficiency, these particular designs are experimental ones he's privy to. Geordi is unwilling to put them into practical use and as he tries to leave the room seems quite annoyed with T'Dick's eagerness to work and talk with Geordi more about improving systems on the ship. Geordi gives him a brush off.

Man, everyone is sort of crabby today.

In sickbay things seem to be going much better, Ogawa goes into Crusher's office to update her on a patient but on entry Crusher automatically assumes Ogawa wants to know about the crew evaluations. She says that she gave Ogawa a glowing report and recommended her for a promotion. Ogawa is happy to hear this and decides to sit with Crusher and girl-talk about relationships. Ohhhh boy.

Luckily granny-porn and spectral masturbation don't come up and Ogawa seems concerned about how distant and pre-ocupied her boyfriend has become recently, Crusher assures her everything is likely fine and he's just busy and the honeymoon isn't over. So to speak.

The ship drops to impulse.

Sito is talking with Worf in Ten-Forward talking about her day at OPS, she had to de-gauss the main deflector dish (because, apparently, it works on 1970s VHS technology) find a loss cat and #24thCenturyPeopleProblems, she's not sure why she's being considered for OPS since she's a security officer. Worf says he recommended her.

Benny is talking with Lil Riker and T'Dick over at another Othello table where Lil Riker wonders what Sito and Worf are talking about when Riker swaggers into the room. Benny gives him a friendly, familiar, greeting much to the surprise of Lil Riker. Lil Riker doesn't believe Riker's ever casual and laid back but the others convince him that he needs to meet with Riker on a personal level and give him some pointers on breaking ice with Riker by talking about some of Riker's interests.

As Sito comes to the table, Lil Riker excuses himself and goes to speak with Riker on a personal level. The scene that follows could almost count as a meet-cute in a romantic comedy. Lil Riker greets Riker who barely turns from his PADD in response before wondering what Lil Riker wants. Lil Riker uses the ruse that he's getting a drink, even though he's holding a full glass of cherry Kool-Aid which doesn't go unnoticed by Riker. Lil Riker gets the same drink as Riker and tries to make small-talk about his Candian grandfather, believing Riker to be Candian from mis-inofrmation from Benny. Riker corrects him, he's Alaskan, and Lil Riker awkwardly points out both places get a lot of snow, Riker sort of agrees and chuckles as Lil Riker slinks away.

Actually sort of a funny little scene and Riker did come across as somewhat personable here, Lil Riker was just trying too hard; but it did feel like a genuine, awkward encounter with your boss and trying to have a causal, non work-related conversation.

As Lil Riker leaves the room, and his original drink, behind the Ten Forward bartender brings over the new drink. Riker just sort of laughs and shakes his head.

The ship holds at the Cardassian/Federation border searching for something, finally they find a small escape pod inside the Cardassian border, Geordi -and T'Dick- are able to increase the transporter range enough to transport off the pod's occupant.

In sickbay, Crusher clears the room -including Ogawa- before the pod's occupant is transported onto the main biobed; as Ogawa leave sickbay she sees Sito there guarding the door, they make some talk how neither knows what's going on, before they notice Picard coming and end their conversation. Before entering sickbay Picard gives Sito a sort of glare before entering the room.

On the bridge, the shift changes and Riker declines Lil Riker's request to stay on for one more shift for extra training. Riker says something about them trying to cut OT, bonus checks were a little thin last quarter.

Picard leaves sickbay and orders Sito to come with him, awkward silence in the tubolift before Picard asks Sito (again, who was involved with the spacecraft accident in "The First Duty") if she's a certified pilot, Sito confirms she is.

They enter the Ready Room where Picard begins berating Sito about the events in "The First Duty", she tries to defend herself by pointing out how long ago (a couple years) the event was and how since then she's been a model officer. Picard is unmoved. She further points out the tough time she had in her last years of the Academy without any friends and the event looming over her, but she toughed through it in order to graduate. Picard is further unmoved and wonders aloud how she made it onto the Enterprise before dismissing her.

In a shuttlebay, T'Dick is firing a phaser rifle at a shuttlecraft under Geordi's discussion. T'Dick questions this and Geordi responds that they are conducting procedural tests on the shuttle's hull. T'Dick is, mostly, unconvinced especially after he recommends using a lower setting on the rifle that'd get them the same data without damaging the shuttle. Geordi says the test remains the same and orders the next target point; T'Dick questions his firing position and Geordi has him changes it. Off handedly, but obviously, T'Dick says that doing so would be "consistent" with making it look like the shuttle had fled an attacker while making evasive maneuvers. Geordi assures him this is a coincidence.

In sickbay, Ogawa enters to help Crusher with their mystery patient, a Cardassian, under orders of ultimate secrecy.

In mirrored scenes we deal with poker games between the Jr. officers and Sr. officers.

In the junior game everyone talks about what they think is going on but, Ogawa is quiet about what she knows, Sito distant from her dressing down with Picard, and T'Dick questioning the work with the shuttle. Lil Riker feels left out and clueless.
 
[cont'd]
In the senior game they talk about general events around the ship, Crusher seeing Ogawa's boyfriend with another female on the ship, Riker and Worf discuss Sito's OPS position. Riker says he'll take it under advisement, considering he's not sure Lil Riker is right for the position. Troi thinks Riker and Lil Riker clash so mush since they're so much alike but Riker doesn't see the similarities. We the audience see it throughout the episode and here in mirrored scenes of our two Rikers bluffing in their respective poker games.

Worf and T'Dick fold in their respective games.

Troi convinces riker that Lil Riker is trying so hard because he's ambitious and just wants to get noticed, just like Riker was likely seen as when he took up poker on an early assignment. Riker admits he may have been a little hard on his younger counterpart before winning the game with a flush and rubbing Geordi's face in it, Geordi excuses himself from the game, saying he has work to do, and he goes to take

T'Dick with him to work on the engine modifications he suggested; this after T'Dick questions his working relationship with Geordi. Benny (who was in the junior game) asks to join-in on the senior game.

The following day at Kling' Chi Worf ends a class before asking Sito to participate in an "advanced class" but first she must pass an unannounced test involving her sparring with him while blindfolded. Worf pwns her a few times before she gives up, saying the test is unfair and she won't participate. Worf congratulates her on passing, realizing and admitting the test was unfair was the entire point. Sito asks if the test was real, considering the translation for the name Worf gives it means "To the Death." Worf admits that it wasn't and tells her maybe next time it won't take her so many bruises before she realizes she was unfairly judged.

We next see her in Picard's Ready Room defending herself and her setbacks at the Academy, she says is Picard cannot see past her mistakes and treat her fairly she wants a transfer. Picard, sternly, points out she's unlikely to find a more lenient commander. She asks to speak freely and when allowed to do so she further defends herself, asking to be judged on who she is today and not who she was in the past. Picard goes to her and tells her she had courgae to stand up to him after the other day and that he wasn't dressing her down for disciplinary reasons but to vet her for a secret mission, and he does know how she ended up on the Enterprise. He requested her, wanting her to have a fair chance to redeem herself for her actions at the Academy.

In sickbay, Cursher calls over Ogawa to talk with her on a more personal level, and seems ready to tell Ogawa about her boyfriend's apparent transgressions; but Ogawa says that he proposed and Crusher is happy to hear this. .... But what about the other woman in Ten-Forward?

Sito joins the senior staff in the Observation Lounge and a Cardassian informant is also there, he's a Federation operative who's brought back some intel that'll help secure the Federation side of the border and better protect Bajorans in Federation space. They need a way to sneak him back into Cardassian territory and their plan has a better chance of success if their operative has a Bajoran prisoner in his stolen Federation shuttle. Picard cannot oder Sito to go on this very dangerous mission so she volunteers. Worf is quick to want to point out the danger she's putting herself in, but Sito as a Bajoran knows better than anyone else what Caradassians do to their Bajoran captives. The Cardassian gulps nervously.

Sito, in civilian Bajoran garb with a face made to appear bruised as if she'd been mistreated arrives in the shuttlebay to board the distressed shuttle, she says her goodbyes to Worf and boards.

Enroute she talks with the Cardassian, asking why he's risking his life to do this. The Cardassian does not consider himself a traitor but feels his people are too focused on war and conquest rather than using their military to keep their people secure. Sito says she'd never thought she'd hear a Cardassian denounce War. The Cardassian thought a Bajoran would never help him to get home. As they near a patrol, they begin the set-up for their prisoner ruse.

Sometime later, Lil Riker is wondering what happened to Sito and assumes it had something to do with the damaged shuttle he saw leaving the ship. Ogawa and T'Dick are moot and imply they know something but cannot say due to orders. Lil Riker leaves for his shift.

On the bridge they search for the escape pod Sito was to be returned to the Enterprise in but it's nearly a day overdue, after a probe launch they find the remains of an escape pod in Cardassian territory; they soon intercept a report about a Bajoran prisoner escaping Cardassian captivity and the pod she fled in was destroyed.

Picard paces in his Ready Room before sitting down and giving the boatswain general call whistle, and announcing to the ship of Sito's sacrifice and death, we see the reactions from the other junior officers we met in the episode.

Later, Lil Riker joins Ogawa and T'Dick in Ten-Forward (even doing the Riker "lifting the leg over the back before mounting the chair" maneuver) and places his new pip down on the table, saying he got the promotion, though he assumes it was Sito's promotion. (They only give out one promotion?) Everyone else at the table gives him encouragring words to be proud of his promotion and to use it to honor her death; Ogawa attaches the Lt. (J.G.) pip.

Benny goes over to Worf at a nearby table and uses a lame ruse to convince Worf to join the junior officers at their table to talk about the loss of Sito since they were all her friends.

----

It's interesting that in this season where there are so many episodes that cried out how this show was struggling for stories and new material to the point people were in agreement the writers had nowhere to go so the show was ready to end; hell last week we used a grocery store romance novel for a plot, that we get an episode like this that stands out as one of Trek's best.

It was an interesting look at "the Average Joe's" perspective on life on the ship from the Jr. officers' perspective and a good re-use of a previous character and expanded use of a current on-and-off character (Ogawa.) The story-line and arc with Sito was well done and interesting (though how is she out of the Academy and on a ship before Wesley?) and the actress does a great job here in the reprisal of the role. The actor playing "Lil Riker" also does a good job of enbibing, well, Riker. The actor playing T'Dick also does well for the TNG era's portrayal of Vulcans.

The B-Story, of sorts, also was interesting and made good use of a Bajoran character as well as dove-tailing the things going on over on Deep Space Nine when it comes to tensions with the Cardassians and the building history between the Cardassians and Bajor.It's highly respectable of Picard to see that he asked for Sito in order to give her a fair chance in her career, meaning he saw her as another pawn in Cadet Not!Paris's plan back in "The First Duty." I can't help but feel a little bad for "Lil Riker" here as he's the only one of our Jr. Officer characters mostly left out of the events, Ogawa helps with the surgeries on the Cardassian spy, T'Dick helps with faking the damage to the shuttle and Sito was the co-conspirtor in helping the Cardassian get re-imbedded. I sort of felt for Lil Riker being left out of the loop on what was going on when he was talking with the others during Sito's absence.

The only critique for the episode is, maybe, Benny. His interaction with the crew seems too common place and causal to really be accepted since we've never seen him before and will never see him again. I mean, he just causally enters Riker's quarters and joins in on the poker game? WTF?!

But it's episodes like this, and a few others in Season 7, that show that the series probably had more it could have done if the writers put forth some effort and were up to the challenge. It's just that most of the better writers of Trek at this point were either on DS9 or likely working on either Generations or building a replacement series; or gone all together. We got occasional greats like this, but then we also got real dogs like the previous episode. Next time we'll continue on the good episode trend before entering some thick soup.
 
So three months passed between this episode and Sub Rosa?

At the rate these two were going through their subjects, on a thousand-person ship, "this time" probably extends all the way from "Sub Rosa" to "Lower Decks" and beyond...

Three months ago would be around "Attached" by stardate count, FWIW.

Timo Saloniemi
 
This was a surprisingly good late entry from the pretty awful Season 7. Even though she only appeared in 2 episodes, one of which she was basically an extra, I was sad about Sito's death. The young officers had great chemistry together. I'd have liked to have seen more of them but the series was almost over so it is what it is.

Taurik/Vorik. It's the same character. To hell with the name change.
 
Love the episode. Sad "red-shirt" type ending but we did get to know her a bit. I think I'm always a sucker for the occasional introspective crew episode.
 
Loved Lower Decks, especially the Jaxa/Worf scenes. It's a shame DS9 never did a follow up, as it would have been a call back that would have made sense, unlike bringing in Lursa and Betor.
 
Taurik/Vorik. It's the same character. To hell with the name change.

I always felt they were twin brothers. One served on board the Enterprise, while the other chose to serve on the incomplete Voyager as part of her construction and stayed on board once the ship was ready for her mission.
 
Just watched it again. The mentor/student relationship between Sito and Worf was truly touching and something different for the character of Worf. We are allowed to supply our own reasons for his brotherly/fatherly feelings for her, but I don't think they're hard to come up with: she has been something of an outcast, too, and he admires her grit.

Lavelle was a great character too and I could wish he had been introduced earlier and had recurred.

The only jarring note for me is Ben. He's obviously intended as a Guinan sub and it doesn't work, probably because it is so obvious. Plus that broad smile of his looked fake to me and grated. And that costume/bar uniform of his is ridiculous.
 
That would take Traveler-level powers, since Ten Forward didn't exist in season 1.

Regarding the crew eval reports, I always figured that they tackled them annually, but just did a quarter of the crew at a time, thus spreading out the workload. At the rate they were going through them, it'd take days of uninterrupted time to do everyone on the ship (granted it's likely somewhere less than a thousand or even nine hundred, given the presence of civilians on the ship).

Mark
 
...Although I'm sure the two loved to "evaluate" all the civilians, too, over their shared cups of whatever at Ten Forward.

Here specifically, one and the same evaluation being shown in both the stardate-less "Sub Rosa" and "Lower Decks" is easy to accept. It's not as if Riker would even have noticed "Sub Rosa" happening! And for Troi, it was the perfect reason to fall behind in the ongoing crew evaluation work.

Timo Saloniemi
 
That would take Traveler-level powers, since Ten Forward didn't exist in season 1.

Ten Forward wasn't on screen on season 1, but it might've been there, at least something was, that part of the ship is seen from the outside on season 1. :)
 
I never did like this episode. The Worf mentor stuff fell flat for me and it was yet another episode that had our regular heroes acting like dicks to lower ranking people to bolster the new characters. A Ron Moore staple.
 
When guest "stars" take over an episode, it's not that great...

And there must've been a safer way to get that Cardy back home without putting Sito in a situation like that... where she eventually was lost.

After what she did in the academy, I wonder, how honest Picard was when he gave this speech...

"She was the finest example of a Starfleet officer, and a young woman of remarkable courage and strength of character."
 
Last edited:
Ten Forward wasn't on screen on season 1, but it might've been there, at least something was, that part of the ship is seen from the outside on season 1. :)

Tasha mentions Ten Forward in "All Good Things" so it was there in Season 1. There was also a scene cut out of a Season 1 episode in which the crew are celebrating someone's birthday in there but it looks nothing like the Ten Forward of Season 2 onwards.
 
Tasha mentions Ten Forward in "All Good Things" so it was there in Season 1. There was also a scene cut out of a Season 1 episode in which the crew are celebrating someone's birthday in there but it looks nothing like the Ten Forward of Season 2 onwards.

Perhps Ten Forward was redecorated after Guinan took over on season 2. :) Season 1 desing just couldn't get synthehol down fast enough through ensign's throaths. And not enough toilets. Unisex toilet just didn't work, even if synthehol shouldn't make people act like idiots... You know, drunk guys are drunk guys...
 
I wasn't too impressed with this, it seemed like we should like the characters because we were told we should. I thought Taurik was interesting but I didn't get the sense that Sito (seemed more self-pitying than regretful) and Lavelle (just pretty annoying) were particularly good at their jobs.
 
I didn't remember this episode, and so wasn't expecting it to be so good. The writing is pretty great for everyone across the board, but what really makes it tick is that the young characters are very likable, even though we only have a short time to get to know them. I was ready to dislike all of them (particularly Lil Riker) from the start, but they were not one-dimensional like so many one-off characters, and the actress playing Sito really did an exceptional job.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top