• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 7x08 - "Attached"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
Attached_4.jpg


The Enterprise has arrived at the planet Kes/Prit in order to review the Kes following their petition to join The Federation. This is an unusual submission as the planet doesn't have a one-world government but two. The Kes are a more diplomatic and "democratic" people who occupy a majority of the planet but one country/continent still exists -the Prit- who're more xenophobic, to the point no real formal means of communication has existed between the two groups for over a century.

Picard worries this planet is too much of a deviation from the Federation standards as usually having a one-world government means a people have worked through their planetary cultural, racial, and other differences and are ready to join the interstellar community. Crusher, seems okay with the notion, wondering if Picard would be against Earth being allowed into the Federation had Australia not been part of Earth's one-world government. (And odd strawman since Earth was a founding planet of the Federation and didn't "join" in the sense that Crusher suggests.)

Picard and Crusher (for, uh.... reasons) are set to meet with Kes leaders in order to set-up the formal arrangements, being while beaming down their transporter signal is somehow redirected to Prit territory and the two are lost.

On the ship, Riker works with a group of people from Kes's intelligence branch in order to recover Picard and Crusher. The Kes recommend using covert tactics to recover the lost crew but Riker initially prefers a more diplomatic approach, even after he's assured by the Kes people that such a thing is impossible.

On the planet, Picard and Crusher awake in a Prit prison cell with implants attached to their brain-stem. They're told by a Prit leader that the implants will allow the Prit to read the thoughts of Picard and Crusher in order to find out why they're really there; fearing the Kes and Federation are conspiring together in order to take over the Prit.

Some time later a Prit prison-worker delivers a covered tay to Picard and Crusher, at first they believe it's food but when opening it they find a modified tricorder. The tricorder has been programmed with a way to exit the cell and sneak into Kes territory to be rescued. They decide to attempt to the escape.

Enroute the experience strange effects from the neural implants, at first getting flashes or glimpses at the other's thoughts and feelings, as they continue their journey the flow of information between the two grows stronger tot he point where they're hearing the random and impulsive thoughts of the other. Crusher noting Picard makes guesses on decisions to give the appearance he knows what he's doing, Picard noting Crusher always has some snarky remark in her head. They try and to distance themselves hoping that the connection will weaken, but they find they grow nauseous when they're too far apart.

Along their given escape route they find someone guarding the trail and they seek an alternate escape.

On the ship, Riker has failed to achieve a diplomatic solution and opts for the more hands-on approach recommended by the Kes; only to discover their plan is already underway and Crusher and Riker are enroute to meet with an embedded officer.

Later the Kes intelligence officer begins to grow suspicious of Riker and the real intent behind the Enterprise's visit, especially after Crusher and Picard failed to rendezvous with their embedded agent. Riker grows annoyed with his increasingly absurd assumptions and accusations and suggests he leave the ship.

Picard and Crusher make camp for the night and as they sit by the fire begin to have a more intimate conversation about their relationship where it's revealed that Picard has had strong feelings for Crusher ever since he first met her; but never said anything since she was with his best-friend.

After Jack died, Picard still avoided sharing feelings with her in respect for his friend, hence his apprehension when Beverly first came to the ship. He worried of his romantic feelings reasserting themselves. But, instead, he found them no longer there and instead began to appreciate Beverly as a friend as their bond was rebuilt after not seeing each other for nearly 20 years. (Well, closer to 15 given Wesley's age in S1.)

The following morning Crusher and Picard continue to make their way to the Kes/Prit territorial border.

Ont he ship, Riker brings the Kes intelligence officer back on board in order to ambush a confrontation between him and the Prit intelligence officer via the viewscreen. When the communication breaks down again he kidnaps the Prit officer tot he Observation Lounge and forces a conversation between the three of them.

The conversation eventually collapses as the paranoia between the two people becomes more and more apparent, so Riker tells the Kes they will not be admitted to the Federation under his -and Picard's- suggestion. That while they're a kind, democratic, people their paranoia consumes them.

He then pokes at the Prit's xenophobia telling them how intense the investigation from the Federation will be should Crusher and Picard not be returned. A dozen ships in orbit, sensor sweeps, communications forced and even away teams. The Prit officer gives up Crusher and Picard just as they reach the border and are captured by Prit security officers.

Once back on the ship, and having the implants removed, Crusher and Picard share in a romantic dinner and discuss their experiences. Picard says he's open to exploring a relationship with her now that everything is now in the open, but Crusher seems more reluctant to go down that road at this time.

Picard: Denied.

--------


As a Picard/Crusher..... *sigh* "shipper" it's hard to not really like this episode and smile during it when we see the interactions between Picard and Crusher. I don't think the "romance" between them was this heavily handled since Season 3's "Allegiance" and, well, that was between a Picard replicant and Crusher, but Crusher's feelings are explored and depending on how much we want to interpret the replicant's portrayal of Picard maybe some of his deeper feelings were explored as well.

Gates McFadden is almost irresistible in this episode between her over look and just her more fun facial expressions during some of her more "Crusher moments," like when talking about her snarky demeanor and how it hurt someone she dated in her teens. And the deeper, more romantic, moments with her are also touching as well. It's really easy to watch this episode and see the connection between her in Picard.

Patrick Stewart and her play off one another very well, as the did in S1 where the suggestion of a relationship between the two of them was in play before being all but eliminated on Crusher's return in S3.

It's really a sweet episode and probably one of the very few times TNG did anything related to romance and love well. (Wait for it!)

It's very odd, however, that the notion of allowing the Kes to join the Federation was ever entertained. I guess they could send in an investigation just to placate or give lip-service, but it a lot of sense that a planet has a one-world government in order to join The Federation. As said, it first of all says the planet has solved any and all internal difficulties. I mean, what could really become of aligning with part of a planet when another part of it is a bunch of reclusive xenophobes who seem to partake in North Korea levels of isolationism and manipulation of their people, to the point of impacting their leaders own views of the world around them?

So... Could Starfleet reverse-engineer the mind-reading device? They seemed to operate independently without any need of having communication with a larger system, since they worked on the ship and the Prit are said to have no means of communication outside of their country.

Seems to be reverse-engineering the devices could be beneficial to Starfleet (at least its intelligence wings) or, hell, just let Picard and Crusher put them on again if they ever want to play around in the other's mind some? :evil:

The ending is a pretty blatant "reset switch", not something TNG did a lot and when they did do it it wasn't too terribly done. (See: Voyager) But having Picard and Crusher become aware of the other's feelings and then for them to pretty much decide not to pursue things is a pretty big reset switch, changing things superficially in order to not upset the status-quo. I mean, how *is* their next breakfast going to go when Crusher comes over and Picard's mind is all, "man, didn't she just deny me last night, even after we know how the other feels for really sure?"

It would have been nice if, this is the last season afterall, the writers just let Picard and Crusher hook-up. It wouldn't have to be dealt with that much in the remaining 18 episodes or following movies, but they could have done *something.*

And then there's the AGT future which I don't accept as being "real" and just Q dicking around with Picard. I think it's fine to feel Crusher/Picard hooked up sometime after Nemesis and lived happily forever. So, neyah!
 
Great episode. I also like to think Picard and Crusher got together post Nemesis. McFadden gets a lot of criticism but I thought she did a terrific job in this episode.
 
I wasn't wild about this episode tbh. I'd sooner the Picard Crusher relationship evolve gradually in an old school way. That they are reading each others minds and stuff of this sort and then to press the reset button, it just seems quite a contrived device and fits into the haphazard, stop-start, mismanaged, half forgotten way the Picard-Crusher relationship is treated during the series overall.

I'd rather have them escalate their relationship in an elegant way that was portrayed in All Good Things. But do it much earlier in the season, so we can see the relationship blossom. It's not without the good moments this episode mind you but I was personally dissatisfied with it overall for the above reasons.
 
It's hardly a "Voyager reset button". Two people find out how they feel about each other and decide to supress it for the greater good. Remember Lessons? This ending fits with Picard's character growth after that.

Happens in RL much more than one would realise.
 
Regarding North Koreas, the UFP has plenty of factions of its own that exist separate from the federal rule and uphold weird counterculture philosophies, ranging from hippie to neo-Nazi. Getting as much as 50% of a planet to join would probably a) guarantee that the entire planet became UFP-compatible in no time flat, and b) introduce some welcome further diversity to the UFP mix.

Sure, most of those dissidents live on faraway colony worlds. But that's really neither here nor there: drawing borders across the surfaces of planets is not fundamentally different from drawing them along those surfaces, or the emptiness between the surfaces. Warp travel is cheap, and ideas can travel across interstellar distances about as easily as across rivers or chicken-wire borders.

As for the telepathy tech, the UFP probably has plenty already. But they are wary of even natural telepathy, so only the spooks would use the stuff, so presumably offscreen...

The 'ship angle in the episode felt extremely forced because it had been ignored for so long - so perhaps it was appropriate for it to be "forced" plotwise, too. But much of the 7th season "character interest" stuff seems pasted-on and uninteresting...

...Just like character interest stuff ITRW tends to be. But realism is not exactly what I'm hoping for from TNG. :(

Timo Saloniemi
 
It's hardly a "Voyager reset button". Two people find out how they feel about each other and decide to supress it for the greater good. Remember Lessons? This ending fits with Picard's character growth after that.

Well, God no, it's not a Voyager-level reset button. But I argue it's still a button to maintain the status quo rather than changing anything. Berman, EP at the time of the franchise, was pretty adamantly against arced story telling as it made the show easier to watch in second-run syndication. It's harder to watch an arced series that way due to numerous factor. One being how second-run syndication worked at the time and the availability of episodes and the watching habits of people. Any arced story, it was felt, would be muddied by episodes seen out of order in repeats.

So Berman didn't want any arced story telling. Hence the "reset button" often used on Voyager and how the ship was always pristine and in tip-top condition unless the story called for it to not be. (Not mention the fleet of shuttles the tiny shuttle-bay held as well as torpedo-count.)

So along those lines this is something of a reset button. They didn't want to change things so people watching repeats wouldn't be confused when Picard/Crusher are in a relationship and this episode hadn't aired yet in syndication. It was out of maintaining a status quo rather than any character arc.

Similar to Troi/Worf after Parallels their hook-up is pretty much never touched on again until "AGT" and even then only tangentially.

So while it may have impacted their characters to make this decision.... It also didn't really since everything is back to normal next week and in future episodes.
 
I thought Picard and Crusher made a good team, it's interesting how their relationship has changed over time.
 
I wasn't wild about this episode tbh. I'd sooner the Picard Crusher relationship evolve gradually in an old school way. That they are reading each others minds and stuff of this sort and then to press the reset button, it just seems quite a contrived device and fits into the haphazard, stop-start, mismanaged, half forgotten way the Picard-Crusher relationship is treated during the series overall.

I'd rather have them escalate their relationship in an elegant way that was portrayed in All Good Things. But do it much earlier in the season, so we can see the relationship blossom. It's not without the good moments this episode mind you but I was personally dissatisfied with it overall for the above reasons.
Over all, I agree with this. However, it's hard to condemn this episode, because it's so damn well played. They just draw you right in. I found it quite useful to flesh out the whole history, even if it was ultimately going to be reset. Clearing the air had it's own point unto itself. Plus, they manage to draw some interesting character revelations, in how they expose Bev's hidden attitudes. It makes us realize how very similar they both are, in having been rather impetuous youths, who through some painful life lessons have aged into being very reserved

Truthfully, this episode was necessary, after all the bungling of this "do they don't they" thing, if they were ever planning to do what they did in All Good Things... It added a much better, previously unwritten, foundation to the relationship they have in that later episode, than say Geordi just getting a hamfisted marriage to a woman, whom when we last saw her, was still married to someone else. I'm glad they didn't wait until the series finale & then just drop us into a history of them being in a relationship. It would've been cheaper had this here episode not somewhat paved the way a bit
 
I just finished watching this episode, and the end really moves me.

It seems like a pivotal point in such a beautiful relationship between two such unique people, and I love how it's so maturely dealt with. The music in the final scene is epic.

* wipes tears away
 
An example of a TNG cop out. They should've had Picard and Crusher get it on.
Data and Yar did. Worf and Troi did. Riker and everyone else did. Why not Picard and Crusher? They could've had Wesley walk in on them and be traumatized.
 
An example of a TNG cop out. They should've had Picard and Crusher get it on.

On the contrary, a cop-out and easy road would have been to follow the formula for 99% of Hollywood tripe and have a completely predictable love scene between two people with obvious chemistry.
It would of pulled more ratings, surely.

I thought the depiction of Picard and Crusher's relationship was very much in line with a more mature and sensible approach to what might have been considered by many as an inevitable affair.
It's things like this that really sets TNG apart.
 
An example of a TNG cop out. They should've had Picard and Crusher get it on.

On the contrary, a cop-out and easy road would have been to follow the formula for 99% of Hollywood tripe and have a completely predictable love scene between two people with obvious chemistry.
It would of pulled more ratings, surely.

I thought the depiction of Picard and Crusher's relationship was very much in line with a more mature and sensible approach to what might have been considered by many as an inevitable affair.
It's things like this that really sets TNG apart.
I think it was a TNG cop-out. Sometimes real life authenticity doesn't make for good high drama.

For me, it's unprecedented for two people to actually dive into each others thoughts in a very real way and dig up all these feelings. These two people are going to struggle badly with this stuff I would've thought.
 
Last edited:
More-over, high-drama doesn't make for a good episodic TV series where everything resets to normal by the next episode without any major changes to status quo.
 
Unpopular opinion #8,481,023: Picard/Crusher chemistry is much more believable and compelling than Riker/Troy. They're great when they play this on screen together, and it was particularly good in this episode. The Riker/Troy romance always struck me as written and played by a high school drama department.
 
I just watched this the other day. This is one of those episodes that is completely transformed by the 24 years of life experience I've gotten since first seeing it.

Originally I received "Attached" with a shrug, and an eye-roll at the reset button.

Now, minus the sci-fi trappings, I've been in a situation almost exactly like this one, and I recognize how emotional and intimate the decision not to pursue things can be. That ending doesn't feel like a cop-out to me anymore, now it feels very powerful and moving.
 
Great episode. I also like to think Picard and Crusher got together post Nemesis. McFadden gets a lot of criticism but I thought she did a terrific job in this episode.

I hope that too. And perhaps with the foresight Picard gained from the temporal rift experience in All Good Things... he maybe figured out how to not f up the marriage. After watching his "The Captains" interview with Shatner, and hearing Sir Patrick talk about his regrets as a husband, I watch those scenes between Picard and Beverly in season 7 episodes in a really different way.

As far as Gates McFadden, I think she provided the most consistently enjoyable characterization and performances on TNG (with the exception of the ghost sex but thats not her fault so much as the writers), with LeVar a close second. Both their characters were just so casual and relatable.
 
The Enterprise has arrived at the planet Kes/Prit in order to review the Kes following their petition to join The Federation. This is an unusual submission as the planet doesn't have a one-world government but two. The Kes are a more diplomatic and "democratic" people who occupy a majority of the planet but one country/continent still exists -the Prit- who're more xenophobic, to the point no real formal means of communication has existed between the two groups for over a century.

Better two than one hundred, LOL?

Picard worries this planet is too much of a deviation from the Federation standards as usually having a one-world government means a people have worked through their planetary cultural, racial, and other differences and are ready to join the interstellar community. Crusher, seems okay with the notion, wondering if Picard would be against Earth being allowed into the Federation had Australia not been part of Earth's one-world government. (And odd strawman since Earth was a founding planet of the Federation and didn't "join" in the sense that Crusher suggests.)

I love how they always say "We did it!" but never really go into details, as if people would do the work necessary anyway?

Many planets would far more likely have numerous cultures and governments that work together on some level (trade treaties).

But any planet with one society means they always had splintered in the past? Too simplistic. Not with the size of the galaxy and number of theorized life-hospitable planets... many species are indigenous to one region of a planet, often because the whole planet has only certain regions that are more hospitable to life without being augmented by technology and there's no way to go back, and the few that adapt to multiple climates don't all turn on each other as a result. Many possibiliti4es exist but for "Attached" one may as well roll with it.

That and if a planet is called Kes/Pritt because of its two cultures, that makes Earth - right now - a total misnomer. But shoving 180 or so names into one name is a bit hard to achieve when people get bored after seven syllables (or even two or three syllables nowadays, suggesting devolution might be more fact than fiction, at least on a linguistic level...)

Picard and Crusher (for, uh.... reasons) are set to meet with Kes leaders in order to set-up the formal arrangements, being while beaming down their transporter signal is somehow redirected to Prit territory and the two are lost.

LOL, "uh... reasons".. definitely plot/narrative contrivance. :D

I forgot this story completely, except the two of them have magical devices where they're sharing all their thoughts. Like being naked in a room together but not for spiritual or related reasons.

On the ship, Riker works with a group of people from Kes's intelligence branch in order to recover Picard and Crusher. The Kes recommend using covert tactics to recover the lost crew but Riker initially prefers a more diplomatic approach, even after he's assured by the Kes people that such a thing is impossible.

I bet Riker will be proven right... no details, they're just always right. :D

On the planet, Picard and Crusher awake in a Prit prison cell with implants attached to their brain-stem. They're told by a Prit leader that the implants will allow the Prit to read the thoughts of Picard and Crusher in order to find out why they're really there; fearing the Kes and Federation are conspiring together in order to take over the Prit.

Good reasoning. The Prit should find out within a few hours or minutes, or seconds if the right key words are used, what the truth is and then Riker will have less to worry about since this incident and "naked truth" will pave the way for genuine peace and prosperity for all.

Some time later a Prit prison-worker delivers a covered tay to Picard and Crusher, at first they believe it's food but when opening it they find a modified tricorder. The tricorder has been programmed with a way to exit the cell and sneak into Kes territory to be rescued. They decide to attempt to the escape.

Well, if their thoughts are monitored they should be recaptured in a few minutes if not sooner. Unless the Prit are pritty lazy despite their zealous paranoia... :D

Enroute the experience strange effects from the neural implants, at first getting flashes or glimpses at the other's thoughts and feelings, as they continue their journey the flow of information between the two grows stronger tot he point where they're hearing the random and impulsive thoughts of the other. Crusher noting Picard makes guesses on decisions to give the appearance he knows what he's doing, Picard noting Crusher always has some snarky remark in her head. They try and to distance themselves hoping that the connection will weaken, but they find they grow nauseous when they're too far apart.

Ah, the true reason for the story since everything else has been, here we go again, pritty lazy... :D

But technology designed to feed thoughts to a central computer, due to Picard and Crusher being Human and not Prit, now work to send each others' thoughts to each other somehow. Like listening to an AM radio and screaming into the air in disagreement over the talk show host and then the talk show actually hears it and responds... um...

At least we know the two technological goobers borgified into their brain stems have no range, how nice. What's the range between them and the main computers recording their thoughts and would tracking devices not be part of these gizmos, in the event they escape because - obviously - wearing devices that record every thought clearly can't monitor and react to the event of any thought where the wearer of the device thinks "I'M FREE, TIME TO RUN AWAY TO THOSE SURROUNDING MOUNTAINS WHERE NOBODY CAN SEE ME AND AT RUNNING SPEED I CAN BE THERE IN ONE HOUR, WHEEEEEEEE!!!!!!"?

(Obviously, this story isn't one of my favorites...)

Along their given escape route they find someone guarding the trail and they seek an alternate escape.

Phew. I don't remember if the guard had been told to be on the lookout because they had escaped or not. Either way, with the walkie talkies in them, they shouldn't have gotten this far in such a paranoid culture.

On the ship, Riker has failed to achieve a diplomatic solution and opts for the more hands-on approach recommended by the Kes; only to discover their plan is already underway and Crusher and Riker are enroute to meet with an embedded officer.

Yikes, he failed. A good twist in an iffy episode for sure.

Later the Kes intelligence officer begins to grow suspicious of Riker and the real intent behind the Enterprise's visit, especially after Crusher and Picard failed to rendezvous with their embedded agent. Riker grows annoyed with his increasingly absurd assumptions and accusations and suggests he leave the ship.

Each side thinks the Federation is there to act for the other. Yet each side won't believe it when the other says that's not the case. It's comedy gold! As told by Joe Piscopo to Data!

Picard and Crusher make camp for the night and as they sit by the fire begin to have a more intimate conversation about their relationship where it's revealed that Picard has had strong feelings for Crusher ever since he first met her; but never said anything since she was with his best-friend.

Never mind Jack Crusher and all...

As far back as "The Naked Now", that's a given - the underlying notion both had a thing for one another despite her old enough to be his daughter. Was "Attached" a rejected season 1 story?

After Jack died, Picard still avoided sharing feelings with her in respect for his friend, hence his apprehension when Beverly first came to the ship. He worried of his romantic feelings reasserting themselves. But, instead, he found them no longer there and instead began to appreciate Beverly as a friend as their bond was rebuilt after not seeing each other for nearly 20 years. (Well, closer to 15 given Wesley's age in S1.)

Okay, that bit rocks. Shame the overall story is a pile, but that scene rocks.

The following morning Crusher and Picard continue to make their way to the Kes/Prit territorial border.

Ont he ship, Riker brings the Kes intelligence officer back on board in order to ambush a confrontation between him and the Prit intelligence officer via the viewscreen. When the communication breaks down again he kidnaps the Prit officer tot he Observation Lounge and forces a conversation between the three of them.

Yup, because once they cross the border, Roscoe P Coltrane can't arrest them but neither side will declare an act of war despite both sides thinking they're spies for the other side.

The Prit shouldn't have been able to lose Picard and Crusher so quickly, and why not beam on up a Kes so they and the Prit can all be in the same room instead of a selective televised event, anti-Prit, which would be the perfect impetus for a real problem and it's all thanks to the Enterprise breaking the Prime Directive... but the planet isn't in the Federation so it must be okay to break the rules so flagrantly, unless one is in the Briar Patch of course...

The conversation eventually collapses as the paranoia between the two people becomes more and more apparent, so Riker tells the Kes they will not be admitted to the Federation under his -and Picard's- suggestion. That while they're a kind, democratic, people their paranoia consumes them.

Another interesting and not unrealistic set piece. Had they been accepted, the Federation would then get to work on the development of their planet. But I'm sure both sides will work together so they can join this haughty Federation that will otherwise not interfere with the development of planets in the greatest twist o' irony ever. Or the incident will cause a big blood war as a result, had the Prit paid attention they would have figured it out quickly that the Federation wasn't there to be biased solely for the Kes, the Federation wanted the planet to be unified and singing songs like "Incense and Peppermints" and "Sit With the Guru", proving that utopia is not achieved with anything except for LSD, music, religion (except for the one that one grew up with because "rebel", of course), and numerous antibiotics (since STDs, as said by most religions, are punishment for sin) because the world was innocent back then (which it wasn't, since the world was the impetus for America's pop- and/or counter- culture of the 1960s.)

He then pokes at the Prit's xenophobia telling them how intense the investigation from the Federation will be should Crusher and Picard not be returned. A dozen ships in orbit, sensor sweeps, communications forced and even away teams. The Prit officer gives up Crusher and Picard just as they reach the border and are captured by Prit security officers.

Wouldn't one ship's sensors differentiate the humans from everyone else? The episode may have discussed something that neatly prevents beaming for x number of reason(s)...

The Kes weren't perfect either...

Once back on the ship, and having the implants removed, Crusher and Picard share in a romantic dinner and discuss their experiences. Picard says he's open to exploring a relationship with her now that everything is now in the open, but Crusher seems more reluctant to go down that road at this time.

Picard: Denied.

Ah, back to the real reason of the episode that's given any tact...

--------


As a Picard/Crusher..... *sigh* "shipper" it's hard to not really like this episode and smile during it when we see the interactions between Picard and Crusher. I don't think the "romance" between them was this heavily handled since Season 3's "Allegiance" and, well, that was between a Picard replicant and Crusher, but Crusher's feelings are explored and depending on how much we want to interpret the replicant's portrayal of Picard maybe some of his deeper feelings were explored as well.

The episode isn't perfect, but it's definitely meant to get Picard and Crusher together and there are some good moments between the two.

Gates McFadden is almost irresistible in this episode between her over look and just her more fun facial expressions during some of her more "Crusher moments," like when talking about her snarky demeanor and how it hurt someone she dated in her teens. And the deeper, more romantic, moments with her are also touching as well. It's really easy to watch this episode and see the connection between her in Picard.

Patrick Stewart and her play off one another very well, as the did in S1 where the suggestion of a relationship between the two of them was in play before being all but eliminated on Crusher's return in S3.

Ditto. That and the episode recognizing Jack and adding in some detail on how Picard respected her (and Jack) are high points.

It's really a sweet episode and probably one of the very few times TNG did anything related to romance and love well. (Wait for it!)

It's very odd, however, that the notion of allowing the Kes to join the Federation was ever entertained. I guess they could send in an investigation just to placate or give lip-service, but it a lot of sense that a planet has a one-world government in order to join The Federation. As said, it first of all says the planet has solved any and all internal difficulties. I mean, what could really become of aligning with part of a planet when another part of it is a bunch of reclusive xenophobes who seem to partake in North Korea levels of isolationism and manipulation of their people, to the point of impacting their leaders own views of the world around them?

Picard's own prepared monologue at the start should have prevented the episode from happening. And it only gets worse from there.

We really don't get enough details to equate Prit with NK. At least from what I remember. Technologically speaking, there is no parallel as the Kes didn't have the convenient bag of goodies the Prit had. But on another frame, isn't it true that the Kes also had their own form of manipulation of people? I need to rewatch the ep, but there might be other factors involved or plot holes...

So... Could Starfleet reverse-engineer the mind-reading device? They seemed to operate independently without any need of having communication with a larger system, since they worked on the ship and the Prit are said to have no means of communication outside of their country.

The Prit couldn't communicate outside their own country (that's far more isolated than NK, since they're communicating) and, even more fun, the Prit could intercept and deflect a transporter beam, from their itty bitty plot of land thatr's sufficiently close to the Kes capitol and the Enterprise to where Captain and Chief Medical Officer (for no real reason as you'd noted) were beaming on down to, and not kill Picard and Crusher in the process. That's pretty good considering alien technologies may be similar in certain aspects but radically different in others. Like PAL vs NTSC for television signals, both transfer sound and imagery but that's the only similarity. Then again, the Prit otherwise don't have transporter technology of any sort since they used a type of tractor beam, which they made for what reason - to cause a war by deflecting Kes satellites being launched into orbit even though there are none in orbit based on all the flyby f/x shots?

Excellent point. Along with every other prime directive breaking moment in this episode, the Federation now has shiny new technology to disseminate and assimilate. Section 31 would have a field day. Then again, the Prit didn't seem to know how to use it since anyone wearing one could escape and nobody would know where to look for them, their thoughts would still be a dead giveaway. 24th century humans are still human and it was a stressful event, they're not going to mislead one another or say "go there, then there". But I've not seen the episode in a very long time, so maybe they had...

Seems to be reverse-engineering the devices could be beneficial to Starfleet (at least its intelligence wings) or, hell, just let Picard and Crusher put them on again if they ever want to play around in the other's mind some? :evil:

Section 31, of course. Or another Romulan masquerading as a Vulcan...

The ending is a pretty blatant "reset switch", not something TNG did a lot and when they did do it it wasn't too terribly done. (See: Voyager) But having Picard and Crusher become aware of the other's feelings and then for them to pretty much decide not to pursue things is a pretty big reset switch, changing things superficially in order to not upset the status-quo. I mean, how *is* their next breakfast going to go when Crusher comes over and Picard's mind is all, "man, didn't she just deny me last night, even after we know how the other feels for really sure?"

LOL, true

It would have been nice if, this is the last season afterall, the writers just let Picard and Crusher hook-up. It wouldn't have to be dealt with that much in the remaining 18 episodes or following movies, but they could have done *something.*

At least Worf got it on with Troi, which was quickly pushed aside when he moved to DS9. I can fathom how Worf would be attracted to Dax, though. I still feel bad for Troi...

And then there's the AGT future which I don't accept as being "real" and just Q dicking around with Picard. I think it's fine to feel Crusher/Picard hooked up sometime after Nemesis and lived happily forever. So, neyah!

Q always "dicked around" with Picard because he wanted to see Picard grow as a person as representative of a species. Not just a thrill. Season 1 lacked the focus, apart from "Farpoint", but season 2 onward solidify that Q is not an ordinary dicker-arounder, hehe -- Now, Q was always said to torment others, but if Q does the same thing to all species and getting them to see bigger pictures, then there's far more going on to the Q than a Civil War reenactment as allusion for the humans to be able to relate to (and to save on budget production costs ) . :D
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top