Neither. I thought it was beautiful from many angles, distances, and under all lighting. In short, I liked it."Didn't mind" as in it sucked but ya didn't care, or only sucked a little bit?
TMP or Abram's Enterprise, which design is better?
- Thread starter Chrisisall
- Start date
Dude, it looks like botched pancake.Neither. I thought it was beautiful from many angles, distances, and under all lighting. In short, I liked it.
I disagree. It actually reminds me more of the refit Enterprise than any other ship, and the refit was a damn functional and elegant looking lady.
It looked like a frisbee & a flashlight that got run over by a truck & smushed into a single mess.
It's not just the nacelles being too big, they look that way because the secondary hull is too small. If they increased the size of the secondary hull a little bit and made the nacelles a little bit smaller then I would find it more understandable how people can compare this to the refit, as is there is just no comparison for me.
The E-E is a nice (not great) ship but below and from the bow is a terrible angle for it. it's much better above and from the bow, or from the sides.
In regards to the original question, here's how I rank them:
1. TWOK/TSFS Refit and E-A
2. XI-prise
3. TMP refit
In short, I just hate that brown deflector. I know this sounds stupid but I really think it ruins the whole thing for me. The XI-prise is very close to the II-VI refit, I just like the bulbous engineering hull of the refit more than the tubular engineering hull of the XI-prise and TOS E.
TMP refit, I know in my head it's nearly the same ship as the TWOK refit but I see that brown deflector and I'm just done. I don't know why, other than I'm crazy.
In regards to the original question, here's how I rank them:
1. TWOK/TSFS Refit and E-A
2. XI-prise
3. TMP refit
In short, I just hate that brown deflector. I know this sounds stupid but I really think it ruins the whole thing for me. The XI-prise is very close to the II-VI refit, I just like the bulbous engineering hull of the refit more than the tubular engineering hull of the XI-prise and TOS E.
TMP refit, I know in my head it's nearly the same ship as the TWOK refit but I see that brown deflector and I'm just done. I don't know why, other than I'm crazy.
Yer not crazy- the blue is WAAAY better. The brown (Or, golden-brown, as I like to call it) ain't enough to freak me, but the successive dishes were much nicer. BUT STILL TOO RECESSED!
The deflector is a dish best served blue then ?
LOLROTF!The deflector is a dish best served blue then ?
That was good, one to save, in fact!
Uuum, the deflector WAS blue in TMP. It just didn't start that way when it fired up because it glows blue due to heat, not magic.
Yeah, in most of it, I reckon. Forgive me, it's been DAYS since I've seen it.
The image that pops into my head is always with the Earth behind her, and the sun coming up, and in that shot it was golden brown if memory (recent memory) serves.
And the deflector was also brown for some shots in TWOK because they reused stock footage during the spacedock scene.
Penny-pinchers!
Well I'll be dipped. They say the memory is the first thing to go, they just didn't say it would go so soon.
*shrugs*It looked like a frisbee & a flashlight that got run over by a truck & smushed into a single mess.
You might also say that the others looked like a frisbee and a flashlight held together by popsicle sticks.
Its not my favorite ship, but it IS nice, IMO. I'm surprised you can't see the resemblance to the refit Constitution-class.
You're right.
I hate them all now.
Yes, it's called early 21st Century Earth!You do an awful lot of maniacal laughing. Are you posting from an insane asylum?
