• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Things You Do / Don't Want in a Fan Film

I guess I'm one of the few people that really likes time travel stories. :(

Bring 'em on! :D

Also, I second, third, and infinity the points already raised about technobabble. The important thing is character and motivation. If you stay true to both, and present a good story or situation that the viewer can get lost in, audiences generally WON'T CARE right off the bat if your plot device is technically accurate or feasible. Eventually, they probably will, but that's AFTER they've enjoyed the story and absorbed its dramatic impact. Of course, this being STAR TREK, eventually someone will quibble. It's the nature of the beast. But honestly, if you REALLY feel the need to detail us to death with pseudo-science or what-have-you, make that one of the last things you do to the script (i.e. research the details AFTER you've fully developed the human interaction and emotion). Just my opinion, mind ya. ;)

And about actors being "in shape": pears are shapes. :) Seriously, come on. I admit I notice it at beginnings of episodes, but if the story's involving enough and you care about the character, as you progress it becomes much less of an issue.

And as a former actor myself (mostly theater, some commercial but all locally Dallas, so no, you most likely have never seen me :D ), I can assure you that no matter how much YOU notice someone's gut or double chin while you're streaming a free video on the Net, the actor him or herself is WAY MORE AWARE OF IT than you are. Every time. And they're probably doing something about it if they're intending to reprise their roles. Technically, I suppose the military aspect of STAR TREK would lead to some level of fitness among the crew, but if you're worried about that, then you're setting truly unfair standards for a fan production. IOW, until food synthesizers are status quo, the fact remains that there is a Burger King on every corner. ;)
 
John Connor, you only like time travel stories because time travel saved your LIFE! :lol:

Things I want:

EXPLORATION! SCIENCE FICTION! "Strange new worlds... new life, and new civilizations"!

Mirror Universe Stories (but not alternate universe stories that violate cannon).

Non Starfleet folks- like the Merchant Service guys on "Intrepid".

Movie era! How you doin', Hathaway?

Animated fanfilms

TAS stuff

Real sets OR green screen- don't care!

Trek by folks who love Trek- no matter what shape they're in.

What I don't want-

TIME TRAVEL- it almost never makes sense and it's almost always a dramatic cheat when you can do whatever you want to your characters knowing in the last scene you're going to "restore the timeline" and everybody will be alive again.

The Guardian of Forever- I think it's only been used in 2 fanfilms (OGAM and NV's IHW) but that's enough. Unless you have a REALLY good idea.

Franz Joseph designs- sorry, I hate those odd-numbered nacelle ships.

Re-used lines. This is the worst. I don't ever want to hear about the Kobayashi Maru, needs of the many, first best destiny, etc. ever again. It screams fanfilm way more that cardboard sets or Starfleet officers with love handles.

WAR. What is it good for? Seriously, what is there left for Trek (or anyone) to say about it? Modern Trek has been mired in war ever since DS9. It's an easy way to pump conflict into a script, but it really isn't very TREK. Roddenberry would be spinning in his grave.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top