• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Theory why spore drive isn‘t used later on in Star Trek Universe

I wouldn’t mind if DIS took something from established Trek and improved on it but I’ve yet to witness it. Klingons are worse, the jury is still out on Pike and Spock, Terran Empire is more jokey than ever, Sarek is not great, Vulcan force communication and young Spock Harry Potter dragons are a joke etc etc. More than an imagination is needed to erase this nonsense from canon
 
I wouldn’t mind if DIS took something from established Trek and improved on it but I’ve yet to witness it. Klingons are worse, the jury is still out on Pike and Spock, Terran Empire is more jokey than ever, Sarek is not great, Vulcan force communication and young Spock Harry Potter dragons are a joke etc etc. More than an imagination is needed to erase this nonsense from canon

You should probably stop watching if you’re not enjoying it.
 
I wouldn’t mind if DIS took something from established Trek and improved on it but I’ve yet to witness it. Klingons are worse, the jury is still out on Pike and Spock, Terran Empire is more jokey than ever, Sarek is not great, Vulcan force communication and young Spock Harry Potter dragons are a joke etc etc. More than an imagination is needed to erase this nonsense from canon
So, I guess, you're not enjoying the show?
 
I wouldn’t mind if DIS took something from established Trek and improved on it but I’ve yet to witness it. Klingons are worse, the jury is still out on Pike and Spock, Terran Empire is more jokey than ever, Sarek is not great, Vulcan force communication and young Spock Harry Potter dragons are a joke etc etc. More than an imagination is needed to erase this nonsense from canon
Can you go rant somewhere else?
 
I remember when ENTERPRISE first started I didn’t really enjoy watching it and stopped after 9 episodes. I didn’t even look back until 8 years later when I set out to watch every production of Trek ever made prior to Abrams’ first film coming out.

In retrospect, VOYAGER was an even bigger chore to get through.
 
Nope. This is a tailored crisis - tailored for a starship with a jump drive. You need the ship to deal with the radioactive rain of rocks, and furthermore you need the ship to be packing a dark matter asteroid.

It's a step-by-step plan with, if not split-second, then at least minute timing. If not for the careful guidance of the Red Things, a starship with the means to deflect the radioactive ringfall would not have arrived at Terralysium at the exact minute required to complete this step of the quest.

We're yet to see whether all the Red Things are directly related to carefully orchestrated quest steps. But the spore drive is front and center there: unless Connolly got the distances wrong (a distinct possibility, considering the dialogue in "New Eden"), the second Red Thing apparently wasn't even one of the original seven, but an all-new signal, in any case appearing in such a way as to force the use of the spore drive. Everybody is seeing these signals, including Klingons and Terralysian primitives, but only the Discovery out of all the assets in the universe is in a position to act on them. And rather clearly because she is being put in that position.

Plenty of suspects for who is doing the putting. Spore Aliens who want to regulate Starfleet use of the technology - we've seen one who claims to be such. Do-gooders who subcontract Starfleet to Quantum Leap and Put Right What Is About To Go Wrong when they Gods Themselves are too busy - we've seen the angelic connection and, in a seemingly unrelated thread, the Preserver obelisk (now upside down and glowing red, so Preserver Satanists?). Spock - he's explicitly in on it somehow, he's a sensitive individual who might be doing mushrooms, and we know mere mortal individuals plugged into the mycelial net can work miracles. And then Starfleet/Section 31 - they are up and about, they may soon be revealed to be manipulating Spock, and they would be the only Alpha Quadrant regulars other than our main heroes and L'Rell who actually know the spore drive exists.

Any of these players could have enough clout to put a stop to Starfleet use of the tech. None can touch the existence of the tech, though - the stakes there are the highest ones imaginable, as all the universes vitally depend on the tech continuing! But this is also reassuring, as if the continuing could even in theory be in jeopardy, the repercussions would have been felt already. Not even an Evil Stamets can put much of a dent in this, as we so readily observe.

Timo Saloniemi
I can't decide if you're giving the showrunners far too MUCH credit here, far too LITTLE, or some strange hybrid of both. But at any rate - Blah. :razz:
 
It seems that they are setting up an ethical reason not to use the drive, perhaps it's destroying a pocket universe or something.
 
I remember when ENTERPRISE first started I didn’t really enjoy watching it and stopped after 9 episodes. I didn’t even look back until 8 years later when I set out to watch every production of Trek ever made prior to Abrams’ first film coming out.

In retrospect, VOYAGER was an even bigger chore to get through.
The real problem with Enterprise was it followed directly on the heels of Voyager and it really wasn't different enough to set itself apart in the short-term. Coming back at it years later enables one to view the show with eyes that are not suffering from long term franchise fatigue.
 
No, but the very slim chances of them figuring out how to make it will.

Then again, the mycelial network is available to an infinite number of cultures and critters. So surely somebody somewhere is always using it, difficult or not.

Which makes one wonder why Stamets' use would get more attention than the others that necessary have preceded it or are concurrent with it. Unless we argue that it was the Mirror Stamets who actually did something exceptionally noteworthy with the network, and ours now gets the blame. But this is not how May originally introduced her grievance: it was all about Stamets' "flying".

Timo Saloniemi
 
It's looking like...
I was right, it was a red herring. Albeit one that's opened up a universe of magic forest life and potential means to seal off the network down the line.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top