• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TheGodBen Revisits Star Trek

Friday’s Child (***)

After deciding that they shouldn’t let the Prime Directive prevent them from making money, the Federation has chosen to negotiate a treaty with the Capellans, a tribal society that hasn’t even developed archery yet. Kirk, Spock, McCoy, and Ensign Ricky beam down to the planet where they learn that some Capellans have been conspiring with a Klingon seemingly named Klingon. Things get a little crazy, the king is murdered, Kirk decides to break the PD again by saving a woman’s life, and they run off into hills with a woman pregnant with McCoy’s child.

On the Enterprise, the crew discovers a Klingon ship loitering near the planet, but Scotty decides not to tell Kirk because reasons. Shortly after, they receive a distress signal that calls them away from the planet. After falling for this trap, they cleverly uncover that it is a trap, and Scotty decides to continue falling for the trap. Once they eventually decide to head back to the planet, they are blocked by a Klingon vessel, but there’s no battle as the Klingon ship model wasn’t ready yet.

This is a simple adventure story, but there’s no central theme or idea that holds it all together. There’s some fighting, some chasing, some rock sliding, some slapping, some archery, and some vaporising, but none of it really means anything. There’s no message, there’s no sci-fi concept to dig into, there’s just a bunch of action and character interactions. And it’s the character stuff that saves this episode from being dull, especially the scenes involving McCoy and “his” child.
 
McCoy slapping a pregnant woman should boost the episode by a star at least. :wtf:

I really couldn't get into this one. I found all of the action scenes repetitive, and the story didn't hold my interest either. I think McCoy and the slapee had some nice scenes together, but they don't save the episode for me.
 
Last edited:
Spock explains that to Kirk in the episode:

SPOCK: We cannot return him to Earth, Captain. He already knows too much about us and is learning more. I do not specifically refer to Captain Christopher, but suppose an unscrupulous man were to gain certain knowledge of man's future? Such a man could manipulate key industries, stocks, and even nations. and in so doing, change what must be. And if it is changed, Captain, you and I and all that we know might not even exist.​

Something about that resonated with me when I was thinking about what Kirk would do if he decided to stay in the past with Edith Keeler and had saved her from dying-what would Captain Kirk do after that? My guess is that he'd get involved with the progressive side in the Spanish Civil War, and then go to Spain and fight (as a part of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade.) Because of his tactical knowledge, and his natural charisma, he'd be the leader of the Brigade, and his skills might even help the progressive side in the war defeat Franco's side and make Spain free of fascism (on the other hand, this would make the Nazis and the Italians retrench-counterattacking and defeating the progressives.) Just an interesting idea I wanted to explore.

It's actually very rare to have any female character in TOS who isn't some kind of vague love interest for someone. If Uhura stands out because the censors had qualms about her getting involved in a mixed race relationship then her character is all the better for this. And what is the first thing they did with her character in the reboot? La plus ca change...

Spock and Uhura being involved was an extrapolation of what attraction they had to each other in 'The Man Trap' and the other episode in which they were playing music, and it worked better than Kirk & Uhura being the ones that might have been in love as shown in 'Plato's Stepchildren'.
 
Last edited:
Yeah that was one thing I thought the reboot had great insight into. I loved Spock and Uhura's little moments in Charlie X and The Naked Time, so it was a nice progression.
 
Last edited:
This is always what ruins the episode for me. I can't even think of a way it's meant to make sense.

Simple-they beamed Christopher and the air policeman back into their bodies at exact points, so that they would have no recollection of what happened to them or of the future..
 
Except that their bodies would then weigh twice as much, and their brains would contain memories of both futures simultaneously.
Simple?
 
It doesn't make sense. It's magic.
Lucian, is that you? Somebody draw a pentagram, quickly!
:devil:

The Transporter may be an incredible piece of science fiction technology, but there's still a scientific explanation at its core.
 
Lucian, is that you? Somebody draw a pentagram, quickly!
:devil:

The Transporter may be an incredible piece of science fiction technology, but there's still a scientific explanation at its core.
I'm saying it's application in the instance of returning Capt. Christopher and the Sgt. to the Earth doesn't make sense.
 
It makes sense, it just isn't very pleasant; the future versions of Capt Christopher and the guard ceased to exist upon attempting to beam into an area where a person already existed. It was a humane way for Kirk to deal with the situation, and since (the original) Capt Christopher and the guard continued to live, he wasn't even committing murder!
 
OR, since we know that there is another Capt. Christopher and guard on Earth, then history is put right, so why not keep Christopher and the guard on the ship and take them back to the 23rd century?
 
They should have returned them to earth before setting off for their little jaunt around the sun. It would have been far more responsible, far less complicated, and completely consequence free!
 
Metamorphosis (***½)

Until Janeway shows up and forcefully separates Nancy and the Companion.

.

Well, if Kes is still around, she might try to persuade Mommy to leave this conglomeration alone. It's not as if she would have any skin in the game, so I think she would be rather more sanguine about this hybrid than she was in supplying the coup de grace to Tuvix after losing it when talking to Janeway about her conflictedness, but ultimate need for Neelix to return.
 
the eventual TNG thread.
YRRQRB8.gif
 
That's right, I know that some people have wanted it for a while, and I've finally decided to do a The Naked Gun review thread. Not only that, I'll be reviewing all of Police Squad! as well. I reckon it will take me about eight months to complete the whole canon, maybe 10 if another season of House of Cards gets in the way.


Who Mourns for Adonais? (***½)

While charting an unexplored region of the galaxy, the Enterprise is grabbed and held in place by a giant hand. One thing is certain, it cannot be Donald Trump’s hand. Indeed not, it is the hand of the ancient Greek god Apollo. It seems that the Greek gods were aliens who settled on Earth millennia ago and influenced the development of western civilisation. See, interfering with primitive cultures isn’t such a bad thing. But the Greeks eventually turned their backs on their gods, so the gods left and lived alone on an isolated world with only goats for company. One by one, the gods faded away, with only Apollo holding out in the hope that humans would one day find this world and he would get to play god once again. Well, today’s his lucky day.

APOLLO [to Lt Palamas]: And for you, because you have the sensitivity to understand, I offer you more than your wildest dreams have ever imagined. You'll become the mother of a new race of gods. You'll inspire the universe. All men will revere you almost as a god yourself. And I shall love you for time without end, worlds without end. You shall complete me, and I you.​

You just met her this afternoon. I understand that you’ve lived alone with goats for thousands of years, you’d probably fall in love with anything wearing a skirt after all that time, but that’s no reason to rush into a commitment so quickly. There’s more than a hundred women on the ship you could choose from, and double the number of men. You are from ancient Greece, after all.

Apollo is like a crazy ex-boyfriend, and I speak from experience of having been one. He just can’t accept that humanity has moved on and doesn’t want to herd goats with him any more, so he tries to force humanity to love him again. Obviously, that only drives the humans further away. Well, most humans...

LT PALAMAS: I love him.​

You just met him this afternoon! I understand that Scotty has been letching after you and you’ve been trying to avoid him as he smells of stale scotch, but there are other fish in the sea. Obviously, Kirk is off limits as he’s your captain. Spock has that emotionless thing going on. McCoy is cantankerous. Sulu is, well, you know. Chekov has that ridiculous thing on his head... Okay, maybe a megalomaniac who will turn your friends and colleagues into slaves is your best choice.

Palamas and Scotty are the low points of this episode. Palamas falls in love with Apollo because she wants to become his baby factory. Meanwhile Scotty is crazily possessive of a woman who clearly has no interest in him romantically. But beyond that stuff, I enjoyed the story here. Maybe it’s because I am euphorically enlightened by my intelligence, but I liked the general theme of humanity turning their backs on gods and striking out on our own. And Lt Palamas does eventually turn on Apollo, slightly redeeming her character. There was also a nice scene for Uhura where it’s made clear that she’s an expert in the field of communications and not just the secretary.

SPOCK: All [phaser] banks maintain firing rate.​

I really don’t see the point of that order.

The God Things: 7
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top