After a decade of false starts on a new Chris Pine-led STAR TREK film, a new report today indicates Paramount may have closed the books on the Kelvin Timeline once and for all
blog.trekcore.com
Meh.
It's been obvious for a long time that Paramount had no serious plans for ST4. Too many start and stops. If they actually had an entertaining script, they would have put it into production long ago. With all the names attached at one point or another to star alongside the Kelvin cast, it's amazing it was never capitalized. Failing that, they could had done what was done with TWoK and take the best parts of them to make a new script and make a film out of that.
Paramount dragged their feet too too long. And I don't think they wanted to deal with the Anton Yelchin question either.
There's also the reality of making Star Trek that been revealed during the Kurtzman era.
Why make a movie when they can spend the same amount of money on a 10-episodes season and tell a story better? And not have to worry about airing it on P+ a month after hit hits theatres.
There's probably still money with the Kelvinverse, in seeing where they ended up a decade later, and a way to tie the movies into a more coherent arc. And if they wanted to explore a Federation that was more militant and undemocratic, the Kelvinvese was the perfect canvas for that, since it also would not upset the canon-obsessed with it being set in an alternate reality. But Paramount does not seem interested in that direction.
But it's interesting they want a clean slate. Since Paramount tried that with Section 31, and everyone hated that movie. So, I'm not sure what direction they could go in that they think will generate interest. Prequel fatigue exists in the fandom and the Toby Haynes film is pitched as an origins film.