• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The New Klingons

Do you like the design of these new Klingons? What was your gut reaction?

  • I liked them

    Votes: 127 46.4%
  • I did not like them

    Votes: 147 53.6%

  • Total voters
    274
Hmm, on second thought... the Hur'q invasion was in the 14th century.

And Worf said Klingon warriors killed their gods "a millenia [sic] ago." A thousand years before the 24th century would put the Klingon gods' demise in the 14th century. So maybe there is a correlation. :vulcan:

Kor

I kinda feel like it would be odd for the Klingons to talk about the Hur'q invasion and the gods which they killed as separate incidents if they were suppose to be the same species, though. They talk about the invasion and pillaging done by the Hur'q in very literal terms, but everything they say about the old gods is more legendary and mythic...and the fact they call them 'gods'.
 
They suck. Just like the uniforms. And appear to be needless continuity errors. Also like the crappy uniforms. But we'll see. Maybe they have explanations given in the episodes.
 
They suck. Just like the uniforms. And appear to be needless continuity errors. Also like the crappy uniforms. But we'll see. Maybe they have explanations given in the episodes.
I wonder why they chose not to give them hair? It's like they've gone for the ugliest versions of Klingon they could find.. but maybe they just belong to a particular sect or something.
 
Not every Klingon needs hair.
Not every Klingon needs hair, but some should have hair.

Its like suddenly every person, females and males, decided to shave all the hair off their body.

Its like they saw that one klingon in Into Darkness and decided that after this all klingons should be shaved. Even though there are concept art of Into Darkness klingons having hair and beard.
 
Not every Klingon needs hair, but some should have hair.

Its like suddenly every person, females and males, decided to shave all the hair off their body.

Its like they saw that one klingon in Into Darkness and decided that after this all klingons should be shaved. Even though there are concept art of Into Darkness klingons having hair and beard.
And Klingons in Into Darkness had hair too, under their helmets. Just the leader happened to not, as well as General Chang as another example.

Since these Klingons appear to be participating in some sort of ritual, my gut instinct is that this is not meant to represent the Empire as a whole.
It could be some lost cult or sect from earlier in Klingon history.
Ninja'd. Well put.
 
They suck. Just like the uniforms. And appear to be needless continuity errors. Also like the crappy uniforms. But we'll see. Maybe they have explanations given in the episodes.
I hope they don't. Strict continuity makes boring stories. We don't need to know why starship designers went through a weird phase where they got obsessed with the 1960s of Earth.
 
I don't think there should be some long-winded continuity-obsessed explanation that throws everything out of flow with a bunch of unneeded meaningless details. I know that we detail-oriented sci-fi aficionados tend to want that type of pointless exposition for some unfathomable reason. :wtf: But it contributes absolutely nothing to the actual story.

A quick throwaway soundbite one-liner will do just fine, thank you.

Kor
 
This. Even though I disagree with some of the creative choices, they don't need to try and explain them in the episodes.

They don't need to. No one would stop watching if they did. I want to meet the person who says "OMG! They said these Klingons are a genetic off-shoot! I refuse to watch this crappy show anymore!" Absolutely no one would do that. But it's not some weird idea that if it's the Prime timeline, it should look like the Prime timeline in terms of things like the appearance of the Klingons. But this is probably best seen as a reimagined Trek that is more or less like the Prime timeline in that Vulcan didn't get blown up, Kirk father and Spocks mother are alive, etc, but that's all. It's a third timeline, basically.
 
Explaining things, like why the uniforms look the way they do, is actually one of the things that the TOS Writer's Guide explicitly said not to do.

"Matt Dillon [of Gunsmoke] never identifies and discusses the breed of his horse before he rides off on it."​

What kind of boots Dillon is wearing is even more trivial than the breed of his horse!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top