The most disliked episode of Star Trek - Final Part

[BlueStuff]

Looks like I'm apparently a little too eager to save Miri!

 

[jep]

The Alternative Factor - 1
Miri - 4
Catspaw - 0
And the Children Shall Lead - 1

***********************************

The Alternative Factor. Because it may have sucked, but not nearly as badly as Catspaw.


.

 

[Harvey]

The Alternative Factor - 1
Miri - 5
Catspaw - 0
And the Children Shall Lead - 1

Killing "Miri." It's mediocre, not terrible. With a few tweaks (like dropping the entire parallel Earth angle that goes nowhere, it would be a perfectly good episode).

 

[Quinton O'Connor]

The Alternative Factor - 1
Catspaw - 0
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

"The Alternative Factor" gets my vote now because the others are two of my absolute least favorites, alongside the already-saved "The Way to Eden".

 

[Geck]

The Alternative Factor - 1
Catspaw - 1
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

I'm tempted to just abstain from this point on, but...Catspaw, I guess.

 

[Harvey]

The Alternative Factor - 1
Catspaw - 2
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

I'll vote for "Catspaw." I don't think it's truly appalling in the way that "And the Children Shall Lead" is, nor is it as incomprehensible as "The Alternative Factor."

 

[MANT!]

The Alternative Factor - 2
Catspaw - 2
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

Casting my vote for Alternative Factor.. if only for the haunting thought at the end..spending all eternity with a madman at your throat...

 

[Caligula]

So pleased to see that my least favorite episode of the series is doing so terribly! Because I've never shared the hate for "The Alternative Factor," I'll go ahead and help it out....

The Alternative Factor - 3
Catspaw - 2
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

 

[Fang66]

The Alternative Factor - 3
Catspaw - 3
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

Catspaw was I believe a halloween episode so I'll cut it some slack. The other two make me want to throw up in my mouth.

 

[Mr Silver]

The Alternative Factor - 4
Catspaw - 3
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

"The Alternative Factor", because it's better than the other two.

 

[Admiral Shran]

The Alternative Factor - 5
Catspaw - 3
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

The Alternative Factor gets saved with my vote. It does have a memorable ending and Catspaw is worse while And The Children Shall Lead is just a catastrophe.

Catspaw - 0
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

 

[Fang66]

Catspaw - 1
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

As the Admiral said.

 

[BlueStuff]

Catspaw - 2
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

Eurgh. I'll give a point to Catspaw. If held at gunpoint, I'd choose to watch that one.

 

[Admiral Shran]

Catspaw - 3
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

Catspaw - see reason above.

 

[Geck]

Catspaw - 4
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

Yeah. Not much to say, I'd like to stop thinking about both of these episodes now and move on to TNG.

 

[Harvey]

Catspaw - 5
And the Children Shall Lead - 0

Yeah, that was an easy choice. Game over.

 

[Quinton O'Connor]

And the children shall continue to be terrible.

 

[BlueStuff]

Unsurprising.

Set course for The Next Generation.

Engage!