I didn't believe the hero could look at a dead body and tell the man was gay. I didn't believe he wouldn't use more prompts (generalized guesses from the psychic that an eager victim seizes upon and unconsciously corrects.) Unfortunately, I did believe that a Christian would also believe in her spiritualist psychic cousin, without being aware that would qualify as sinful and ungodly. But that kind of unpleasant person is altogether common and doesn't need to visit my living room. I don't think I'm going for this one. Any dissents?