• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The least disliked episode of TNG - Season Seven

Eliminating Liaisons.

It has its moments but doesn't stand out much.

Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
Parallels
The Pegasus
Lower Decks
Thine Own Self
Eye of the Beholder
Preemptive Strike
All Good Things...
 
Is it possible to dislike a forgettable episode? To me, no, it's a forgettable episode. So I then had to find an episode that otherwise stank.

Parallels

Why?

Well, for most of the episode we're treated to Worf getting his own version of "Remember Me" except it's his past that's changing but he in the present remembers. The episode has a number of fine moments, right down to an obligatory "What if the Borg win?" world and the writer had a field day and nailing that version of Riker perfectly and horrifically. But one sweeps week scene doesn't make for an all-time classic... especially when our Enterprise fires on that version with the one damaged by the Borg, they babble about the warp core exploding except it's the bridge that first dissolves into a beautiful shade of gold that looks similar to what Golden Grahams cereal goes through once it hits the hydrochloric acid in one's stomach, long before the Engineering hull where the warp core is housed in.

And the one line that's the pudding's proverbial proof to this episode's truest reason for being disliked?

DATA: However, the uncertainty principle dictates that time is a variable in this equation. You may end up several days before the event or several days after. There is no way to tell.

Seriously?? That cop-out is so certain, that it'd get the biggest laughs if told on "Night Court". Maybe "Barney Miller" too, it is that ludicrously funny.

...And then comes in that ending, which now ushers in some convenient, shiny happy time travel because of some fliflamflingy with the space/time/Gouda continuum, yes it was that cheesy. When Data alluded to it earlier in the episode, it was like saying with a megaphone "Hey everyone, come look at me, see this huge bag filled with money? Now see this toilet? Give me a few minutes and you will see me flushing the bag down the toilet? With blackjack and--" sigh... Well, that's "Parallels". A novel take on parallel universes, which not only flushed it down the toilet with shoehorned contrivances to pretend it never really happened but they couldn't even pick up Professor Arturo... oh wait, he wouldn't get caught up in Q-Ball's antics for another year...




What's left:

Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
The Pegasus
Lower Decks
Thine Own Self
Eye of the Beholder
Preemptive Strike
All Good Things...
 
Eye of The Beholder needs to be deep sixed NOW. First of all, I've come to dislike the Worf\Troi romance and the soap opera flavor of TNG's final missions. From what I recall about this episode, some phenomena causes crewmembers to hallucinate, become angry at their partner, and attempt suicide. I don't remember the details but I'm sure the explanation was ridiculous and had no basis in real science.


Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
The Pegasus
Lower Decks
Thine Own Self
Preemptive Strike
All Good Things
 
I shall now launch Lower Decks out of the nearest airlock. Would have been a fine premise back around season four, but not for the final. I also couldn’t get past the horrible acting of the younger folk.

Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
The Pegasus
Thine Own Self
Preemptive Strike
All Good Things
 
Shame about Lower Decks, it's one of my favourites. Acting is indeed not top-notch, though.
Shame about Parallels, too, I always considered it a fun episode.

Removing "Preemptive Strike". It's not horrible, and it has some nice character moments, but the ending makes no sense, and Riker's concluding remarks are just stupid. "She thought she was doing the right thing"? So what? Most people think they do the right thing when they commit a wrongful act!

Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
The Pegasus
Thine Own Self
All Good Things
 
There are only a few really good episodes in S7 in my opinion. Only one of them remains here.
 
I'm more than happy to axe "Thine Own Self". It has a horribly stupid version of a no-win scenario ("Oh no, I have to tell a holographic representation of a real person to kill itself!!!"), and I really don't care about the aliens we meet and never see again.

Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
The Pegasus
All Good Things
 
While neither half of Gambit stands out as being especially better than the other, I'll give the second half the push, as the first half had just a little bit more in the way of mystery and suspense.

Gambit (I)
The Pegasus
All Good Things
 
Goodbye Gambit.

I liked it but it is the weakest of the remaining three. The mystery of Picard's death was a bit pointless, as if anyone believed he was actually dead, so him turning up alive was not a surprise. The cliffhanger was weird too, firing on the Enterprise ... of course Riker and/or Picard would make sure the ship would not be damaged. No suspense there.

The Pegasus
All Good Things
 
I don't want All Good Things to win. I appreciate its scope, seeing the past and future(Stewart really shines playing a cranky old man), and I like how it bookends the series with Q and the trial. That being said I dislike the technobabble and the Troi/Worf/Riker soap opera. I also think the series should have ended on the bridge. Yes these people care about each other and their relationships are important, but they are career officers exploring the unknown, boldly going forward.

The Pegasus.
 
I'm more than happy to axe "Thine Own Self". It has a horribly stupid version of a no-win scenario ("Oh no, I have to tell a holographic representation of a real person to kill itself!!!"), and I really don't care about the aliens we meet and never see again.

Gambit (I)
Gambit (II)
The Pegasus
All Good Things
If all one has to do is to order a holographic officer to sacrifice his life to save the ship, why couldn't Data or Geordi become full commanders? I didn't buy that either. In Coming of Age Wesley had to make choice to save one man in a crisis situation for the Academy 'pysch test'. That was better written in my view.
 
The only way I can see that test being at all meaningful is if Troi wasn't aware she was in the holodeck at the time. Hell, at least the KM scenario has the bridge blowing up around you if you take certain courses of action, and involves people (or does it?) outside your own ship.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top