The least disliked character of Enterprise

[BlueStuff]

Okay Trek fans, the episode and movie versions proved very popular, and here's the beginning of the character contest. The basic idea is your standard elimination game. I'll provide a list of main and some recurring characters and you need to eliminate your least favorite or the one you deem the 'worst.' Please provide an EXPLANATION for why you are eliminating your choice and be sure to copy and paste the list with your choice removed. Finally, leave at least 2 eliminations before you eliminate another one. Not a very accurate way of determining the best character, but a fun game nonetheless. No tactical voting! You cannot remove a character because you feel they would threaten your favorite character's chance to win. Pretty simple. Enjoy!

Winners
The Original Series - Leonard McCoy
The Next Generation - Data
Deep Space Nine - Quark
Voyager - B'Elanna Torres
Enterprise -

As with Voyager, thanks again to Admiral Shran for helping me to make this list.


Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Koss
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las
Vosk
Xindi Aquatic Councilor
Xindi-Insectoid Counciler
Xindi-Primate Counciler

 

[Lucky]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Koss
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las
Vosk
Xindi Aquatic Councilor
Xindi-Insectoid Counciler

Xindi-Primate Counciler - I thought the other Xindi were better

 

[DevilEyes]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Koss
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las
Xindi Aquatic Councilor
Xindi-Insectoid Counciler


Vosk - just say no to Space Nazis.

 

[Mr Silver]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las
Xindi Aquatic Councilor
Xindi-Insectoid Counciler


Koss is gone from the list because there was just something un-Vulcan about him, even for ENT. I always feel uncomfortable watching his and T-Pol's interactions.

 

[Skywalker]

Somebody keep Admiral Shran out of here before he eliminates all the good characters.

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las
Xindi Aquatic Councilor

Xindi-Insectoid Councilor - Why are any Xindi aside from Degra and Dolim even on this list?

 

[DevilEyes]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las
Xindi Aquatic Councilor


Future Guy - who the hell was he, anyway? Don't know, don't care. A mysterious silhouette does not a character make. I don't know why he is even on the list.

 

[Dion]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Future Guy
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Jannar
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las


Xindi Aquatic Councilor - Didn't think much of the Xindi Councilors, so I'm eliminating the last unnamed one.

 

[Skywalker]

DevilEyes forgot to take Future Guy off the list, so I'm fixing it.

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
T'Pol
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Jannar - Removing the last inconsequential Xindi Councilor, though Jannar seemed a decent fellow.

 

[Hopeful Romantic]

No Lorian?!

 

[Skywalker]

Ooo, good call. Any chance we could retroactively add him, BlueStuff?

 

[JRoss]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Dolim
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

T'Pol- The actress was so horrible that they had to re-write the character.

 

[Lucky]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Malik
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Dolim - I thought the show had better villains.

 

[Admiral Shran]

As with Voyager, thanks again to Admiral Shran for helping me to make this list.

You're very welcome again.

Somebody keep Admiral Shran out of here before he eliminates all the good characters.

It is my duty to make these games interesting.

No Lorian?!

Unfortunately, he was only in one episode, so he doesn't count as a recurring character.


Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Travis Mayweather
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Malik - if any villain on the show needs to go, it's him. Whiny, non-threatening and a joke of a villain. Brent Spiner totally stole the show from him as Arik Soong.

 

[DevilEyes]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Persis
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Travis Mayweather - someone is going to put him out of his misery sooner or later, so why not me right now.

 

[Lucky]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Daniels
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Persis - Not my favorite augment.

 

[Admiral Shran]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Porthos
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Daniels - the less said about the Temporal Cold War, the better.

 

[DevilEyes]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau
V'Las

Porthos - having a dog outlast a bunch of characters is a joke. You all know it, you just want to have the opportunity to crack jokes how 'Porthos is a better character than [insert character you hate]'. Yeah, right.

 

[Lucky]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Elizabeth Cutler
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau

V'Las - Never found this character particularly memorable.

 

[Hopeful Romantic]

No Lorian?!

Unfortunately, he was only in one episode, so he doesn't count as a recurring character.

Then why did you leave off the Female MACO Who Kept Getting Shot?

I protest!



(I don't see T'Les on the list either.)

 

[JRoss]

Jonathan Archer
Dr. Phlox
Malcolm Reed
Hoshi Sato
Trip Tucker
Degra
Maxwell Forrest
Major Hayes
Shran
Silik
Arik Soong
Soval
T'Pau

Elizabeth Cutler- If I've forgotten that they existed, they can't be that great.