• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The "K" Sound in Captain

Wild speculation: Maybe all dating back to "Cain," the first murderer in the Bible, and/or Genghis Khan?

I doubt it. As someone mentioned before, it's just a "striking" sound because of the way it's produced. It stands out to the ear, and it feels forceful to the tongue. Also, it's not exclusive to villains, but it used to make hero names sound stronger too. Think of titles for leaders like king, kaiser, captain, commander.
 
Those all have the letter O, but they use it to represent at least six distinct sounds (seven if you pronounced Sato's name the Japanese way, not that they ever did). So that doesn't count.

hJGGHBi.gif
 
But the planet's androids were based on the crew's thoughts and expectations, as read by the planet. Finnegan and Ruth acted the way Kirk imagined them, the Rigel II cabaret girls acted the way McCoy imagined them, etc. So it seems more likely that a person of Japanese heritage would default to imagining a generic samurai as a hero rather than a villain.
,
On the other hand, McCoy was "killed" by a Black Knight because he cast himself as a white knight protecting Tonia Barrows, and the planet gave him a suitable opponent. So it's possible that Sulu imagined himself as a heroic samurai and the planet sent a more antagonistic one after him. But that seems incongruous given that Sulu was otherwise always played as entirely Westernized in his interests, more likely to dream up Cardinal Richilieu as his adversary. It was just about the one time TOS went the Asian-stereotype route in writing him, and the only time it linked him to Japanese culture in particular.

Of course most Japanese people are mostly descended from Japanese peasants instead of from samurai or daimyo. And possibly 23rd century Japanese think of samurai as tyrannical agents of oppressive daimyo & shoguns instead of as noble heroes. In "Beatbox Bandits" the July 22, 2004 episode of Japanese series Samurai Champloo, travelers are caught trying to use counterfeit travel passes at a checkpoint on the road and are crucified. And from what I have read the shogun's government and its samurai officials and warriors, was brutal enough to have the death penalty for traveling without permits. So possibly in the era of TOS most Japanese descendants feel about samurai the same way that Chekov feels about Cossacks.

Besides Sulu could be part Korean, or part Chinese, or part___, well any east Asian ancestors of Sulu would likely think of Japanese iin the WWII era as being evil oppressiors and remember that the Japanse Bushido code at that time ws based on the samurai code.

And possibly in the era of TOS most English persons think of medieval knights as agents of their bosses in the nobiility and gentry oppressing the English peasants that most English persons are mostly descended from.

No, he was her security chief. Her first officer was Commander Cavit, who was killed in "Caretaker." That's why she appointed a former enemy, Chakotay, as her first officer. She would've had no reason to do that if Tuvok had been her XO -- which would have been unlikely given that his rank at the time was lieutenant.

Possibly you are interpreting wrongly the post you are responding to. POssibly it meant that Tuvok was Janeway's second in command in original drafts of the story before it was decided that Janeway would make Chakotay second in command.
 
Last edited:
For a moment I thought that this thread was going to be all about how Chekov pronounces the word Kapktain… :shrug:
 
^ In my headcanon, the DS9 station was one of an entire set of space stations constructed at the same time: Terok NOR, terok OR, terok XOR, and its slightly more distant relatives Terok AND, Terok NAND and terok NOT.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top