• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The "Hirogen" communications network... good lord, was that thing huge

Re: The "Hirogen" communications network... good lord, was that thing

The Kazon were not aware how much power reserves the Ocampa had.
For that matter, they had no reason to think that the energy barrier would go down in the first place (we don't know that either).
Also... how stupid can the Caretaker be?
Why provide the Ocampa with energy supplies from space instead of constructing geothermal power generation itself that would be able to sustain the Ocampa indefinitely?

Also... there are numerous Ocampa who went directly against the Caretaker's wishes and as a result would have already done some preliminary preparations before the energy reserves ran out (water on the other hand is something else and was never mentioned as being a problem - and they seem to have an ample supply of it underground to begin with - and more than enough technology to start figuring out how to create more via technology).

As for the Kazon emerging as a galactic power... doubtful.
The progression of the Ocampa and balance of power of that whole sector was disrupted by the arrival of Nacene (the Caretaker).
To that end, the continuing presence of the array and the Caretaker kept the Ocampa in stagnation mode for a long time - otherwise, they might have been on the level of the Federation by the time Voyager arrived - and the Kazon Ogla wouldn't be able to get to the planet or its kelbonite deposits.

By taking the array and the Caretaker out of the picture, Janeway effectively returned things to pre-Caretaker state, giving the Ocampa the chance to progress technologically.
And if the Kazon Ogla are still there... well, that would be their first problem to deal with upon returning to the surface.
For that matter, Kes decided went back to Ocampa at most 5 years and 11 months after Voyager's departure.
Which means the Ocampa would have to 'fend for themselves' for about 11 months until Kes gets back and encourages their mental and technological development - though they would already be on their way of doing the latter at the very least.
 
Re: The "Hirogen" communications network... good lord, was that thing

(Or, considering how functional this network was... If you could save your own sorry ass by making the internet disappear forever, should you? :devil:)

Just think if someone pulled that off somehow. They'd be more hated than Hitler. :p
 
Re: The "Hirogen" communications network... good lord, was that thing

(Voyager and the Maquis ship approach the Array. Two Kazon ships are there.)
TUVOK: The lead Kazon ship is hailing us, Captain.
JANEWAY: On screen.
JABIN [on viewscreen]: Have you come to investigate the entity's strange behaviour too, Captain?
JANEWAY: All we care about is getting home, Jabin. We're about to transport over to the Array to see if we can arrange it.
JABIN [on viewscreen]: I'm afraid I can not permit that.
JANEWAY: We have no dispute with you.
JABIN [on viewscreen]: I have a dispute with anyone who would challenge us.

They knew the frequency of the power bursts had been radically increasing for quite sometime until they stopped. The power bursts stopped so so they went to see if Caretaker was dead. They probably went to check if he was dead all the time. Yet Caretaker didn't kill them or kick them off Ocampa.
 
Re: The "Hirogen" communications network... good lord, was that thing

Again... power bursts are one thing, knowing how much of the food and power reserves the Ocampa had is something else (Jabin himself probably learned about food and power from Kes, but the actual amount... doubtful).
The only reason Janeway knew about the 5 years estimate was because the Ocampa or Kim and Torres told her, and the Ocampa told Kim and Torres in return.

As for the Caretaker not kicking the Kazon off the planet... well, I have to admit that was odd to say the least - but, at the same time, the Kazon were a minor inconvenience to him and he probably didn't care about them too much in the first place while he was still around and the underground barrier was intact.
 
Re: The "Hirogen" communications network... good lord, was that thing

After the power bursts stopped, then Caretaker started blasting the machinery on the other end to perfectly seal in the city.

So what if jabin didn't know that he would have to wait 5 years?

If the maje took the array, there would have been a big ass lovely "off" button.

He could have turned the shields off, or just continued to blast them from the array until they failed.

Point is.

There was a kazon settlement, and a profitable kazon mine, kazon refinery and kazon store on Ocampa, that they are going to still be there in 5 or 50 years still selling cormaline whether the Ocampa surfaced or not.

Waiting 10 minutes for Janeway to finish her business should seem easier than waiting 5 years to be surprised, by the millions of Ocampa looking for a handout and a new Cartaker, but that's just not how the kazon oogla swing.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top