• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Classic/Retro Pop Culture Thread

I love the Who. After the Beatles, my favorite band. Yeah they didn't really "hit it big" till the end of the Sixties, but it wasn't from lack of trying. Their mid Sixties output stands with the best of that time even if the US charts don't reflect it. It's been said they founded both Heavy Metal and Punk. Quadrophenia is a masterpiece. My first wife was part of the Mod revival of the 80's and really got me into that part of the Who's legacy.
 
Coming to us three weeks in advance of entering the Hot 100 is the spankin' new single by Spanky & Our Gang, "Like to Get to Know You":

Such a pleasant piece of sunshine pop, which I'm glad is still around in '68.

Wonderful song. You call it "sunshine pop" but its rather moody in places, especially with the string section.


Star Trek
"Assignment: Earth"Originally aired March 29, 1968
Earth date: 1968

Solid end to season two with a fascinating character in Gary Seven.


Get Smart "Die, Spy"
Originally aired March 30, 1968

Now this was a genuine parody episode, not a Wiki reviewer trying to make a parody out of a spoofy title or some coincidental bit of story business. And not just of fellow NBC show I Spy, but also of rival network ABC (barely disguised as Atrocities, Cruelties, and Brutalities). Stu Gilliam seems to be deliberately channeling Bill Cosby; and while I've never sat and watched I Spy, I recognized the little montage with the cities and their names superimposed on the ping-pong playing as a play on the show's title sequence.

One wonders why Get Smart did not spoof its network-mate earlier in its run, as "Die, Spy" premiered a little over two weeks before I Spy aired its final, first-run episode on April 15, 1968.

"Mony Mony," Tommy James & The Shondells
(#3 US; #1 UK)

Never fond of this song.

I acknowledged that they'd arrived by the turn of the decade...but the Beatles and the Stones owned the decade. You can put a lot of qualifiers in to justify it, but with all the great and influential artists in the '60s, placing the Who third to those two seems like an odd fit.

As far as rock bands go, I see no reason why they would not rank at #3 in terms of growth / innovation (already covered), landmark tracks that not only helped establish the "British Invasion" as a serious musical force, created songs that gave a voice to teenagers and social / personal problems few to none covered (e.g., "My Generation", "Substitute", etc.). While other acts either sparked, then quickly faded (Cream), were always climbing, but never reaching a consistent high level (The Animals), or were hit and miss (The Kinks), The Who--despite internal issues--not only soldiered on, but were changing the genre along the way. That is a significant set of credits.


Commercially, the Supremes would belong up there with the Beatles and Stones; influentially, Dylan (and you'd have to sell me on the Stones belonging up there with him and the Beatles).

Well, if you're going by sales, you could place The Monkees up there, since there were a couple of years where they were outselling The Beatles and the Stones. The point being that ranking includes several factors, not just checking the box next to commercial appeal; The Who's overall feat in such a loaded, competitive decade left them soaring above innumerable acts.
 
Their newest single, "Forever Came Today," is still climbing the chart 50 years ago this week, and I saved this video for the occasion:
Not one of their most memorable songs, but that's definitely the sound of my 60s.

Coming to us three weeks in advance of entering the Hot 100 is the spankin' new single by Spanky & Our Gang, "Like to Get to Know You":
Another strong element of my internal 60s soundtrack. A very easygoing sound and sentiment.

At one point Charlie, who sports a Chaplinesque look, swallows his clarinet's mouthpiece and emits squeaks.
Reminds me of Willie Whistle. :rommie:

In their encore performance, the Supremes show off their versatility by performing a tribute-by-medley to composer Fats Waller:
That's a nice, and long, performance. I love "Honeysuckle Rose."

This week gives us our striking new credits sequence:
Very nice, and appropriately surreal.

The academy uniforms in the episode look quite Trekkish, which is interesting...Trek wasn't being shown in the UK yet.
Well, the producers had probably seen it or seen parts of it, or at least stills from it.

Despite the negative comparisons to Peel, Tara defends herself a lot better tan Batgirl did, I'm afraid.
Tara was fine. Her only problem was that she was not Emma Peel. But nobody is Emma Peel.

This episode generally scratches the sign o' the times itch, with talk of acid, head shops, and the generation gap.
I watched Ironside hardly at all back in the day and Raymond Burr seems so stuffy that it's funny to think his show was so groovy. :rommie:

The good news: Michael Dunn is the villain in this one.
Oooh, I love Michael Dunn.

Well...that's it for Tarzan. The show could be pretty weak at times, but overall I'd say that it was enjoyable and a worthwhile watch. Highlights included the early episodes with the regular setting and additional cast members; the Supremes; and of course, the now-legendary Giant Clam.
It does seem pretty entertaining. I'll have to pay more attention if it ever shows up on one of my channels.

but also of rival network ABC (barely disguised as Atrocities, Cruelties, and Brutalities).
There's the Third Spy Network. I remember getting a big kick out of that.

I don't remember this one. Easy to listen to, but nothing special.

I had forgotten about this one, but I like it. Definitely the sound o' the times.

Not exactly one of Stevie's best.

"Mony Mony," Tommy James & The Shondells
Nice party song. They've done better, but it's also part of my internal soundtrack. I somehow connect to the theme from the Saturday-morning Hardy Boys cartoon.

I'm planning to take my time getting to both films, to give each the attention it deserves.
Oh, yeah, you must see both of these. Both are amazing classics.
 
You call it "sunshine pop"
Not
just
me.

landmark tracks that not only helped establish the "British Invasion" as a serious musical force
See, that's why I used the term "critical hindsight" several posts back on this subject. The Who barely made a blip on the American radar during the British Invasion period. It's easy to retroactively insert them as a major force in that part of the decade after they've done something like Tommy, but by that point the British Invasion was a major musical movement or three in the past. The Who simply were not playing on the same field as the Beatles or the Stones for the bulk of the decade.

To look at how the Rolling Stone 100 Greatest Artists list ranks some acts known largely for their work in the mid-to-late '60s:

1) The Beatles
2) Bob Dylan

4) The Rolling Stones

6) Jimi Hendrix (Hello, innovation and influence!)
7) James Brown

9) Aretha Franklin

12) The Beach Boys (Oh yeah, remember them? Pet Sounds, anyone? A far more natural third to the Beatles and Stones as '60s pop bands go.)

21) Otis Redding

29) The Who​

Well, the producers had probably seen it or seen parts of it, or at least stills from it.
If that's the case, it would explain why they specifically look like pilot-era Trek, since there were a lot of promotional photos with those uniforms.

I watched Ironside hardly at all back in the day and Raymond Burr seems so stuffy that it's funny to think his show was so groovy. :rommie:
It was dealing with issues of its time, in an arguably less reactionary manner than Dragnet.

I don't remember this one. Easy to listen to, but nothing special.
Hasn't made much of an impression on me yet. It's a charting B-side, and it sounds like one.

I had forgotten about this one, but I like it. Definitely the sound o' the times.
Definitely an obscuro and one-hit wonder, but yeah. And here's a fun fact that I just stumbled across: It was a cover of a Zombies song!

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Not exactly one of Stevie's best.
Not by his own high bar, but a perfectly enjoyable single.

Nice party song. They've done better, but it's also part of my internal soundtrack.
Definitely a stone-cold classic of the period.

Oh, yeah, you must see both of these. Both are amazing classics.
I have seen both...I own 2001. I'm just planning to give each a proper 50th anniversary watch and review.

Almost forgot to include: In my additional layering in of songs at the Top 30 level, we have a couple more odd things in the weekly selections list that didn't get covered on their debut weeks.

"I'm Gonna Make You Love Me," Madeline Bell
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(Charted Feb. 10, 1968; #26 US; #32 R&B; an earlier and more modestly charting version of the song that Diana Ross & the Supremes and the Temptations will team up to take to #2 on both charts in late '68 / early '69)

"Soul Serenade," Willie Mitchell
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(Charted Mar. 9, 1968; #23 US; #32 AC; #10 R&B)
 
Last edited:
If that's the case, it would explain why they specifically look like pilot-era Trek, since there were a lot of promotional photos with those uniforms.

As I said, contrary to popular belief, creators usually try to avoid copying what other people have done recently, so that kind of similarity is usually evidence that they weren't aware of each other. But contemporary creators are all swimming in the same pool of cultural influences, so similarities are hard to avoid. After all, there must've been some prior cultural precedent that led Bill Theiss to think that turtleneck jerseys and black trousers would read as military uniforms to the audience. So the Avengers designers were probably influenced by the same precedent.
 
12) The Beach Boys (Oh yeah, remember them? Pet Sounds, anyone? A far more natural third to the Beatles and Stones as '60s pop bands go.)
Interesting thought. You're right that their later careers influenced the perspective on their early careers.

It was dealing with issues of its time, in an arguably less reactionary manner than Dragnet.
That wouldn't take much arguing. :D

Definitely an obscuro and one-hit wonder, but yeah. And here's a fun fact that I just stumbled across: It was a cover of a Zombies song!
Wow, interesting indeed. Even more interesting is that there are (at least) three volumes of Zombies recordings....

"I'm Gonna Make You Love Me," Madeline Bell
That's a fine version of the song, it's just that there's no comparing anyone to Diana Ross.

"Soul Serenade," Willie Mitchell
Pleasant, but all intro. :rommie:
 
That's a fine version of the song, it's just that there's no comparing anyone to Diana Ross.
I think it sounds good enough that it deserved to do better before the Supremes and Temptations got ahold of it.

Pleasant, but all intro. :rommie:
This one hasn't really caught on with me yet. These are the peak hits by both artists, so we likely won't be hearing anything else from them in these parts.

You'll be happy to know that "Soul Serenade" does have a version with words:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

ETA:
You're right that their later careers influenced the perspective on their early careers.
I'm not denying that the Who were one of the more important and influential groups in their own time, but lumping them in with the British Invasion is chronologically off. Their first album was released in the UK in Dec. '65, and in slightly altered form in the US (where it didn't chart) in Apr. '66. The "My Generation" single was released in the US in Nov. '65, and only got to #74 on the Hot 100 in early '66. By that point, we were well into the Folk Rock era and fast approaching psychedelia; the Beatles had done Rubber Soul and were making Revolver. The "British Invasion" period was over, British bands were established and had already transformed the American music scene. The Who were simply not a factor in that earlier phase when British groups were taking America by storm...they were still playing clubs in London. Throwing a video of the Who performing "My Generation" into a documentary about the British Invasion ca. 1964 is pure retconning. They made their mark in the post-psychedelic era.

They weren't part of the Invasion. They were part of the Occupation.

_______

12 O'Clock High
"Back to the Drawing Board"
Originally aired February 7, 1966
Xfinity said:
A civilian master technician (Burgess Meredith) invents a device that allows B-17's to bomb accurately through cloud cover.
...and he's going to use it to rob the Gotham Mint! WAUGHK! WAUGHK! WAUGHK!

Britt is back, and Stovall gets some more time in the cockpit.

This episode features enemy-side scenes with a German colonel played by Alf Kjellin, who must have been typecast, because he was also on Tarzan as a Na...er, person who did some very bad things a long time ago.

A trope I've noticed on this show...if there's a major mission that Gallagher doesn't go on in the middle of the episode, it's gonna go horribly wrong as a plot complication. "No, I'm not going up today...it's Act II, that'd be suicide."

The Germans figure out how to triangulate on the emissions from the radar-equipped bomber, and as a countermeasure Meredith's Dr. Rink invents chaff.

_______

51st Anniversary Viewing

_______

Selections from Billboard's Hot 100 for the week that the episodes aired:
1. "Happy Together," The Turtles
2. "Dedicated to the One I Love," The Mamas & The Papas
3. "Penny Lane," The Beatles
4. "There's a Kind of Hush," Herman's Hermits
5. "Bernadette," Four Tops
6. "This Is My Song," Petula Clark
7. "For What It's Worth (Stop, Hey What's That Sound)," Buffalo Springfield
8. "Strawberry Fields Forever," The Beatles
9. "Somethin' Stupid," Frank & Nancy Sinatra
10. "Western Union," The Five Americans

12. "I Think We're Alone Now," Tommy James & The Shondells
13. "The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)," Harpers Bizarre
14. "I Never Loved a Man (The Way I Love You)," Aretha Franklin
15. "Baby I Need Your Lovin'," Johnny Rivers
16. "I've Been Lonely Too Long," The Young Rascals
17. "Sock It to Me, Baby!," Mitch Ryder & The Detroit Wheels
18. "Jimmy Mack," Martha & The Vandellas
19. "A Little Bit Me, a Little Bit You," The Monkees
20. "Love Is Here and Now You're Gone," The Supremes
21. "The Return of the Red Baron," The Royal Guardsmen
22. "California Nights," Lesley Gore
23. "Ruby Tuesday," The Rolling Stones
24. "The Love I Saw in You Was Just a Mirage," Smokey Robinson & The Miracles
25. "Beggin'," The Four Seasons
26. "Dry Your Eyes," Brenda & The Tabulations
27. "Then You Can Tell Me Goodbye," The Casinos
28. "With This Ring," The Platters
29. "Ups and Downs," Paul Revere & The Raiders
30. "Sweet Soul Music," Arthur Conley
31. "The Hunter Gets Captured by the Game," The Marvelettes
33. "Let's Fall in Love," Peaches & Herb
34. "At the Zoo," Simon & Garfunkel

40. "Sit Down, I Think I Love You," The Mojo Men

46. "Darling Be Home Soon," The Lovin' Spoonful
47. "Niki Hoeky," P.J. Proby
48. "Don't You Care," The Buckinghams
49. "I'm a Man," The Spencer Davis Group

51. "The Girl I Knew Somewhere," The Monkees
52. "Gonna Give Her All the Love I've Got," Jimmy Ruffin

55. "On a Carousel," The Hollies

63. "I'll Try Anything," Dusty Springfield
64. "Close Your Eyes," Peaches & Herb
65. "Get Me to the World on Time," The Electric Prunes

72. "Friday on My Mind," The Easybeats

81. ""Dead End Street Monologue/Dead End Street," Lou Rawls

83. "You Got What It Takes," The Dave Clark Five

86. "My Back Pages," The Byrds

88. "Somebody to Love," Jefferson Airplane
89. "Yellow Balloon," The Yellow Balloon

100. "No Time Like the Right Time," The Blues Project



Leaving the chart:
  • "The Beat Goes On," Sonny & Cher
  • "Epistle to Dippy," Donovan
  • "Gimme Some Lovin'," The Spencer Davis Group
  • "It Takes Two," Marvin Gaye & Kim Weston
  • "Kind of a Drag," The Buckinghams
_______

The Monkees
"Monkees on the Line"
Originally aired March 27, 1967
Wiki said:
Hired by a telephone answering service, the Monkees are soon plunged into mix-ups, hang-ups and crossed wires leading to pursuit by a crooked bettor (Milton Frome).

Nothing much to see here. Put in charge of an answering service unsupervised and with no training, the boys get involved with a girl threatening suicide who turns out to be an actress and a booking operation that surrepitiously places bets through the service. Perhaps noteworthy for having the least threatening use of the "red button" gag ever (it causes a bed to come out of the wall).

Look out, here comes one of the previous week's songs (and I couldn't find an episode-specific clip):

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

_______

The Rat Patrol
"The Double or Nothing Raid"
Originally aired March 27, 1967
H&I said:
A German colonel captures Moffitt and plans to use him as bait to double-cross the Rat Patrol during a prisoner exchange.

Subbing for Dietrich in scheming against the Patrol is Ben Wright as Colonel Voss.

Moffitt gets captured while trying to conduct an operation dressed as a German officer at a German field camp on the desert set. His getaway is foiled by not having much room to drive the vehicle, so he quickly crashes. His would-be execution takes place on location, giving the Patrol plenty of room for their Jeeps to come barrelling in for an unsuccessful initial rescue attempt. After that, it's back and forth between the set and location for the entire episode, as the Germans try to keep Moffitt disoriented as to where he's being held.

The Patrol loses their prisoner, so Troy dresses as a German officer for the exchange.

They give us a specific date in this one, FWIW...March 7, 1942.

TV Fu seems to be standard German soldier training.

_______

TGs1e29.jpg
"Author, Author"
Originally aired March 30, 1967
Wiki said:
For an upcoming audition, Ann needs a comedic line, and seeks help from both Donald and a washed-up comedy writer, neither of which prove to be adequate.
That...pretty much covers the entire episode premise. I suppose it's noteworthy that the humor of the badly written humor in the episode relies on the audience never hearing a full example of either writer's material, just out-of-context hints that are meant to convey how bad it is.

In the climax, when Ann does her impromptu run-on story about everything she's been through in the episode (a standard bit of business for her), I thought that the people running the audition were going to think that was her original comedy material.

This episode is the last appearance of Bonnie Scott as Judy Bessemer.

"Oh, Donald" count: 4

_______
 
Last edited:
I think it sounds good enough that it deserved to do better before the Supremes and Temptations got ahold of it.
Yeah, it's funny that it didn't do better. Madeline Bell might have had a different career.

You'll be happy to know that "Soul Serenade" does have a version with words:
Now that's more like it.

They weren't part of the Invasion. They were part of the Occupation.
:rommie: At least they didn't shoot a bunch of Bostonians over on State Street.....

The Germans figure out how to triangulate on the emissions from the radar-equipped bomber, and as a countermeasure Meredith's Dr. Rink invents chaff.
He's actually a stranded Vulcan. He went on to invent Velcro.

Nothing much to see here. Put in charge of an answering service unsupervised and with no training, the boys get involved with a girl threatening suicide
That's kind of heavy.

Look out, here comes one of the previous week's songs (and I couldn't find an episode-specific clip):
Deja vu all over again.

Moffitt gets captured while trying to conduct an operation dressed as a German officer at a German field camp on the desert set. His getaway is foiled by not having much room to drive the vehicle, so he quickly crashes. His would-be execution takes place on location, giving the Patrol plenty of room for their Jeeps to come barrelling in for an unsuccessful initial rescue attempt. After that, it's back and forth between the set and location for the entire episode, as the Germans try to keep Moffitt disoriented as to where he's being held.
:rommie:

I suppose it's noteworthy that the humor of the badly written humor in the episode relies on the audience never hearing a full example of either writer's material, just out-of-context hints that are meant to convey how bad it is.
You'd think they wouldn't have any trouble coming up with bad jokes. Or maybe they were afraid it would be too similar to the good jokes. :rommie:
 
I recognized an ambiguity in my laziness typing that up.

_______

Selections from Billboard's Hot 100 for 55 years ago this week:
1. "He's So Fine," The Chiffons
2. "Our Day Will Come," Ruby & The Romantics
3. "The End of the World," Skeeter Davis
4. "South Street," The Orlons

6. "Baby Workout," Jackie Wilson
7. "In Dreams," Roy Orbison
8. "You're the Reason I'm Living," Bobby Darin
9. "Rhythm of the Rain," The Cascades

11. "Puff (The Magic Dragon)," Peter, Paul & Mary
12. "Do the Bird," Dee Dee Sharp

17. "I Wanna Be Around," Tony Bennett
18. "Mr. Bass Man," Johnny Cymbal
19. "Laughing Boy," Mary Wells

21. "Twenty Miles," Chubby Checker
22. "Don't Say Nothin' Bad (About My Baby)," The Cookies
23. "Walk Like a Man," The Four Seasons
24. "Let's Limbo Some More," Chubby Checker

26. "Pipeline," The Chantays

28. "Wild Weekend," The Rebels
29. "One Broken Heart for Sale," Elvis Presley
30. "I Will Follow Him," Little Peggy March
31. "Sandy," Dion

33. "I Got What I Wanted," Brook Benton
34. "Don't Set Me Free," Ray Charles

37. "On Broadway," The Drifters
38. "Ruby Baby," Dion

41. "Watermelon Man," Mongo Santamaria Band

44. "Linda," Jan & Dean
45. "Surfin' U.S.A.," The Beach Boys

52. "Tom Cat," The Rooftop Singers
53. "Let's Turkey Trot," Little Eva
54. "Foolish Little Girl," The Shirelles
55. "Greenback Dollar," The Kingston Trio

57. "Mama Didn't Lie," Jan Bradley
58. "Boss Guitar," Duane Eddy & The Rebelettes
59. "Alice In Wonderland," Neil Sedaka

78. "If You Wanna Be Happy," Jimmy Soul

81. "Killer Joe," The Rocky Fellers
82. "Losing You," Brenda Lee

88. "Reverend Mr. Black," The Kingston Trio

93. "Two Faces Have I," Lou Christie

97. "Come and Get These Memories," Martha & The Vandellas


Leaving the chart:
  • "The Bird's the Word," The Rivingtons
  • "The Gypsy Cried," Lou Christie
  • "Hitch Hike," Marvin Gaye
  • "Walk Right In," The Rooftop Singers
_______

12 O'Clock High
"Twenty-Fifth Mission"
Originally aired February 14, 1966
Xfinity said:
A talented pilot (Bradford Dillman) suffering internal anxieties learns that a miscount means he must fly one more mission.

This premise sounds very familiar. This is one of those stories that I'd swear they already did a time or three.

12och29.jpg
Future Hulk-hunter...

12och30.jpg
...Ed from Ironside...

...Antoinette Bower...

...and Messerschmitts! Though we only see them in a bit of footage being viewed at Allied HQ. Their manufacturers are the target this week.

Britt plays tough with Dillman's major and decides that one of his missions doesn't qualify on the basis that all of his missions were milk runs or aborted. Dillman ultimately gets on the pathfinder mission and gives it his all, and proves his anxieties wrong by managing to survive despite his bomber being shot down. What I didn't catch was how Dillman managed to establish a reputation as being the only pilot in the group skilled enough at low-level flying to perform that risky mission while establishing a long record of having avoided danger.

This week we get a base doc who isn't Barney Phillips.

_______
 
Last edited:

Still, "sunshine" anything attached to that song is misplaced.

See, that's why I used the term "critical hindsight" several posts back on this subject. The Who barely made a blip on the American radar during the British Invasion period. It's easy to retroactively insert them as a major force in that part of the decade after they've done something like Tommy, but by that point the British Invasion was a major musical movement or three in the past. The Who simply were not playing on the same field as the Beatles or the Stones for the bulk of the decade.

I'm not denying that the Who were one of the more important and influential groups in their own time, but lumping them in with the British Invasion is chronologically off. Their first album was released in the UK in Dec. '65, and in slightly altered form in the US (where it didn't chart) in Apr. '66. The "My Generation" single was released in the US in Nov. '65, and only got to #74 on the Hot 100 in early '66. By that point, we were well into the Folk Rock era and fast approaching psychedelia; the Beatles had done Rubber Soul and were making Revolver. The "British Invasion" period was over, British bands were established and had already transformed the American music scene. The Who were simply not a factor in that earlier phase when British groups were taking America by storm...they were still playing clubs in London. Throwing a video of the Who performing "My Generation" into a documentary about the British Invasion ca. 1964 is pure retconning. They made their mark in the post-psychedelic era.

I look at history from the perspective of when/how it happened first, not as it would be seen in the years to follow. A band's influence on a musical movement of its time often predates chart listings, as seen with The Who, the early Rolling Stones, et al. You have to look at actual events on the ground, and how it fueled and threaded through movements, not end results (i.e. chart listings) which do not paint the full picture. On that charting note, chart listing is no hard measure of the influence of the artist or work, otherwise songs such as "Winchester Cathedral" (US #1 & UK #4 in 1966) "The Ballad of the Green Berets" (US #1 in 1966) or "Mony Mony" (UK #1 in 1968) would be considered significant to the progression of culture & music at time released. They were not.

On the other hand, The Who were not only a known band in Europe, with one of the busiest touring schedules (and exposure) of any 60s band, but were one the few white rock groups to first and successfully appeal to the growing, increasingly vocal counterculture / disaffected youth long before acts like The Beatles decided to full on move from their "yeah, yeah, yeah" period and play with experimentation. That cannot be brushed aside or underestimated in the changes affecting European youth culture, and the type of music they played at a time that what would later be called "hard rock", metal not to mention an innovative weaving of jazz chord progressions (likely an orbiting influence from Townshend's father) to pretty much create their own sub-genre of music. This happened in the 60s--it was not some dreamy look back at the period.

The Who were having an impact in the U.S. as well, not only with audiences, but the often-jagged edged news media, with a 1967 article from the San Francisco Examiner going as far to say:

"The Who, the most impressive British group..."

This is 1967. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band was already on the market, The Rolling Stones had a string of strong LP's up to that point (including 1966's Aftermath, arguably tied for the group's best album of the 60s), Cream's Fresh Cream made their presence more than known at the end of '66, yet the Examiner (who were not alone) rated The Who as the most impressive. This debate could go on and on, and I can certainly post endless period reports similar to the one above, but any objective analysis of the British Invasion does not exist sans the impact of The Who--a group that continued to innovate for the rest of the 60s, and was one of its very few survivors to become a greater act after their decade of origin (incredibly rare) in both production & performance (studio and live) in the 70s. By any measure, they were one of the great 60s acts, easily earning that bronze medal, if not deserving more in some ways.


51st Anniversary Viewing
The Monkees
"Monkees on the Line" / Originally aired March 27, 1967

Nothing much to see here.

...well, there's a few significant production / behind-the-scenes details related to this episode:
  • This was the last episode to feature Don Kirshner's "Music Supervisor" title in the credits. By the time this episode was in post-production, Kirshner had been fired.
  • Although aired a month before the end of the season, "The Monkees on the Line" was the final episode shot for that debut season.
  • One day after this episode's first run airing, The Monkees completed recording Headquarters.
 
I look at history from the perspective of when/how it happened first, not as it would be seen in the years to follow.
Yet you described them as part of the British Invasion. The Invasion had moved to Occupation by the time their first album came out on either side of the pond.
but were one the few white rock groups to first and successfully appeal to the growing, increasingly vocal counterculture / disaffected youth long before acts like The Beatles decided to full on move from their "yeah, yeah, yeah" period and play with experimentation.
Bullshit. The Who's first album came out the same day as Rubber Soul in the UK. The Byrds had invented Folk Rock with Mr. Tambourine Man, Dylan had plugged in and released Highway 61 Revisited, and Brian Wilson was working on Pet Sounds by that point. Your chronology is skewed and you're way oversimplifying what else was going on in music while the Who were still playing London clubs. The story of the Who's influence as you tell it relies on reducing everyone who preceded them to insignificance.

On that charting note, chart listing is no hard measure of the influence of the artist or work
But the fact that their first album didn't chart at all in the States tells a story...that they were still relatively unknown in the States at that point. It's hard to be influential when nobody's heard of you. Never mind "help[] establish the 'British Invasion' as a serious musical force," as you put it upthread. Citing them as a serious musical force in the British Invasion refers to their influence on this side of the pond, not in the London club scene; and earlier than anyone would have had reason to have heard of them in the States.

The Who were having an impact in the U.S. as well, not only with audiences, but the often-jagged edged news media, with a 1967 article from the San Francisco Examiner going as far to say:
And nobody's debating that they'd started to become a known force in the States by that point. They were on their second album (which did chart) and had done the Monterey Pop Festival.
Wiki said:
Although already a big act in the UK, and now gaining some attention in the US after playing some New York dates two months earlier, the Who were propelled into the American mainstream at Monterey.
And for clarity, Happy Jack (the US version of their second album) reached its peak position of #67 in the aftermath of Monterey.

TREK_GOD_1 said:
but any objective analysis of the British Invasion does not exist sans the impact of The Who
Their impact was after the Invasion. The Beatles, Dylan, the Byrds, and the Beach Boys had already changed the American music scene in huge ways by the time of the Who's "coming out" on this side of the pond at Monterey in mid-1967.
 
Last edited:
I'm finding the Who discussion fascinating. I envision a day when the major political parties are defined by their stance on the nature of the Who's influence in the 60s. :D
 
I envision a day when the major political parties are defined by their stance on the nature of the Who's influence in the 60s.
Little girl in political ad: Thank you, the Who, for the British Invasion.

_______

50th Anniversary Viewing

_______

The Ed Sullivan Show
Season 20, episode 30
Originally aired March 31, 1968
As represented in The Best of the Ed Sullivan Show

This week's acts come to us from two different mixed installments of Best of.

Smokey Robinson & the Miracles perform a medley of their previous hit, "I Second That Emotion"; their current hit, "If You Can Want," which is at #16 this week and still on the rise to its peak position of #11 (and has caught on with me in the weekly playlist listening); and 1965's "Going to a Go-Go" (#11 US; #2 R&B; #44 UK), which includes getting the audience involved in a brief singalong. Here's a too-short clip of the first part of the medley:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

In their follow-up, the Miracles contribute to "Yesterday"'s status as one of the most covered songs in the history of recorded music, with a very intimate, soft-gospel-style vocal rendition accompanied by a gentle, somewhat Spanish-sounding guitar. I used to be fond of saying that I never heard a Beatles cover that I liked, but...well, judge for yourself:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(Just close your eyes and listen if you find the squished aspect ratio in the video as distracting as I do.)

Listenable but much less up my alley is Frankie Laine performing his previous Easy Listening hit, "To Each His Own" (charted Jan 20, 1968; #82 US; #2 AC). tv.com indicates that he also plugged his newest hit, "I Found You" (charted the week of this episode; #118 US; #19 AC).

Also in the original episode according to tv.com:
Music:
--The Young Americans - "Oklahoma" medley.

Comedy:
--Wayne & Shuster (comedy team) - sketch about participants at a parent-teacher meeting discussing TV violence.
--Myron Cohen (storytelling comedian).

Also appearing:
--Charlton Heston reads from Abraham Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address. Later in show, Heston discusses his movie "Planet of the Apes," with film clip.
--Peter Gennaro & Troupe (choreographer with dancers) - "If I Were A Rich Man" production number.
--Baranton Sisters (foot jugglers who balance & spin tables).
--Audience bows: Richard Rodgers, Jerome Hines, Pearl Mesta & Earl Blackwell, and Samuel Defalco.

CBS repeated this show on July 28, 1968.

A very brief bit of one interesting-sounding piece of business there can be found at 0:53 of this video:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

_______

Rowan & Martin's Laugh-In
Season 1, episode 10
Originally aired April 1, 1968
The Wiki list of guest appearances said:
The Bee Gees, Johnny Carson, Barbara Feldon, Harry Belafonte, Ed McMahon, Flip Wilson, Sivi Aberg

Sign o' behind the times: Jokes in the party sketch that would have been filmed when Johnson was still in the race. He'd just announced that he wasn't running the night before.

In his usual crack about the horn players in the New Talent intro, Dick describes them as "The Band from Hunger".

In the news skit, Johnny Carson does the "Heeeeere's Dicky!"

I had to dig a bit to identify the song in the Bee Gees video as "Lemons Never Forget," from their then-current album, Horizontal.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Mod, Mod World looks at communications.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

_______

Ironside
"Return of the Hero"
Originally aired April 4, 1968
Wiki said:
Ironside's attempts to save a Vietnam hero from the gas chamber are put at risk by the man's war buddies.

The episode opens with a spinning newspaper and the voice of a newsvendor reading it to us--How extra! extra! quaint. Cut to Ironside testifying in court...well, that's a natural enough fit, though he's on the other side of the questioning in this series. The titular hero on trial for shooting his wife, Capt. Larkin, is played by Gary Collins. One of the war buddies is Ned Romero. Another is Charles Wood, whom I recognized from multiple roles on Tarzan. Gavin MacLeod, who seems to have been typecast as slimeballs in this decade, plays a witness who'd been paid to give false testimony and gets killed by a booby-trapped shower handle.

It turns out there are two independent parties behind the series of death threats, intimidations, and bombings...the party responsible for killing Larkin's wife and her lover is making the phone calls and planting the bombs; while the other, consisting of the war buddies, is trying to get witnesses to retract their false testimonies. Larkin's wife was only killed to frame Larkin; the man she was having an affair with was the real target.

And that's the first season of Ironside. This one's still on the bubble for me should new show recording opportunities make DVR space an issue, but it's not currently in danger.

_______

Get Smart
"The Reluctant Redhead"
Originally aired April 6, 1968
Wiki said:
CONTROL has discovered that a writer of children's books named Mimsi Sage strongly resembles the deceased wife of a man named Kinsey Krispin (Cesar Romero) with a list of KAOS informers that CONTROL would very much like to have. Max trains Mimsi to pretend to be the deceased wife; no easy task, as this requires the mousy writer to act like the jet-setting Mrs. Amanda Krispin. (Working title: "Smart's Waterloo".)
Another Saint-style title, though I don't remember which show did one before.

The Chief said:
She wrote "The Tiger that Couldn't," "The Elephant that Wouldn't," and "The Pussy that Would Like To."
:eek:

The book that Mimsi's currently working on is Seymour the Psychedelic Mouse.

99 makes a THRUSH reference...that might have slipped by me if I hadn't read it first. The premise strikes me as being TMFU-ish, though I don't know if that was deliberate...recruiting the female guest of the week, (seemingly) an ordinary civilian, to help in a spy operation.

IMDb tells me that the "puzzle piece" commercial transitions used in this episode will become standard in the coming seasons.

Good twist at the end with Mimsi's true identity. And while I spotted one of the people made up like a statue early, the gag about so many of the statues being both CONTROL agents and Krispin's men in disguise was pretty good. I had to go back and take another look at the set-up...in the transition back from commercial, you can see 99 wobbling a bit.

And that's my first full season of Get Smart. I'm still not finding the show knee-slappingly hilarious for the most part, but it's a pleasant enough sign o' the times viewing experience.

_______
 
Last edited:
_______

50 Years Ago This Week

April 7 – Racing driver Jim Clark is killed in a Formula 2 race at Hockenheim.
April 8 – The Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs (under Department of Justice) (BNDD) is created.
April 10 – The ferry TEV Wahine strikes a reef at the mouth of Wellington Harbour, New Zealand, with the loss of 53 lives, in Cyclone Giselle, which created the windiest conditions ever recorded in New Zealand.
April 11
  • Josef Bachmann tries to assassinate Rudi Dutschke, leader of the left-wing movement (APO) in Germany, and tries to commit suicide afterwards, failing in both, although Dutschke dies of his brain injuries 11 years later.
  • German left-wing students blockade the Springer Press HQ in Berlin and many are arrested (one of them Ulrike Meinhof).
  • U.S. President Lyndon B. Johnson signs the Civil Rights Act of 1968.
  • MGM's classic film The Wizard of Oz makes its NBC debut after being telecast on CBS since 1956. It will remain on NBC for the next 8 years.
In Beatle news, John, George, and wives return from Rishikesh on April 12.

Selections from Billboard's Hot 100 for the week:
1. "Honey," Bobby Goldsboro
2. "Young Girl," The Union Gap feat. Gary Puckett
3. "(Sittin' on) The Dock of the Bay," Otis Redding
4. "Cry Like a Baby," The Box Tops
5. "Sweet Sweet Baby (Since You've Been Gone)," Aretha Franklin
6. "Lady Madonna," The Beatles
7. "The Ballad of Bonnie and Clyde," Georgie Fame
8. "La-La Means I Love You," The Delfonics
9. "Valleri," The Monkees
10. "Mighty Quinn (Quinn the Eskimo)," Manfred Mann
11. "I Got the Feelin'," James Brown & The Famous Flames
12. "Love Is Blue (L'amour Est Bleu)," Paul Mauriat & His Orchestra
13. "Scarborough Fair / Canticle," Simon & Garfunkel
14. "Dance to the Music," Sly & The Family Stone
15. "Simon Says," 1910 Fruitgum Co.
16. "If You Can Want," Smokey Robinson & The Miracles
17. "Playboy," Gene & Debbe
18. "Cowboys to Girls," The Intruders
19. "Summertime Blues," Blue Cheer
20. "Kiss Me Goodbye," Petula Clark
21. "Ain't No Way," Aretha Franklin
22. "(Theme from) Valley of the Dolls," Dionne Warwick

24. "Sweet Inspiration," The Sweet Inspirations
25. "Love Is All Around," The Troggs
26. "The Unicorn," The Irish Rovers
27. "I Thank You," Sam & Dave
28. "Jennifer Juniper," Donovan
29. "Forever Came Today," Diana Ross & The Supremes
30. "Take Time to Know Her," Percy Sledge
31. "Funky Street," Arthur Conley
32. "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly," Hugo Montenegro, His Orchestra & Chorus
33. "Just Dropped In (To See What Condition My Condition Was In)," The First Edition
34. "Delilah," Tom Jones

37. "Tighten Up," Archie Bell & The Drells
38. "Soul Serenade," Willie Mitchell

41. "Will You Love Me Tomorrow," The Four Seasons
42. "U.S. Male," Elvis Presley

48. "The End of Our Road," Gladys Knight & The Pips

50. "I Wish It Would Rain," The Temptations

53. "Call Me Lightning," The Who

56. "A Beautiful Morning," The Rascals
57. "Shoo-Be-Doo-Be-Doo-Da-Day," Stevie Wonder
58. "The Unknown Soldier," The Doors
59. "Sunshine of Your Love," Cream

66. "She's Lookin' Good," Wilson Pickett

72. "Mony Mony," Tommy James & The Shondells

75. "Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing," Marvin Gaye & Tammi Terrell

84. "Do You Know the Way to San Jose," Dionne Warwick

88. "(You Keep Me) Hangin' On," Joe Simon


93. "Master Jack," Four Jacks and a Jill

95. "I Love You," People


Disavowed by the Secretary:
  • "I'm Gonna Make You Love Me," Madeline Bell
  • "Mission: Impossible," Lalo Schifrin :sigh:
  • "Up from the Skies," The Jimi Hendrix Experience

New on the chart:

"(You Keep Me) Hangin' On," Joe Simon
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(#25 US; #11 R&B; not the same song as the the Supremes hit)

"She's Lookin' Good," Wilson Pickett
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(#15 US; #7 R&B)

"Do You Know the Way to San Jose," Dionne Warwick
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(#10 US; #4 AC; #23 R&B; #8 UK)

"Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing," Marvin Gaye & Tammi Terrell
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(#8 US; #1 R&B; #34 UK)

"A Beautiful Morning," The Rascals
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(#3 US; #36 R&B)


And new on the boob tube:
  • Rowan & Martin's Laugh-In, Season 1, episode 11
  • The Avengers, "Split!"
  • That Girl, "The Beard"
  • The Saint, "The House on Dragon's Rock"
_______
 
Last edited:
Yet you described them as part of the British Invasion. The Invasion had moved to Occupation by the time their first album came out on either side of the pond.

Nonsense. There's no such thing as an "occupation" where The Who is concerned. Further, the Invasion is not strictly limited to album releases or charts. Its about the creative/social movement in music which organically grew in influence & popularity. The Who had been part of this movement as early as 1963 under the Detours/High Numbers line-ups. Like every other early version of important groups, they were one of the foundations of the revolution, which does not snap into existence/prominence like magic, and always predates a chart listing.

The Byrds had invented Folk Rock with Mr. Tambourine Man,

Where on earth are you getting that fantasy?? Long before the Byrds were even a thought, acts such as The Kingston Trio had been at the forefront of folk-infused rock/pop in the late 1950s, and certainly influenced acts who would adopt that sub-genre in the decade to follow--including the Byrds.

Dylan had plugged in and released Highway 61 Revisited, and Brian Wilson was working on Pet Sounds by that point. Your chronology is skewed and you're way oversimplifying what else was going on in music while the Who were still playing London clubs.

My chronology is accurate, which means referring to the sources who were there to see it unfold, instead of the myopic ramblings of certain magazines. To the point: while Dylan released Highway 61...in August of '65, the rock/pop musical landscape had well traveled the road of being upended in the UK, with The Who already recording "I Can't Explain" (9/1964), "Anyway, Anyhow, Anywhere" (4/1965) and other notable tracks, but their rise as a group seen as speaking to the exploding music/youth culture of the UK had been well on its way in their Detours/High Numbers periods, which you completely ignore.

The story of the Who's influence as you tell it relies on reducing everyone who preceded them to insignificance.

Say hello to the mirror, as you have tried undervalue, if not erase The Who's place and influence as part of the musical movement in question, which most reputable names from the period and historians have never tried to separate them from said movement.

Early on, the insightful Brian Jones had this to say:
"They are the only young group doing something new both visually and musically."

Prophetically adding...

"Originality usually means success."

What did a certain Beatle named McCartney say about The Who in '64?

"The Who are the most exciting thing around."

McCartney was well acquainted with most of the important UK bands of the era, and their various talents, but he clearly realized their undeniable value to the music scene.

Again, this can go on and on, with historically accurate notes, quotes and other details stating the facts, but if you're convinced to reduce The Who to a footnote, or an act that "blossomed" late in the 60s, then there's no point in continuing this specific exchange.
 
Last edited:
Where on earth are you getting that fantasy?? Long before the Byrds were even a thought, acts such as The Kingston Trio had been at the forefront of folk-infused rock/pop in the late 1950s
No, that was just Folk, or maybe "Folk Pop" if one is subgenrizing to that extent. Folk Rock was a distinct new phase when people performing folk music "plugged in," using electric/rock instrumentation rather than the traditional acoustic arrangements. The Byrds are credited for having gotten this going by fusing the styles of the two most influential acts of the era, the Beatles and Bob Dylan.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folk_rock
Wiki said:
The term "folk rock" was initially used in the U.S. music press in June 1965 to describe the Byrds' music.

Dylan plugging in after hearing how the Byrds successfully arranged his music with rock instrumentation was a legendarily scandalous moment in the folk world of the era. "Positively 4th Street" is believed to be his answer to the critics who turned on him over that development.

TREK_GOD_1 said:
Say hello to the mirror, as you have tried undervalue, if not erase The Who's place and influence as part of the musical movement in question
No, I'm just trying to put them in their proper historical context. There's no shame in their having emerged as an influential group in a later period of the decade than the Beatles and the Stones did. I'm not an aficionado of the UK-specific music scene of the period, so I can't speak to that. If the Who were creating some sort of stirring in the British music scene as early as '64, I'll take your word for it. But that's a different thing from having been an integral part of the British Invasion in America.
 
Last edited:
Aight, I have a concession to make that undermines the main gist of my argument...I've been overlooking that the Who did indeed have what I would consider to be a late and underwhelming toehold in the British Invasion proper:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
(US release: Dec. 1964; Charted Mar. 27, 1965; #93 US; #8 UK; #371 on Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Songs of All Time)

So I concede, the Who were legitimately part of the British Invasion. How big a part is debatable and more a matter of opinion than fact. The songwriter himself dismisses the originality of that particular release:
Wiki said:
In the album's liner notes, Townshend noted the song's similarity to the contemporaneous hit single "All Day and All of the Night" by The Kinks: "It can't be beat for straightforward Kink copying. There is little to say about how I wrote this. It came out of the top of my head when I was 18 and a half." In a 1994 issue of Q magazine, Roger Daltrey echoed Townshend's comments regarding The Kinks' influence on the writing of the song:

We already knew Pete (Townshend) could write songs, but it never seemed a necessity in those days to have your own stuff because there was this wealth of untapped music that we could get hold of from America. But then bands like The Kinks started to make it, and they were probably the biggest influence on us – they were certainly a huge influence on Pete, and he wrote 'I Can't Explain', not as a direct copy, but certainly it's very derivative of Kinks music.​

I also maintain that Monterey in '67 is considered their breakout moment on this side of the pond. And would encourage enthusiastic Who fans not to sing the band's praises at the expense of ignoring or dismissing every other major breakthrough that was happening in music at the time.
 
In their follow-up, the Miracles contribute to "Yesterday"'s status as one of the most covered songs in the history of recorded music, with a very intimate, soft-gospel-style vocal rendition accompanied by a gentle, somewhat Spanish-sounding guitar. I used to be fond of saying that I never heard a Beatles cover that I liked, but...well, judge for yourself:
"El Condor Yesterday." I've never given much thought to Beatles covers, but this is certainly a good fit for Smokey.

A very brief bit of one interesting-sounding piece of business there can be found at 0:53 of this video:
Interesting indeed. I'd love to see more of the readings and poetry that were on the show.

Sign o' behind the times: Jokes in the party sketch that would have been filmed when Johnson was still in the race. He'd just announced that he wasn't running the night before.
Oops. The pitfalls of being topical. :rommie:

I had to dig a bit to identify the song in the Bee Gees video as "Lemons Never Forget," from their then-current album, Horizontal.
I don't remember that one at all. Pleasant, but doesn't hold up to their other stuff of the period.

The episode opens with a spinning newspaper and the voice of a newsvendor reading it to us--How extra! extra! quaint.
I love that stuff. :rommie:

Cut to Ironside testifying in court...well, that's a natural enough fit, though he's on the other side of the questioning in this series.
It's a shame they never did a Perry Mason/Ironside crossover. That would have been the best spin on the twin-split screen gimmick ever. :rommie:

And that's the first season of Ironside. This one's still on the bubble for me should new show recording opportunities make DVR space an issue, but it's not currently in danger.
Your capsule descriptions make it sound pretty good.

I wonder if the censors just didn't get it.

IMDb tells me that the "puzzle piece" commercial transitions used in this episode will become standard in the coming seasons.
Oh, yeah, I remember that, along with the new "more exciting" intro that came later.

"(You Keep Me) Hangin' On," Joe Simon
I don't remember this one. Kind of ordinary.

"She's Lookin' Good," Wilson Pickett
I don't remember this one either, but it's toe-tappin.'

"Do You Know the Way to San Jose," Dionne Warwick
Ah, now this is a stone-cold time-travel classic for me. I'm in Dorchester, sitting on the piazza, eating a spucky and drinking a can of tonic....

"Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing," Marvin Gaye & Tammi Terrell
Another classic.

"A Beautiful Morning," The Rascals
Another favorite, happy 60s classic.

I've been overlooking that the Who did indeed have what I would consider to be a late and underwhelming toehold in the British Invasion proper:
And I love this, too, as I love most Who songs.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top