• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Battle of Wolf 359!?

Babaganoosh said:
Huntingdon said:we know that the Excalibur not only faced the Borg but also survived, as some of the assimilated crew showed up in another Voyager episode.

Just because some of the crew showed up later, doesn't mean the Excalibur survived. (New Frontier doesn't count, of course.)

It's made clear in the Voyager episode.
 
Huntingdon said:
Babaganoosh said:
Huntingdon said:we know that the Excalibur not only faced the Borg but also survived, as some of the assimilated crew showed up in another Voyager episode.

Just because some of the crew showed up later, doesn't mean the Excalibur survived. (New Frontier doesn't count, of course.)

It's made clear in the Voyager episode.

How?
 
One thing I don't understand, why was there wrekage of Constitution class star ships in the debris field?
 
it wasn't it was a ship with a constitution-style secondary hull. like the other ships included galaxy-style nacelles or or saucers...
 
Lonestar said:
One thing I don't understand, why was there wrekage of Constitution class star ships in the debris field?

There was so much kitbashing going on, parts from the Constitution-class ship model were used to create all new classes. There was one I know of which had the Connie's secondary hull, but with the saucer and three nacelles from a Galaxy class. Another one had the Connie 'neck' but with the saucer and *one* nacelle from the Galaxy. Etc.
 
If I remember correctly, the real world reason for the presence of a Constitution class ship at Wolf 359 is that one of the models used was the model of the destroyed Enterprise from Star Trek III, and that is the piece visible on screen. I personally just choose to think it was an older surplus-yard ship reactivated to counter the Borg incursion.

:rommie:
 
Yep, they pulled an old Connie out of mothballs to fight the invincible cyborg invaders. They also found some old TOS-style redshirts to give to the crew.
 
If they're still using Mirandas, why not a few remaining Constitutions too?


Marian
 
They don't show Constitutions in TNG+ Trek because they don't want to take away from the destruction of the Enterprise in Trek III. Since the Galaxy is a TNG era ship they can trash and destroy as many of those as they want, like how they destroyed other Constitutions in TOS.
 
Yeah, that's really partly Gene's fault. Originally the crew was supposed to be given a new ship entirely in TMP, with an 1800 registry, but that was changed because he felt people wouldn't associate it with the original Enterprise. And ever since then there's been a weird sort of ban on using movie-era Connies in any fashion.
 
I've always just chosen to think we didn't see Connies (excluding the one at Wolf 359) in TNG because (1) the class is older than the Miranda and reached its service lifetime and (2) other classes such as the Excelsior could perform their duties just as well or better, while the Miranda could be relegated to support roles.

Weak rationalization, I know. But possible.

:rommie:
 
* shrugs * I'm kind of the opposite. Given that Mirandas, Constellations, and Excelsiors are still in service, I'd think a lot of the Connies still are too. Even if they're unseen.
 
Maybe you're right... maybe they just send them on super-duper deep space duty. I dunno.

Mostly my thinking came out of the quick retirement of the Enterprise-A... but that could have been for other reasons too. Either way, I personally like to think the 'A' was a prototype built of spare parts solely to test the grafting of Excelsior tech onto Constitution class frames, never meant for long term duty, but given to Kirk's crew as an honor for one last outing. Then, you could choose to believe that was either successful or a failure, depending where you wanted Connies to be in the 24th.

I've thought that some Connies were probably in service until the 2340s, that Mirandas (being a newer class) were kept in service long enough that by the time the Dominion war rolled around they weren't retired, and that they and the Excelsiors were retired shortly after the war. We saw so few Constellations I could go either way with them.

I dunno, it's just one of those things that is difficult to reconcile because of real-world weirdness.

:rommie:
 
There are numerous fan and for that matter professional designs over the years that utilize Constitution class seocndary hulls.

For example, FASA Indomiable class battleship design was an interim design to make up for delays in the Excelsior class.

It utilized a modified Constitution class engineering hull and engines along with an Excelsior class saucer.
 
Cronos, in that picture you posted, what is the four-nacelled ship at the right edge of the screen? It's the one where the two top nacelles are closer together than the bottom two. (Not the other four-nacelled ship which is directly above it.)
 
Babaganoosh said:
Cronos, in that picture you posted, what is the four-nacelled ship at the right edge of the screen? It's the one where the two top nacelles are closer together than the bottom two. (Not the other four-nacelled ship which is directly above it.)

Looks like a Nebula Class variant.

Go to "Ex Astris Scientia".

It's listed as a "Nebula Prototype 1"

Link
 
Judging by the Deep Space Nine episode 'Valiant' they still use the Republic and that was Constitution Class
 
Yeah, the original Nebula models built for BOBW had four nacelles - the two standard ones and the two mini ones in place of the pod that's now common. One was wreckbashed for the graveyard scene and the other appeared as a studio model in a few eps.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top