• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The 100 infant changelings

IMO, they killed the Borg when they added the queen.

I can at least see there being a logical purpose of a queen for a hive mind. Something to bring order to chaos.

The reason why "DARK FRONTIER" defanged the Borg so badly is actually a simple reason, and ultimately why the FRIDAY THE 13TH remake movie sucked, as an example.

The Borg Queen made a deal with Seven instead of just letting the attack happen and assimilating the crew and her. They didn't need to do that because they are FAR more powerful than a single Intrepid class ship. It broke the character of the Borg irreperably. With my other example, Jason Vorhees NEVER TAKES PRISONERS. It went completely against his character, and defanged him completely. When you make an established danger like those two do something comparatively benign from their established nature, you throw all the menace and danger out the window.

(I'm not forgetting about the "SCORPION" deal... in that case, Janeway had actual leverage because the Borg were losing. I still don't agree with her doing the deal, but at least it didn't declaw them like the deal the Queen did with Seven.)

And Janeway's undercover assimilation in the "UNIMATRIX ZERO" two-parter... final nail in the coffin.

I like VOYAGER a lot, but the one thing I can never forgive them for is defanging the Borg.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
I can at least see there being a logical purpose of a queen for a hive mind. Something to bring order to chaos.

The reason why "DARK FRONTIER" defanged the Borg so badly is actually a simple reason, and ultimately why the FRIDAY THE 13TH remake movie sucked, as an example.

The Borg Queen made a deal with Seven instead of just letting the attack happen and assimilating the crew and her. They didn't need to do that because they are FAR more powerful than a single Intrepid class ship. It broke the character of the Borg irreperably. With my other example, Jason Vorhees NEVER TAKES PRISONERS. It went completely against his character, and defanged him completely. When you make an established danger like those two do something comparatively benign from their established nature, you throw all the menace and danger out the window.

(I'm not forgetting about the "SCORPION" deal... in that case, Janeway had actual leverage because the Borg were losing. I still don't agree with her doing the deal, but at least it didn't declaw them like the deal the Queen did with Seven.)

And Janeway's undercover assimilation in the "UNIMATRIX ZERO" two-parter... final nail in the coffin.

I like VOYAGER a lot, but the one thing I can never forgive them for is defanging the Borg.

Having a Queen unit wasn’t the problem. The problem was the way she gave human emotions to an enemy interesting for being emotionless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
Having a Queen unit wasn’t the problem. The problem was the way she gave human emotions to an enemy interesting for being emotionless.

They did the same thing to the Q. Q was degraded from a godlike omnipotent being to a clown act...; Every villain that is overused eventually loses its originality and what makes it interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top