I see it now. Yeah, I'm sticking with my suspicion that there is only one Master of Poisons medal and the one with the globe is actually the Captain medal.
Don’t forget some of the Terran awards shown in Enterprise were repurposed from NuBSG. Some of those TOS MU devices look familiar as well. Gonna have to do some research on them.
Took me a while but I found what I needed (and Imgur was recently down), but here are examples of Enterprise-era Terran decorations: And their NuBSG sources: Some things were added, but they're basically pretty much the same.
Nice catch! Pretty sure one of the Rec Deck guys in TMP had half a Cylon ship from the original BSG strapped to his chest. And of course there are 2 Trek novels novels with BSG ships on the cover. Diane Carey's Ghost Ship has Galactica herself (upside down) and Diane Duane's The Romulan Way has a Colonial Viper chasing McCoy.
I recall seeing those before. I love it when the literature companies commission artists who don't have the foggiest clue of the topics on which what they're supposed to make artwork.
They may have modified the molds but it doesn't look like any of the medals from BSG. The Lee Adama one might be used but with stuff added, but it seems the only one that's the right shape and size.
The big one is definitely the Lee Adama piece (IIRC, Kara had something similar on hers) with some swooshy thing glued on. I think the one below it as well, with the extra “V” shaped greeble added onto it looks like the fourth one down on Bill Adama’s sash. It was also used by Adm. Corman as well as the honor guard.