• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Superman

Do you have any evidence that was why a different version of the reveal was used in Lester’s theatrical version — along with many other differences from Donner’s planned film — or is it just supposition on your part?
The fact that it remained in the original shooting script for Donner's version of the movie through the entirety of production before it paused tells me that it wasn't because the Salkinds or someone at Warner Bros suddenly said, "won't somebody think of the children?"

What seems likely to me, given Richard Lester's emphasis of comedy over moments that make dramatic or thematic sense, is that the rewrite to Clark bumbling into the flames was purely for the laughs. And besides - how would parents be any less concerned about their kids literally playing with fire in this alternate version versus the gun in the original? Both are just as potentially harmful or deadly.
 
The fact that it remained in the original shooting script for Donner's version of the movie through the entirety of production before it paused tells me that it wasn't because the Salkinds or someone at Warner Bros suddenly said, "won't somebody think of the children?"

What seems likely to me, given Richard Lester's emphasis of comedy over moments that make dramatic or thematic sense, is that the rewrite to Clark bumbling into the flames was purely for the laughs. And besides - how would parents be any less concerned about their kids literally playing with fire in this alternate version versus the gun in the original? Both are just as potentially harmful or deadly.

Superman cannot fall over unless he is being pushed, hard.

In that situation, stumbling, rather than falling over onto his face, his body would have chosen to float, before risking confrontation with the ground or a shitty little fire feature.

Then there's Freud.

There are no accidents.

Manifest subconscious desires.

What do you know, 11 years of Frasier, finally paying off.

13?

No.

"That's impossible!"
 
No scenes should be removed from older films (or books, etc.) because of changes in cultural standards, or for much of any other reason I can think of.

The pearl clutching over the offscreen slap is excessive to me, maybe because I’m a child of that era, so the bit is fixed in my mind as what it was intended to be at the time: a (very) mildly dark joke. And yes, I do still perceive it as funny in that context. It made me laugh when I saw it in the theater as a teen, and it still makes me chuckle now. If that brands me as a monster, so be it. :p
 
No scenes should be removed from older films (or books, etc.) because of changes in cultural standards, or for much of any other reason I can think of.

The pearl clutching over the offscreen slap is excessive to me, maybe because I’m a child of that era, so the bit is fixed in my mind as what it was intended to be at the time: a (very) mildly dark joke. And yes, I do still perceive it as funny in that context. It made me laugh when I saw it in the theater as a teen, and it still makes me chuckle now. If that brands me as a monster, so be it. :p

You're going to put Winston Smith out of a job.
 
No scenes should be removed from older films (or books, etc.) because of changes in cultural standards, or for much of any other reason I can think of.
Completely agree.

I remember reading that some streaming service took down an episode of the Golden Girls for having a black face joke despite the episode being about confronting prejudices with a clear anti racist message.

Both ends of the spectrum are out of touch with reality honestly. The hyper politically correct pearl clutchers with no sense of humour and the bigots who think anyone calling them out for their racism/homophobia/transphobia just doesn't have a sense of humour. They should both shut up.
 
Both ends of the spectrum are out of touch with reality honestly. The hyper politically correct pearl clutchers with no sense of humour and the bigots who think anyone calling them out for their racism/homophobia/transphobia just doesn't have a sense of humour. They should both shut up.
I’m not much of a both-sideser. We all know who the bad guys are in this country (or most of us do, anyway). So the extent to which I agree with you depends on how far you mean to take it. Altering existing works of art to suit modern sensibilities, no. Demanding progress in our current society, absolutely.
 
I’m not much of a both-sideser. We all know who the bad guys are in this country (or most of us do, anyway). So the extent to which I agree with you depends on how far you mean to take it. Altering existing works of art to suit modern sensibilities, no. Demanding progress in our current society, absolutely.
Oh no current society needs to progress absolutely but not to nanny state levels.

I assume by this country you mean america which is not my country but in mine as well there are large chunks of people who seem to need reminding nazis were bad.
 
Do you have any evidence that was why a different version of the reveal was used in Lester’s theatrical version — along with many other differences from Donner’s planned film — or is it just supposition on your part?
Purely an educated guess based on various factors including: the era of production, the influence of parents' groups during that era, the existence of the "emulative clause" (Basically, the clause stated that a scene with a weapon needed to be eliminated if a six year old child could physically emulate what he sees) in kids cartoons (not enforceable against a movie, of course, but indicative of the Hollywood mindset) during that era, the (possible urban legend) wherein a kid tried to shoot George Reeves and a general familiarity with how both in-house counsel and insurance carriers think.

Again, I render no opinion on artistic merit of the scene, I'm just saying I'm not surprised it got changed.
 
I’m not much of a both-sideser. We all know who the bad guys are in this country (or most of us do, anyway). So the extent to which I agree with you depends on how far you mean to take it. Altering existing works of art to suit modern sensibilities, no. Demanding progress in our current society, absolutely.
Yeah, I'm definitely not a fan of altering works of art to fit modern sensibilities, people just need to recognize that it was a different era. Which is why I am a fan of putting warnings in front of things, that way people who might be triggered are aware of it and can choose if they want to see it or not, but you're not actually changing the work itself.
 
Yeah, I'm definitely not a fan of altering works of art to fit modern sensibilities, people just need to recognize that it was a different era. Which is why I am a fan of putting warnings in front of things, that way people who might be triggered are aware of it and can choose if they want to see it or not, but you're not actually changing the work itself.
I really love companies like StudioCanal who put the notice at the head of a film to help contextualize that it’s based in outdated historical values and attitudes. It’s an easy way to make stuff accessible without alienating someone coming to it fresh.

I’ve never understood folks who fly off the handle when those pop up. Such a silly thing to be outraged over.
 
I really love companies like StudioCanal who put the notice at the head of a film to help contextualize that it’s based in outdated historical values and attitudes. It’s an easy way to make stuff accessible without alienating someone coming to it fresh.

I’ve never understood folks who fly off the handle when those pop up. Such a silly thing to be outraged over.
It doesn’t make me “fly off the handle” but I find it an infantilizing and performative type of “concern”.
 
It doesn’t make me “fly off the handle” but I find it an infantilizing and performative type of “concern”.
I find it to be neither.

I look at it from the perspective of someone that did not grow up inured in the attitudes or unconscious prejudices the older films exhibit and could react to something with zero context if they’re finding it randomly on a streaming service. A simple bit of text helps to set the stage, and that’s it. There’s nothing wrong with that.
 
I find it to be neither.

I look at it from the perspective of someone that did not grow up inured in the attitudes or unconscious prejudices the older films exhibit and could react to something with zero context if they’re finding it randomly on a streaming service. A simple bit of text helps to set the stage, and that’s it. There’s nothing wrong with that.
It’s not wrong per se to have such messages. I simply find them unnecessary and part and parcel of an attitude that suggests people (adults) are far more fragile than they really are.

It’s not a topic I find so bothersome so as to motivate me into writing weekly editorials about it, or engage in some sort of significant protest (it’s been quite a few years since the last time I’ve devoted even this little amount of time to the topic). However, I’ve yet to encounter a persuasive argument for the necessity of such things nor am I likely to do so, so agree to disagree is where I’ll leave it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top