• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Superman (casting, rumors, pix till release)

I'm not one to normally "slag off on women on the internet", but in Dunst's case, I just never felt like she lived up to the Mary Jane Watson portrayal of the comics.
The MJ of the Raimi movies wasn't the MJ of the comics, though. She was a girl-next-door MJ who becomes a stage actress rather than a sassy bombshell who becomes a supermodel/soap star.
 
. A Superman movie is definately something that I'd watch (even if its just out of morbid curiosity to see what they did to Superman). Amy Adams movies are mostly not, but a lot of them aren't really normal movies anyway.

Your Superman "experience" seems very limited.

The films you listed are mostly genre films and therefore are not "normal" movies. Amy Adams credits are probably a lot more "normal" than you think.

I'm not one to normally "slag off on women on the internet", but in Dunst's case, I just never felt like she lived up to the Mary Jane Watson portrayal of the comics.
The MJ of the Raimi movies wasn't the MJ of the comics, though. She was a girl-next-door MJ who becomes a stage actress rather than a sassy bombshell who becomes a supermodel/soap star.
Exactly.
 
Yeah it seemed pretty obvious to me that Raimi was going for a more innocent, 1960s vibe with those characters, and wanted MJ to be a more believable girl next door type for Peter. Which I personally think was a good move.
 
Yeah it seemed pretty obvious to me that Raimi was going for a more innocent, 1960s vibe with those characters, and wanted MJ to be a more believable girl next door type for Peter. Which I personally think was a good move.
Especially for a Peter Parker that looks like Tobey Maguire.

Wait, someone's complaining about films that they haven't seen winning awards (and they're serious)?!? Ah, the Internet.
Truly a wondrous, soul-destroying place.
 
Not one of the guys who "slag off on women on the Internet," as you say, has ever been with anyone as attractive as the women they're criticizing. I guarantee you that.

Yeah, and anyone who dislikes a movie hasn't made a film as good as the one their criticizing.

Nobody is allowed to criticize anything.
 
. A Superman movie is definately something that I'd watch (even if its just out of morbid curiosity to see what they did to Superman). Amy Adams movies are mostly not, but a lot of them aren't really normal movies anyway.

Your Superman "experience" seems very limited.

The films you listed are mostly genre films and therefore are not "normal" movies. Amy Adams credits are probably a lot more "normal" than you think.

Well, I seem to have a few people that agree that she's not a household name, so there is that. As for my superman experience, here's basically what I can recall seeing/reading involving Superman

TV/Direct to DVD movies:
All of Superman TAS
All of Justice League
All of Smallville
A few episodes of the old Black and White Superman
A few episodes of Lois & Clark
Every DC Direct Animated movie with him except The Dark Knight Returns

Movies:
Superman 1 & 2, and good portions of 3 &4
Superman Returns

Comics:
About 25-30 issues of Silver age superman (from various DC Showcase collections)
Some Golden Age Superman stories
All of the JMS started "Grounded" arc before the reboot
The first six issues of All Star Superman
Various issues of Action comics
A lot of Justice League comics
A lot of various event comics and misc appearances, way too many to list

I'd say that, in general, I have a good amount of experience with Superman. As for "normal" movies, what exactly would those be? The Muppets? Julie & Julia? Even though I may prefer certain kinds of movies, Adams hasn't been in a lot of movies directed toward a general audience (and not ones specificly made for women/kids/independant film fans). She's been in a few, but what does it matter?

My point was that it wasn't that unusual that I didn't know her, and other people have agreed that she's not a household name. I can count the number of movies I've seen with Angelina Jolie on one finger (Mr. & Mrs. Smith, which I saw on TV when I was bored) but I still know who she is. Same with actors like, for example, Clint Eastwood (I don't actually think I've every watched a full movie he's been in). I don't need to have seen many (or even one) movie neccesarily to know who an actor is if they're very famous. Adams isn't super famous, regardless of what my movie tastes are.

Is the Amy Adams famous or not question answered now? If I'm making big posts in this thread, it might as well be more on topic, if more rage filled, stuff about the movie than arguing over whether the bland Lois in what looks to be a horrible Superman movie is very famous or not.
 
Not one of the guys who "slag off on women on the Internet," as you say, has ever been with anyone as attractive as the women they're criticizing. I guarantee you that.

I'm not one to normally "slag off on women on the internet", but in Dunst's case, I just never felt like she lived up to the Mary Jane Watson portrayal of the comics.

I didn't watch the comic, but the movie that Raimi made. Mary Jane in the movie is Peter's next door neighbor and friend, who intends to be an actress. None of that has anything necessarily to do with being "a superhot model." She's pretty enough, and Toby was dorky enough.
 
. A Superman movie is definately something that I'd watch (even if its just out of morbid curiosity to see what they did to Superman). Amy Adams movies are mostly not, but a lot of them aren't really normal movies anyway.

Your Superman "experience" seems very limited.

The films you listed are mostly genre films and therefore are not "normal" movies. Amy Adams credits are probably a lot more "normal" than you think.

Well, I seem to have a few people that agree that she's not a household name, so there is that. As for my superman experience, here's basically what I can recall seeing/reading involving Superman

TV/Direct to DVD movies:
All of Superman TAS
All of Justice League
All of Smallville
A few episodes of the old Black and White Superman
A few episodes of Lois & Clark
Every DC Direct Animated movie with him except The Dark Knight Returns

Movies:
Superman 1 & 2, and good portions of 3 &4
Superman Returns

Comics:
About 25-30 issues of Silver age superman (from various DC Showcase collections)
Some Golden Age Superman stories
All of the JMS started "Grounded" arc before the reboot
The first six issues of All Star Superman
Various issues of Action comics
A lot of Justice League comics
A lot of various event comics and misc appearances, way too many to list
I'd say that, in general, I have a good amount of experience with Superman.
Action Comics and Superman are his main "venues". If you haven't read those in the last 10-30 years then your experience in where the character has been and is going is limited.

As for "normal" movies, what exactly would those be? The Muppets? Julie & Julia? Even though I may prefer certain kinds of movies, Adams hasn't been in a lot of movies directed toward a general audience (and not ones specificly made for women/kids/independant film fans). She's been in a few, but what does it matter?
"Normal" movies are RomComs, Dramas, Comedy and biopics. I'd say a large percentage of her body of work was geared to general audience.

My point was that it wasn't that unusual that I didn't know her, and other people have agreed that she's not a household name. I can count the number of movies I've seen with Angelina Jolie on one finger (Mr. & Mrs. Smith, which I saw on TV when I was bored) but I still know who she is. Same with actors like, for example, Clint Eastwood (I don't actually think I've every watched a full movie he's been in). I don't need to have seen many (or even one) movie neccesarily to know who an actor is if they're very famous. Adams isn't super famous, regardless of what my movie tastes are.
The point was she's been in popular films, was nominated for an Oscar and has a certain level of name recognition.

Is the Amy Adams famous or not question answered now? If I'm making big posts in this thread, it might as well be more on topic, if more rage filled, stuff about the movie than arguing over whether the bland Lois in what looks to be a horrible Superman movie is very famous or not
Depends on what the next topic will be.
 
Comics:
About 25-30 issues of Silver age superman (from various DC Showcase collections)
Some Golden Age Superman stories
All of the JMS started "Grounded" arc before the reboot
The first six issues of All Star Superman
Various issues of Action comics
A lot of Justice League comics
A lot of various event comics and misc appearances, way too many to list

I'd say that, in general, I have a good amount of experience with Superman.

You haven't even scratched the surface of the character.

She's pretty enough, and Toby was dorky enough.

Fair enough.
 
I liked Dunst fine as Mary Jane. She's very attractive.

Not one of the guys who "slag off on women on the Internet," as you say, has ever been with anyone as attractive as the women they're criticizing. I guarantee you that.
They say that truth hurts. Sometimes it's just funny as hell. :guffaw:
 
Comics:
About 25-30 issues of Silver age superman (from various DC Showcase collections)
Some Golden Age Superman stories
All of the JMS started "Grounded" arc before the reboot
The first six issues of All Star Superman
Various issues of Action comics
A lot of Justice League comics
A lot of various event comics and misc appearances, way too many to list

I'd say that, in general, I have a good amount of experience with Superman.

You haven't even scratched the surface of the character.

So? I still know what superman is like (and I'd bet I've read/seen more with him than Snyder or Nolan). I don't need to have read every superman comic in the last 80 years to know what he's like. Moody, angsty, and having an earth Dad that tells him to let kids drown and having Jor El be some kind of fighter? Not superman. Bearded "hobo"? Not superman (outside of a hilarious looking silver age comic, apparently, and even then he didn't have a beard). He seriously looks like Christian bale's type of character in the bearded hobo clips, and all the clips look like generic dark superhero movie #456.

The Dark Man of Steel Rises just looks bad. Every clip makes it look worse. I haven't seen a superhero movie thats made me just shocked at how stupid it looked since Dark Knight Rises was showing tV spots/trailers. It will probably not be as bad as The dark Knight (I don't know if its possible to make a worse superhero movie than that) but its almost certainly going to suck. I'll admit that it is possible that it could be watchable (Snyder did direct a version of Watchman that I could sit through, even if the story still sucked) and its even possible it won't be as much of a Nolan superhero movie as I think, but it still looks like a bad superhero movie that will make Superman IV look like The Avengers.
 
This is my last say on the subject, as it's not about Superman...

I'm not trying to take down all silent films. On the other hand, a silent film in this day and age is just an artsy film for critics, period.

Really? Because the theater I saw it in wasn't full of critics. I'm not a critic. And everyone really enjoyed the movie. An art film doesn't make 133 million dollars world wide.

It's a FUN movie. It's got a lot of heart and soul. And incredibly charming performances. It's not an art film. It's done by the same guy who did the OSS 117 movies.

AND, the reason it's a silent movie is actually a part of it's story. I can't say more without spoiling it.

I can accept people using black and white and not strictly trying to make a movie for artsy movie critics, but a silent movie?

Why is black and white ok but not sound? That just seems random.

Why don't they just start giving out awards to cave paintings. They only made silent movies because they couldn't do movies with dialog.

They could do movies with dialogue. They used cards. You mean they couldn't do movie with sound, yes. Just like they made black and white movies because they couldn't do them with color.

It was a story telling CHOICE in The Artist.

As soon as they could, I'm pretty sure silent films basically disappeared. Its fine if people like it, but to me its just confusing and laughable to see a silent movie win anything outside of some film festival award.

It's confusing and laughable because you didn't see it. You are bound by a very narrow taste. And that's sorta sad.

It's like only eating hamburgers all of your life because you only like hamburgers. There is SO much more out there...

...but, I know, it's falling on deaf ears... so, with that...

I can't wait to see Man of Steel. It's the next big movie I'm putting on my calender...
 
Are silent films are actually the general audience? Yes, it must be so fun to see what wikipedia calls a romantic comedy-drama, without dialog. What is a "romantic comedy-drama" even supposed to be? I'm assuming thats just a fancy way of saying "chick flick". A french made, silent, black and white romance movie is definately an artsy movie, regardless of how much money it made. I may not have the most common tastes, but I refuse to believe that the average guy went and saw the Artist, atleast of their own free will. There is no way its a movie for the average person.
 
Comics:
About 25-30 issues of Silver age superman (from various DC Showcase collections)
Some Golden Age Superman stories
All of the JMS started "Grounded" arc before the reboot
The first six issues of All Star Superman
Various issues of Action comics
A lot of Justice League comics
A lot of various event comics and misc appearances, way too many to list

I'd say that, in general, I have a good amount of experience with Superman.

You haven't even scratched the surface of the character.

So? I still know what superman is like (and I'd bet I've read/seen more with him than Snyder or Nolan). I don't need to have read every superman comic in the last 80 years to know what he's like. Moody, angsty, and having an earth Dad that tells him to let kids drown and having Jor El be some kind of fighter? Not superman. Bearded "hobo"? Not superman (outside of a hilarious looking silver age comic, apparently, and even then he didn't have a beard). He seriously looks like Christian bale's type of character in the bearded hobo clips, and all the clips look like generic dark superhero movie #456.

The Dark Man of Steel Rises just looks bad. Every clip makes it look worse. I haven't seen a superhero movie thats made me just shocked at how stupid it looked since Dark Knight Rises was showing tV spots/trailers. It will probably not be as bad as The dark Knight (I don't know if its possible to make a worse superhero movie than that) but its almost certainly going to suck. I'll admit that it is possible that it could be watchable (Snyder did direct a version of Watchman that I could sit through, even if the story still sucked) and its even possible it won't be as much of a Nolan superhero movie as I think, but it still looks like a bad superhero movie that will make Superman IV look like The Avengers.
Why not just wait to see the movie before you condemn it?

If you don't want to see the movie because it will suck, why waste time and energy arguing about it?
 
I'm not one to normally "slag off on women on the internet", but in Dunst's case, I just never felt like she lived up to the Mary Jane Watson portrayal of the comics.

I take it you never read Ultimate Spider-Man.
Dunst pretty clearly wasn't playing Ultimate Mary-Jane. In fact, I'm not sure Ultimate Spider-Man even existed at the point that the script was written and the film was cast.
 
In fact, I'm not sure Ultimate Spider-Man even existed at the point that the script was written and the film was cast.

Ultimate Spider-Man started in 2000, Spider-Man came out in 2002, so unless they were filming for two years (and seeing as 9/11 caused a scene to get scraped thats very unlikely not to mention a Green Goblin suit that looks like the Ultimate Green Goblin design). So it did exist at that point and time.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top