• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds 2016 Review Thread

Strange New Worlds 2016

  • Outstanding

  • Above Average

  • Average

  • Below Average

  • Poor


Results are only viewable after voting.
From Q-Strike:

"Q," Picard asked. "Who are those beings over there?" He gestured toward a quartet of humanoid figures standing silently at the perimeter of the war, looking on with pained expressions upon their faces. Unlike the combatants, they had not assumed the garb of Earth's ancient warriors, wearing instead simple Grecian chitons made of what looked like common wool. Their faces were youthful and unmarked by time. They clasped their hands together before their chests in a meditative pose. Picard was struck by the aura of peace and dignity the beings projected, which reminded him somewhat of the sadly departed Sarak of Vulcan.

"Oh, them," Q said disdainfully. "Those are the Organians. Relative youngsters compared to the Continuum, but still reasonably evolved at this point in galactic history."

The Organians, Picard thought, wide-eyed and astounded. They were semi-mythical beings in his own time, legendary for their historic role in averting a bloody war between the Federation and the Klingon Empire decades before Picard's birth. The Organians had largely kept to themselves since then; Picard had never thought that he might actually see one in person.

Q was considerably less awestruck. "A bunch of upstart, idealistic kids, really. Slackers and layabouts, all of them. Compared to their childish doctrine of pacifism and noninterference, your Prime Directive is practically an incitement to riot."

Picard took Q's assessment of the early Organians with a grain of salt; small wonder Q dismissed a people who practiced the virtues of forbearance and restraint. The Federation of his own time owed a lot to the reluctant peacemaking of these people or their descendants. Still, he could not deny that the Organians of this era seemed content to stay on the sidelines during the Continuum's heated struggle to subdue 0. As he watched the cosmic battle develop, his doppelganger among the Q plucked a steel-tipped lance from the ether and hurled it at 0 himself, who materialized a disk-shaped shield just in time to block the spear. Deflected, the weapon ricocheted toward the assembled Organians, who merely shook their heads sadly at its approach. The spear vanished only seconds before it would have struck the placid spectators, followed a heartbeat later by the Organians themselves. The four figures dissolved into the emptiness of space, having apparently seen enough of the barbaric melee.

Though it's from Q, so I'd follow Picard's lead and take it with a large grain of salt.

BTW, glad you enjoyed "The Last Refuge"! And I'm very happy to see that the first two posters caught my Starfleet Academy reference. I was arguably violating the contest's rules by including a novel reference, but I pointed it out to my editor and they left it in (even though I offered an alternative line), so I'll take that as implicit approval.
 
It's what happened
before he was re-integrated? Or an alternate universe where he stayed...

It would have to be an alternate universe.

In the story, Captain Braxton is fully prepared to reintegrate with his homeless counterpart, who talks him out of it and is eventually left behind to live out the rest of his life. Either the Captain version reneged on the deal and beamed his old counterpart up anyway, or it really is another universe. Because in "Relativity", Braxton specifically makes reference to years of exile on 20th-century Earth and how he had to undergo extensive rehab before he was allowed to return to duty.
 
Organians are more powerful than Q?!? That seems unlikely.
I don't know why I bother, given that somebody else raised the same question without a spoiler tag!

And regarding TOC, I didn't find one as an actual page (e.g., a hyperlinked TOC page in a PDF), in what I downloaded to my Android tablet, but if I brought up the toolbar ("say 'ARCH'."), there was a menu button that brought up a TOC.
 
Last edited:
Half way through and have to say this series and this book just arent my thing. The older books usually had a story or two I got in to but so far nothing has here.
 
"The Seen and Unseen" didn't do much for me. Neither did "The Dreamer and the Dream." But I liked "Dilithium is a Girl's Best Friend" and "The Last Refuge."
 
I haven't read this yet, but I see there's a reference to either Zak Kebron or the Brikar race in general in "The Last Refuge." To catalog this in the Litverse Reading Guide, I'm wondering if anyone can tell me what specifically is referenced, and when does this story say it takes place? Thanks!
 
The thinly veiled mention of Zak Kebron was Chakotay saying "I remember Boothy telling me about a Klingon and a Brikar who were literally at each other's throats" in reference to the events of Star Trek: The Next Generation—Starfleet Academy #1: "Worf's First Adventure" by Peter David.

The framing story happens almost immediately after "Basics, Part 2" with Tuvok clearing out the late Lon Suder's quarters.

The flashbacks happen "mere days" before the events of "State of Flux" (when Seska is uncovered) but after Carey helps "in obtaining the Sikarian transporter" in "Prime Factors". (So around stardate 48650, though no stardates are used in the story.)
 
Thank you very much. I'll get this added to my Voyager page. Congratulations on your story!
Thanks! Love your site. Happened to have it open in another tab when I saw your post.

Also thanks to hbquikcomjamesl for the kind words. I've been a little sad to see SNW16 flying pretty low under the radar overall, but I'm gratified that I've seen quite a few call out my story as a favorite.

Though if you think it sucks don't feel shy to say so just because I'm hanging around. ;-)
 
^ The mods can update your status to "Writer", if you feel inclined to contact them.

Thanks! Though I'm not sure if I have the ability to do message mods (or anyone) with my "Newbie" status. This post will bring me up to 5 of the required 14. (I created this account in 2013 to post a message but hadn't used it again until SNW16 came out.)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top