• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds 2016 Review Thread

Strange New Worlds 2016

  • Outstanding

  • Above Average

  • Average

  • Below Average

  • Poor


Results are only viewable after voting.
^Maybe he's thinking of Star Wars Infinities, which was a comics miniseries in the vein of Myriad Universes or Marvel's What If...?
 
It bears repeating: Since at least a Pocket Books editor and CBS representative (presumably, though no editors listed) approved all these stories, they are not "fan fiction." I realize you probably know this and meant "fan fiction corner" to mean something like "wish fulfillment" or "continuity-focused" fiction, but I'm a persnickety enough nerd to not let it slide without a friendly (I hope) reminder. :)
Personally, I thought "Qarol," though not my favorite of the stories thus far, was wildly innovative and audacious - I would never have dreamed anyone could get away with a story like that. It would have fit nicely in the "Infinities" section of the old books.

It was a TNG story, cut and dried.
I mean "fan fiction" as quality (or lack thereof) judgment. It's licensed work and thus eligible content for Memory Beta.
 
What was the "Infinities" section? I know there was a "Speculations" section for stories that don't exclusively fit in one series, but I don't think I've heard of an "Infinities" section.
My apologies, I meant "Speculations." (I think one of those stories had the word "infinite" or "infinity" in its title, so that misled me... Probably also had the Marvel Star Wars Infinities in the back of my mind!)
 
My apologies, I meant "Speculations." (I think one of those stories had the word "infinite" or "infinity" in its title, so that misled me... Probably also had the Marvel Star Wars Infinities in the back of my mind!)
No apologies needed :)

Interestingly there is a The Lives of Dax short story titled Infinity, which depicts the death of Tobin Dax. An alternate version of that was presented in a SNW short story, called Trek. This boring fact was brought to you by: 12 seconds Memory Beta research, beacuse I apparantly don't have anything better to do
 
This story is set at the height of the Dominion War (or maybe not the height, the short story wasn't any more precise than pretty much "somewhen during the Dominon War".) If the story was set after the Romulans had joined the Federation and Klingons in their battle Worf shooting one of them would be very at least strange to outright stupid.
You're right here, I was just pointing out that we did see him that aggressive at one point.
 
Something that irritates me a bit about the Kindle version is that you can't go directly to a specific story you want. You can only search by show (TOS, TNG, DS9, Voyager) and you have to manually page through until you get the one you actually want to read. There's no table of contents. :mad:
 
Then why isn't there one in the macOS version? I always thought that a table of contents is part of the e-book itself, not a function of whichever app you choose to read it.

Especially since most of the other e-Books I have, DO have tables of contents (even when I read them with the macOS app). SNW '16 is the only one that does not.

Edit: I checked my iPad and it seems that when read with the Kindle iOS app, SNW '16 does have a TOC. Now I'm even more confused. Why would the same e-book only show its TOC on iOS and not on macOS? :confused:
 
Last edited:
I just read the Captain Braxton story. How can this be reconciled with "Relativity"?

In the SNW story, old homeless Braxton is left (at his own request) to live out his life on 20th-century Earth. But in "Relativity", Captain Braxton specifically says that all versions of himself were temporally integrated.
 
Got through two stories. I am a TOS fan but the first story was not that good. On the other hand the first TNG story was. I do not buy the Orgsnians are more powerful than the Q.
 
Got through two stories. I am a TOS fan but the first story was not that good. On the other hand the first TNG story was. I do not buy the Orgsnians are more powerful than the Q.
I think one of the Q Continuum novels established that the Organians were a "few levels" (or something similar) beneath the Q.
 
I did not recall that although I thought I read those three books.
I couldn't find anything to back my claim up, after searching through the books with the kindl search function, so I guess my mind made that up. Sorry.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top