• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Starship design history in light of Discovery

zlE4W8a.jpg
off topic but every time i watch this scene, i expect the niburans to be blown away when the deflector rises into view. and am always disappointed when they aren't.
 
Unless we conjecture that the Grissom is about eighty years old or even older and the way the Oberth-class ships look in that timeframe is due to a major Constitution-style refit to look newer. Which I can't say I buy without evidence to the affirmative.

Unfortunately, TNG threw a monkey wrench into the works by using the model in the show (80 years after STIII), and giving it an insanely high 5XXXX registry.
 
Please, no, not the registry thing again! They're not sequential, never were. Please, can we talk about the bridge window or is the Starfleet a military instead?
Well, given that Starfleet is a military organization, they have a registry system that sometimes needs to be done in a method that isn't always made public, further confusing starship captains when they look at other ships through the front window on the bridge.
 
off topic but every time i watch this scene, i expect the niburans to be blown away when the deflector rises into view. and am always disappointed when they aren't.

Blown away as in like by a leafblower or blown away as in 'whoa a deflector dish!'
 
  • Like
Reactions: pst
Don't some of the Mirandas and Excelsiors in TNG/DS9 have 5 digit numbers?

Yeah, more than a few of them. The Saratoga on which the Siskos are living at the time of the Battle of Wolf 359 is a Miranda-class starship with a five-digit registry number.
 
It could also be that the system for assigning registry numbers changed over time. Maybe pre-tos they were sequential, but then at some point, maybe 3-digit numbers were for science vessels and 4 for explorers, and within those systems the first one or two digits mean something and the next two are sequential. Given that the numbers are presented at random with regards to ship age or class and the only consistent thing about them is that over time, the numbers tend to get longer.
 
The Kelvin has been described as a colony supply vessel which could also help explain its four-digit number that begins with a 0. It would also help explain why a ship in service a couple of decades before the Constitution-class starships are first commissioned can carry nearly a thousand passengers and crew during a routine assignment whereas later starships seen in TOS and later chapters of the franchise carry signifcantly fewer personnel.
 
The Kelvin has been described as a colony supply vessel which could also help explain its four-digit number that begins with a 0. It would also help explain why a ship in service a couple of decades before the Constitution-class starships are first commissioned can carry nearly a thousand passengers and crew during a routine assignment whereas later starships seen in TOS and later chapters of the franchise carry signifcantly fewer personnel.
I like this idea. It also helps to show the evolution of the starships, given that they are built and manned with more increasing special tasks in mind.
 
The Kelvin would sport heavy phase cannon or phaser batteries due to its frequent visits to the frontier of Federation space near the Klingon and other hostile borders. Starfleet basically gives a frontline starship's firepower to a colony supply ship to protect the colonists en route to their new homes or back to other Federation planets.
 
The Kelvin would sport heavy phase cannon or phaser batteries due to its frequent visits to the frontier of Federation space near the Klingon and other hostile borders. Starfleet basically gives a frontline starship's firepower to a colony supply ship to protect the colonists en route to their new homes or back to other Federation planets.

There's gotta be someone on the Federation council driven crazy by this. "Couldn't we just not put all these colonies next to hostile borders?"
 
I read an article a while ago about how German UBoats were numbered out of sequence on purpose, because if the allies captured U-718 for instance, and the registration was sequential, they would know the Germans had built at least 718 UBoats.
I could see starfleet doing something similar with their ship registries.

(Not 100% sure it was the Germans but you get the idea)
 
Last edited:
I'd be fine with this system of numbering starting with the formation of the unified Federation Starfleet:

Three digits: early starships and then science and survey vessels.
Four digits: 23rd century starships and heavy explorers.
Four digits but the first is 0: colony supply and defense ships.
Five digits: 24th century vessels of any design and mission parameters.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top