• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Starfleet Admirals

James Wright

Commodore
Commodore
How many Starfleet Admirals have been killed fighting the Borg?
I count 2, Admiral Hanson at Wolf 359 and the Admiral that led Starfleet at Sector 001.

James
 
Is non-canon acceptable? Because...

Because I imagine some were killed during the recent Borg War
 
Admiral Owen Paris for one.

Officially I think it's only JP Hanson. Admiral Hayes from First Contact survived and was seen on Voyager.
 
How many Starfleet Admirals have been killed fighting the Borg?
I count 2, Admiral Hanson at Wolf 359 and the Admiral that led Starfleet at Sector 001.

James
Only Admiral Hanson was kill. Admiral Hayes survive the the destruction of his ship, by escaping in a life pod. Later he sent a encrypted message to Voyager. Which to place after the message in the bottle episode.
 
Then was Picard in the right for assuming Fleet Command?

Considering that he saved the planet, I rather imagine no one held it against him.

Ha, can you imagine though?

Admiral: "Thank God you showed up in time Picard, you saved the Federation!"
Picard: "I was only doing my duty, sir."
Admiral: "I'm glad you're here by the way, your under arrest and to be court martialed."
Picard: "Wait, what? Why!?"
Admiral: "Well, Jean-Luc, you did violate orders by leaving the Neutral Zone to come to Earth..."
Picard: "To save Earth from the Borg!"
Admiral: "And I'm sure that will be presented to the court. However, there is the matter of you usurping command of the fleet from Admiral Hayes."
Picard: "But his ship was destroyed --"
Admiral: "He was still alive, in an escape pod."
Picard: "He couldn't very well command the fleet while floating around in a glorified washing machine!"
Admiral: "I don't see why not? It does have a comm system."
*Two armed guards walk in and seize Picard by the arms*
"You'll be brought before the tribunal tonight and executed tomorrow, if found guilty."

*Next day, Picard is standing infront of the death pit. Admiral Jellico walks out and begins reading the conviction and sentence*

Picard: "Death for insubordination!? This is madness!"
Jellico *staring at Picard intently* "Madness?" *He turns and looks back at Nechayev, who nods* "Madness?

THIS IS THE FEDERATION!" *Kicks Picard into the pit*

And that's how you make the greatest Star Trek movie EVER. :D
 
Admiral Kathryn Janeway died while in Borg custody but it was more suicide than the Borg killing her.
 
If Admiral Hayes survived the destruction of his flagship he'd just transfer to another ship and that would become his flagship and he'd continue to command the fleet, that is if he were able to get to another ship!?


James
 
How many Starfleet Admirals have been killed fighting the Borg?
I count 2, Admiral Hanson at Wolf 359 and the Admiral that led Starfleet at Sector 001.

James
Only Admiral Hanson was kill. Admiral Hayes survive the the destruction of his ship, by escaping in a life pod. Later he sent a encrypted message to Voyager. Which to place after the message in the bottle episode.

Hayes made two Voyager appearances. First, in the S4 finale Hope And Fear, the one you mention in your post. And again in the S6 episode Lifeline.
 
If Admiral Hayes was able to he could have transferred command of the fleet to Picard.
Wish we could find out if there were other lower ranking flag officers present at the Battle of Sector 001!


James
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top