I am about 3/4 through the campaign now I think, and VERY impressed. It was a real thrill to walk on the hull of the Enterprise. The plot is great, the graphics are great, it's a real treat- like a new episode of next gen! I love it.
Yeah, it's nice and expansive, the new races are nicely developed. The dialogue in the end movies is REALLY clunky however, but I still enjoyed it.
Makes me wish for a game with a 3D engine that's not centred around shooting everything in sight, but more of an adventure game that plays out like a movie. Elite Force 2 is closer than Elite Force 1 with the tricorder stuff, but it's still an FPS.
I've been playing Marvel Ultimate Alliance on the Wii recently and getting off on the Silver Age geekfest that it is and building a dream team, but wouldn't that be a cool mechanic for a Star Trek game? Not a beat-em-up, but some kind of overarching time-travel/dimension-spanning storyline where you could put your own crew together to face whatever threat to the universe?