• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Prodigy General Discussion Thread

Given how important the growth of Star Trek is to CBS right now, I feel like there must be guarantees in place to ensure that Nickelodeon can’t mismanage this so blatantly, and then cancel it early. I’d assume, in the case of the latter, CBS would absolutely just move it to CBSAA, as a cancelled [and not saved] Trek show is not in their best interests at this time.

anyway, great interviews. I’m actually excited for this, to be honest.

Fair enough. But I think of all the major children's network out there, Nickelodeon tends to treat animated series the worst.

I mentioned cartoons like Harvey Beaks getting bad treatment from Nickelodeon, but Nickelodeon just sent their latest Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cartoon to Nicktoons and that is a franchise they bought back in 2009. Being sent to Nicktoons seems like a step right before cancellation. Cartoon Network and Disney seem to treat their new animated shows with more respect then Nickelodeon does, I would hope that this Star Trek show will be sent to Netflix or CBS All Access if it does not work out on Nickelodeon, rather then being to sent to die on the vine over at Nicktoons.

I feel like Nickelodeon had a better commitment to animation in the 90s, then they do today.
 
I mentioned cartoons like Harvey Beaks getting bad treatment from Nickelodeon, but Nickelodeon just sent their latest Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cartoon to Nicktoons and that is a franchise they bought back in 2009. Being sent to Nicktoons seems like a step right before cancellation.

To be fair, I think those episodes were probably aired on Nicktoons because they were too dark, intense, and violent for the younger-skewing Nickelodeon.
 
To be fair, I think those episodes were probably aired on Nicktoons because they were too dark, intense, and violent for the younger-skewing Nickelodeon.

I have not seen Rise of the TMNT, but I think it was supposed to be the goofy and light hearted cartoon compared with the 2003 and 2012 cartoons?

Also I heard Harvey Beaks was a fun slice of life cartoon that got sent to Nicktoons when it did not get Spongebob ratings.

Avatar the Last Airbender had a genocidal empire as the villains and that aired on Nick.

If Rise of the TMNT is too intense for Nick viewers, it makes me think this new Trek show will sent off to Nicktoons in short order as well.
 
I have not seen Rise of the TMNT, but I think it was supposed to be the goofy and light hearted cartoon compared with the 2003 and 2012 cartoons?

Oh, I thought it was the 2012 series you were talking about. I haven't paid attention to the new one, so I didn't know they'd moved it. Sorry.
 
“F-bombs” in Discovery? :rolleyes: In two seasons, I’ve heard “f-bombs” only once. Ffs. :vulcan:

Anyway, this looks like it could be interesting. :bolian:

Only once, but it was so memorable people understandably believe it happened often enough?

And it wasn't even that good of a scene to begin with. :(
 
Since this show about teenagers running away and finding an old ship to fix up, I wonder if Star Fleet will send a small ship to bring back these teens. Maybe someone like M'Ress could be leading a small team to get these kids back. M'Ress could be annoyed with such an assignment, but follow orders none the less and be a secondary, sympathetic antagonist.

If M'Ress does not appear, maybe one of M'Ress people, the Caitains (silly name, but whatever) could be one of the teenagers. It would be nice if the cast characters was a blend of humans and aliens.

Too esoteric a reference. Won't be used.

There is some new information about the Star Trek cartoon coming to Nickelodeon.

It's going to be a serialized series, rather than stand-alone:

https://comicbook.com/startrek/2019/10/19/star-trek-animated-series-nickelodeon-serialized-stories/

Also, it's not going to dumb things down, just to appeal to kids:

https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-nickelodeon-star-trek-show-wont-talk-down-to-its-yo-1838873110

I think you can make something that appeals to kids, but still gets the mythos of Star Trek right. However I think episodic TV is becoming a thing of the past, even kids cartoons have ongoing plots nowadays.

I hope Nickelodeon will not mistreat this show like they have some of their other shows, like say Harvey Beaks.

Hopefully but given how sci-fi nowadays by and large all do the nudge nudge wink wink self-aware garbage, meaning many shows seem to treat adults as children or teenagers anyway, what might that perceived implication imply?
 
John Eaves just leaked the name on his website that it will be called Star Trek: Prodigy.
 
Last edited:
John Eaves just leaked the name of his website that it will be called Star Trek: Prodigy.
Interesting!
According to an old online article, that’s one of the titles CBS trademarked in 2019. Link: https://www.escapistmagazine.com/v2...r-star-trek-section-31-and-star-trek-prodigy/

Prodigy. Strange word. Could refer to the ship & and theme, like Voyager before it, The word basically means wunderkind. Perhaps the central characters might be exceptionally intelligent, and capable survivors?
 
I guess that means he's working on it then Busy man.

https://www.atomicjohnnyspinups.com/about-me

Here's a screencap if he deletes it
unknown.png
 
Interesting!
According to an old online article, that’s one of the titles CBS trademarked in 2019. Link: https://www.escapistmagazine.com/v2...r-star-trek-section-31-and-star-trek-prodigy/

Prodigy. Strange word. Could refer to the ship & and theme, like Voyager before it, The word basically means wunderkind. Perhaps the central characters might be exceptionally intelligent, and capable survivors?

It makes sense, in most Nickelodeon shows are children as the protagonists (Avatar the Last Air Bender, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, etc) and the plot outlines mentioned teen outcasts finding an old starship and fixing it up and going on adventures with it.

I still think this is the most important show in Star Trek roster because it will bring in more new fans then Picard or Discovery will, because it will be aimed at kids.
 
I have not seen Rise of the TMNT, but I think it was supposed to be the goofy and light hearted cartoon compared with the 2003 and 2012 cartoons?

Also I heard Harvey Beaks was a fun slice of life cartoon that got sent to Nicktoons when it did not get Spongebob ratings.

Avatar the Last Airbender had a genocidal empire as the villains and that aired on Nick.

If Rise of the TMNT is too intense for Nick viewers, it makes me think this new Trek show will sent off to Nicktoons in short order as well.

I've never seen any of these things. The only Turtles cartoon I've seen is the one from 1987. So I have no frame of reference whatsoever. But if Nick is okay with Prodigy, then I guess it won't be as bad as all that other stuff?
 
I've never seen any of these things. The only Turtles cartoon I've seen is the one from 1987. So I have no frame of reference whatsoever. But if Nick is okay with Prodigy, then I guess it won't be as bad as all that other stuff?

Nickelodeon has a habit of mistreating shows that do not get Spongebob Squarepants level ratings right away.

Harvey Beaks and Welcome to the Wayne were apparently fun, interesting kids cartoons, but since Nickelodeon moved them around all the time, sent to another channel called Nicktoons and just cancelled them. Ditto with the latest TMNT cartoon.

I am hoping Nickelodeon will not treat this Star Trek show the same way. I think it will be one of the most important Star Trek shows of recent times, because it will introduce Star Trek to today's kids, so I hope Nickelodeon doesn't mistreat it.
 
Nickelodeon has a habit of mistreating shows that do not get Spongebob Squarepants level ratings right away.

Glad I stopped watching Nickelodeon after 1991. You Can't Do That On Television, Double Dare, Hey Dude, and Clarissa Explains It All. That's where it was at. And they had a cartoon called Count Duckula. Also Nick At Nite with old shows from the '50s and '60s. They even made their own original sitcom called Hi Honey, I'm Home with a '90s family living next door to a '50s sitcom family. Hilarity ensued.

Good times.

EDIT: I remember them showing TAS on Nickelodeon too.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top