• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek Generations novelization with original Kirk ending available anywhere in digital?

youngtrek

Commander
Red Shirt
Hi. I’m guessing that this may have been asked in the past at some point but I’m wondering if the Star Trek Generations novelization first edition/hardcover with original Kirk ending is available anywhere in digital format? I’m pretty sure that the Kindle version available via Amazon is the updated paperback version (with Kirk’s death scene mirroring what was in the actual film). I’ve got the hardcover. But I’m just wondering if maybe even just that chapter has ever been shared anywhere officially in a digital format? For comparison sake, without having to locate my print copy (and for those who may not have the hardcover and only have the eBook).

— David Young
 
Yeah, it's available the same place you can get an e-copy of the original version of Killing Time with extra slashy bits...

ETA: "the same place" I was referring to is "nowhere". Sorry my attempted joke didn't land. I wasn't suggesting it was available someplace piratical.

I've considered brushing up on an epub editor and manually typing the missing bits back into Killing Time myself, but that would be a LOT of work for something that only I would ever see.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. I’ve got a copy of the Generations novelization that I downloaded from probably a place very similar to the one you are referring to. (I later went on to buy the officially licensed Kindle ebook version, and, as I mentioned earlier, have had a physical copy of the original hardcover release since it first came out.) But I checked last night and that epub version still has Kirk falling off a collapsing bridge. So, it’s the paperback edition. (Which I also recognized by the price being on the front cover—a paperback range price for back then—and a “Special Edition” starburst in the upper right corner.)

— David Young
 
I should have a copy of the novelization with the original ending around somewhere, but that's in analog format.
 
I had no idea there were different endings to the book!

And of the film as well. Kirk's original fate didn't go over well with test audiences or something, since it wasn't heroic enough, so they went back and reshot the climax before the film was released. But by then it was too late to change the novelization, so its initial hardcover edition got published with the original, unseen ending. The paperback release around a year later was rewritten with the theatrical ending.
 
Not that anyone asked, but as far as I know, the YA novelization by John Vornholt only had one edition, though I don't recall checking back then. It came out at the same time as JM Dillard's hardcover and almost certainly had the original ending. (Each of the TNG movies had a JM Dillard novelization and a John Vornholt YA novelization.)
 
Last edited:
YA novelizations also have an annoying tendency not to include the entire ending, and would often not include icky things like death scenes, so it may not be an issue with Vornholt's book....
 
I'm suddenly confused. I very distinctly recall Kirk's death in the movie: Kirk and Picard discussing whether he'd made a difference, and his last words, "It's been fun."

And that's his death scene in the first edition hardcover novelization I have.

I don't recall anything different.
 
I'm suddenly confused. I very distinctly recall Kirk's death in the movie: Kirk and Picard discussing whether he'd made a difference, and his last words, "It's been fun."

And that's his death scene in the first edition hardcover novelization I have.

I don't recall anything different.
If the death scene in the hardcover you have matches what's shown in the film with the bridge and all, versus Kirk being shot by Soran, then you don't have the first edition.
 
I'm suddenly confused. I very distinctly recall Kirk's death in the movie: Kirk and Picard discussing whether he'd made a difference, and his last words, "It's been fun."

And that's his death scene in the first edition hardcover novelization I have.

I don't recall anything different.

Well, a couple things come to my mind after reading that. #1, I wonder if there was more than one printing of the hardcover edition perhaps. And also, I wonder if the Science Fiction Book Club was still doing their own exclusive printings of some of the Star Trek novels at that point in time.

As for what you have there, does Kirk get shot by Soran in the back? Or does he fall and get crushed by the metal bridge he’d been fighting with Soran on. It’s possible that he still had that last conversation with Picard even after getting shot, if it didn’t kill him right away.


David Young
 
As for what you have there, does Kirk get shot by Soran in the back? Or does he fall and get crushed by the metal bridge he’d been fighting with Soran on. It’s possible that he still had that last conversation with Picard even after getting shot, if it didn’t kill him right away.
That could be it. I didn't go far enough back in the book to see one vs. the other, but that's certainly easier (and less time-consuming) to check than digging out the DVD and replaying the scene while following along in the book. I'll try and remember to look again this evening.

The movie, and the book, are over 30 years old, and it's been quite a few years since the last time I saw the movie or read the book. And I forget details even of books I've read dozens of times, like DD's most revered ST classics. I remembered that somebody had written a throwaway scene in a ST novel about an Enterprise crew member whose metabolism was fueled by ethanol, and who got drunk on organic acids, but I had to do a fair amount of research before I uncovered that it wasn't (as I'd initially thought) ADF in one of the Star Trek Logs, but rather Joe Haldeman, in Planet of Judgment (probably the only comic relief in a book that had an otherwise very serious tone).

And yes, it is the first edition hardcover. Purchased while the movie was in first-run. And the copyright page says as much.

*********

And yes, Soran shoots him in the back in the novelization. Then again, I've been used to odd differences between what's on the screen and what's on the page for a long time. Since Blish adapted a script for "The Trouble With Tribbles" from before Chekov was given all of Sulu's lines (because George was off filming The Green Berets).
 
Last edited:
Now you're making me wish I hadn't traded the hardback novelization for the paperback one; because now I can't remember if the hardback edition had the original or the corrected death of Kirk. I'm leaning toward it being the original with Kirk being shot in the back.
I do know that the hardback novelization of Nemesis includes the deleted scenes and alternate ending with Picard meeting his new First Officer, played by Steven Culp.​
 
Pretty sure I had the YA book when I was little, and pretty sure Kirk got shot. But it has been a very, very long time.

Also remember the FC YA novel, where the Queen had flowing black hair... and a picture section with photos from the movie showing her bald.
 
Pretty sure I had the YA book when I was little, and pretty sure Kirk got shot. But it has been a very, very long time.

Also remember the FC YA novel, where the Queen had flowing black hair... and a picture section with photos from the movie showing her bald.
As a kid, I was very confused by the photo inserts in my edition of 2001: A Space Odyssey, where the characters went to Jupiter, unlike the book I was reading, where they went to Saturn.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top