• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Space Nazis!

Space Nazis - Good, bad or indifferent?

  • Space Nazis good

    Votes: 22 34.4%
  • Space Nazis bad

    Votes: 36 56.3%
  • Space Nazis indifferent

    Votes: 6 9.4%

  • Total voters
    64
The ones in Ent were not just Space Nazis (like the ones in Patterns of Force, who actually had some interstellar capability as well) but the next step up in silliness -
ALIEN Space Nazis...Of The FUTURE!!!

See! See!! That makes it cool!! The episode was made of win, simply because of that. Also that phaser battle in new york was pretty cool
 
I hated it. I already thought Zero Hour was a bit of a letdown after the excellent Countdown, but it seemed to be doing its job; then we got the twist ending. I've got no problem with twist endings per se, but that one was completely absurd - it deflated the drama of the Xindi arc. I thought Storm Front parts 1 and 2 were pretty much a complete waste - I just wish the last scene of that two-parter had been the last scene of Zero Hour and that we'd had Home as the opener for Season 4.

I've got to say, people rave about how great Season 4 is, but it still contains Storm Front parts 1 and 2 AND These Are the Voyages.
 
I love Space Nazis...you can kill 'em all and not feel bad at all.

Just like Space Hippies. You can watch them die in agony and not feel bad about it at all. Doesn't make 'em any less obnoxious, though.

I never boycotted Trek. Ever. I give everything a shot, and I usually end up liking it. But...should Space Nazis ever again make a special guest appearance on the big or the small screen, I swear I'm going to stay the fuck away from it - lest I bust a tit or something.

God, I hate Space Nazis. They are lame and weak and just plain stupid. Can't writers come up with anything more original and less cliched? With all the aliens emulating the actual Nazis, I wonder if they have any knowledge of our history, or they just fancy the cool uniforms.
 
With all the aliens emulating the actual Nazis, I wonder if they have any knowledge of our history, or they just fancy the cool uniforms.

It must be the cool uniforms. Somewhere I read that a young Hugo Boss designed at least some of the outfits. Don't know if its true though.
 
Space Nazis are of course bad, very bad, but by that time I'd given up on ENT being anything other than monumentally silly, so for me it was kind of good, being excellent fodder for hilarity while waiting for the fall season to start.
 
And I used to love me a man in a nice Hugo Boss suit.... when in all likelihood, it's just an Space Alien Lizard Nazi from the Future. Always up to something, aren't they?

Damn it.
 
When I saw the finale of the Xindi story, and we got that shot of the alien nazi, I laughed.

Well, that was a far better response than I had. There I was, watching the season finale of what started to be a much better season of ENT than what had come before, the Xindi arc was finally concluded, and then the final scene shows some alien in an SS uniform? WTF??? I can truthfully say that I was extremely pissed off. I went to bed with all kinds of unhappiness that night.

THIS, THIS, THIS! I was SO angry, I couldn't sleep! I told my wife, "F-ing Space Nazis! Star Trek is dead!" Glad I was wrong about about ST being dead. :techman:

I was SO turned off, I didn't bother to watch season 4 until that weird syndication package a year later that only showed about 65-75% of the eps from season two and a few season 1 and 2 eps. That was plain WEIRD, however, it was enough to wet my appetite for more of season 4. I did eventually see season 4 on DVD and found it better than 1 or 2, maybe a fraction better than season 3 overall.

However, as mentioned above, season 4 did include the idiotic Space Nazi wrap up and the unforgivable misfunctioning halodeck dreck/"Valentine" TATV. :vulcan:
 
]The VOY Nazis were, if I recall correctly, neither "space" (being Earth-set holograms) nor Nazis, just Hirogen meanies dressed in SS duds.

:wtf: Being a Hirogen in a SS uniform makes one a Space Nazi.
Even without the Nazi ideology?
Kirk and Spock also wore the uniforms, does that make them Space Nazis too?
No but the guys John Gill taught Nazi 101 to were. They my be the only true "Space Nazis" since they are the only one who actually practiced Nazism.
 
Space Nazis are fucking awesome. Not only was the scene in Zero Hour quite possibly the best cliffhanger ever, the Alien Nazi fired up my imagination summer of 2004.

While Storm Front is an entertaining enough episode, and its take on alternate WWII history is quite enjoyable, I was still somewhat disappointed in a story that could have been so much more. I wanted the aliens to actually be 20th century aliens being manipulated by Future Guy (much like how he manipulated the Suliban in the 22nd century) and were acting on his orders, secretly involved in WWII for whatever reasons. Maybe they wouldn't reveal the reasons, not much about the TCW and nothing about Future Guy ever was revealed. And I mean actual WWII, not alternate timeline that gets erased WWII. I wanted it to be an epic tale featuring Hitler (not stock footage spliced together to make it look like he's visiting America), Churchill, Eisenhower, Roosevelt, Stalin. Sigh.

Oh well, the alternate history angle was fun. Unfortunately, they had less of a budget in the fourth season, and it showed. The initial description of a Nazi occupied White House sounded awesome, but cheap CGI ruined it and made it look crappy. Was it so hard to take an actual image of the White House and digitally insert Nazi flags and banners?

Vosk was a cool villain with some awesome dialogue. "Every moment we live we travel through time. We've earned the right to decide which direction."

Overall, I consider the Space Nazis to be among the most awesome things Star Trek has ever delivered. While Star Trek may be more remembered for the more profound and serious contributions TOS, TNG, and DS9 gave us (and well it should) it never hurts to sometimes let your hair down and have fun, and therefore there will always be room for a Space Nazi in whatever incarnation of Star Trek we watch.
 
When I saw the finale of the Xindi story, and we got that shot of the alien nazi, I laughed.

Well, that was a far better response than I had. There I was, watching the season finale of what started to be a much better season of ENT than what had come before, the Xindi arc was finally concluded, and then the final scene shows some alien in an SS uniform? WTF??? I can truthfully say that I was extremely pissed off. I went to bed with all kinds of unhappiness that night.

THIS, THIS, THIS! I was SO angry, I couldn't sleep! I told my wife, "F-ing Space Nazis! Star Trek is dead!" Glad I was wrong about about ST being dead. :techman:

I was SO turned off, I didn't bother to watch season 4 until that weird syndication package a year later that only showed about 65-75% of the eps from season two and a few season 1 and 2 eps. That was plain WEIRD, however, it was enough to wet my appetite for more of season 4. I did eventually see season 4 on DVD and found it better than 1 or 2, maybe a fraction better than season 3 overall.

However, as mentioned above, season 4 did include the idiotic Space Nazi wrap up and the unforgivable misfunctioning halodeck dreck/"Valentine" TATV. :vulcan:

I was happy -- it was a great Twilight Zone/Outer Limits twist moment that is lacking in most modern sci-fi.
 
Despite my earlier comments about the cliffhanger being the best cliffhanger ever, I do admit on the night Zero Hour aired, I wasn't exactly enthusiastic. I wasn't particularly angry or disappointed, in fact when the alien walked forward from the shadowy corner and the credits rolled I just sat there of ten seconds and then said "well that was fucked up," then turned the TV off. Time helped me appreciate that for the excellence that it was, and made me realize it is indeed the best cliffhanger ever.
 
Space Nazis are evil and must die. All of them. Forever. They serve no purpose other than being an excuse for writers to be fucking lazy. They are so lame. That season 3 finale was the lamest thing I have ever seen. They ruined a perfectly fine story. I was so angry I thought my head would explode.
 
Time helped me appreciate that for the excellence that it was, and made me realize it is indeed the best cliffhanger ever.

I would have to respectfully disagree with you (providing you were serious in the first place). What makes a good cliffhanger is that the ending is unexpected, but at the same time has something to do with the story being told. Look at the cliffhangers for "Best of Both Worlds Pt. I" and "Redemption Pt. I." In both instances, the whole story is being built up for the appearance of Locutus and Sela, respectively. In "Zero Hour," the story is basically concluded, and then all of a sudden some alien space Nazi appears out of nowhere (and no segue at all that all of a sudden, now we're in the past), has nothing to do with the story we've just seen, and basically only exists to awkwardly conclude the TCW thing that nobody really cared about anyway. I mean, c'mon! If they really felt that they had to give the TCW silliness some kind of closure, why didn't they just reveal who FutureGuy was? How about making him a Romulan who's trying to prevent Earth from winning the Earth-Romulan war that would have been a major factor in the series if it had been allowed to continue? Why space Nazis?
 
Meh... All fans ever want to do is get pissed off at trivial things and complain. Wah. Wah. Wah.

There was nothing wrong with Space Nazis. It was a way to end season 3 with a cliffhanger and get them to tune in to see what happens. That's what a TV show is supposed to do to keep them interested over the break.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top