• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

So I returned a laptop battery to Dell

propita

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Hubby and I bought his youngest brother a laptop (Dell) a few years back. Some time ago, the battery went bad--the laptop didn't even recognize its existence.

So I called up and ordered a new battery...from Dell. It gets here and we finally get it into the computer--and it doesn't work. The computer "saw" it, but it wouldn't take a charge. When I call Dell to return it, they said "Oh, you're over the 21 day return policy."

No supervisor to speak with wherever the hell "customer service" was located. No way to contact Dell in the US--which I'm told is very typical of them. So, since I bought it using Amex, I called them. They said that since it didn't work from the start, it didn't qualify as my breaking it, so sorry, no help there.

BUT...then I get a letter from Amex, that they've stopped the disputed charge, contacted Dell, and got an RMA number for me to return the battery (return receipt)--and send that to Amex. And no charge for the battery.

So, I did all that, and included a letter which stated things like "while customer service was not rude, they were not helpful--perhaps they lack sufficient authority to deal with problems," that a 21-day from date of order return limit is inadequate since it inhibits customers buying backups and "perhaps Dell should suggest clearly that customers check upon receipt any item purchased," and that since I had ordered the battery by phone to ensure I got the right model (and relied on the verbal representations that it would work), these reassurances that the battery was the correct model and would work was an express warranty that superseded any written disclaimer, per the Uniform Commercial Code, Art. II, section 2-316(a).

A friend who's actually certified for Dell laptops checked it out, ordered a battery, and determined that both the original and the one we bought were bad--that it was NOT the laptop, as claimed by Dell.

So, at least we only paid for ONE working battery.

I guess that if I were to buy from Dell in the future, I would make sure that I use a credit card that's willing to halt payment on disputed amounts.
 
I've used quite a few Dell brand computers over the years, none of which I owned. I found that most of those I used had recurring problems: sudden loss of keyboard function, or mouse function, or floppy drive function. The only way I could restore them was to reboot. I think it was all bios related.

I have no confidence in the brand.
 
Third'd. I had a Dell, the screen cracked while it was sitting on the counter, unplugged and idle. I'm cooking lunch, hear a SNAP, look over and the display had a diagonal crack from one corner to the other.

My experience with their "support" line prompted me to switch to IBM. NEVER had a problem (other than price) with IBM/Lenovo.
 
I worked for Dell in the warranty division (specifically HDD replacement/software imaging). Believe me when I tell you I have no confidence in the brand.


J.
 
What's odd is that my two Dell laptops have had no problems--and they've had far more work on them than my brother-in-law's.

But this has...disenchanted...me with the brand for future purchases.
 
Well, as I discussed with J. Allen in another thread a few weeks ago, after much angst I recently bit the bullet and purchased another Dell laptop. The good news is that it arrived last week and seems to be in good order and I've already grown to absolutely love the thing.

That is, after 2 delays, topped off by some shipping issues, and several completely unsatisfying calls to customer support. My ordering experience was actually very positive, but all subsequent communications with them were horrible, and they were pretty much completely frustrating and incompetent. I was so disillusioned I'd decided that if the computer had even the tiniest thing wrong when it arrived i was returning it and switching to a Mac.

For better or worse, it arrived fine and runs better than any laptop I've ever used.

Keeping my fingers crossed, and hoping the OP's issues have been resolved once and for all.
 
I worked for Dell in the warranty division (specifically HDD replacement/software imaging). Believe me when I tell you I have no confidence in the brand.

J.

Have you worked in the warranty divisions of many other major computer manufacturers to make a useful comparison?
 
I worked for Dell in the warranty division (specifically HDD replacement/software imaging). Believe me when I tell you I have no confidence in the brand.

J.

Have you worked in the warranty divisions of many other major computer manufacturers to make a useful comparison?

Do you need to clean every toilet in existence to know that they have been full of shit?
 
I worked for Dell in the warranty division (specifically HDD replacement/software imaging). Believe me when I tell you I have no confidence in the brand.

J.

Have you worked in the warranty divisions of many other major computer manufacturers to make a useful comparison?

He has not said that he has no confidence in any of the other manufacturers. Just that after working for them, he has no confidence in DELL. There is no comparison to make here.
 
Do you need to clean every toilet in existence to know that they have been full of shit?

You can assert that all toilets are full of shit, but whilst that may be true it's not particularly useful as we still need to use them. A meaningful comparison would be between the amount and types of shit contained in various toilets, and to make that comparison one does need to have experienced more than one toilet.

Incidentally, the Bristol Stool Chart identifies seven types of shit.
 
I had a Dell laptop issued to me a few years ago, a model from the budget "Inspiron" line. Multiple hardware failures in the first 6-12 months. I bought an IBM ThinkPad T42 to replace it in mid-2005 and I'm still using it now, after being heavily upgraded and modded by me. It even survived having coffee spilled on it due to the drain system built into the keyboard.

I'm planning to get something in the W500 line around Q4 2009 or Q1 2010 once Windows 7 and the new Intel processor architecture hit the market.
 
I would make sure that I use a credit card that's willing to halt payment on disputed amounts.

All credit cards should do that. I can't imagine why any one wouldn't. I thought it was a standard feature. What kind of bank wouldn't allow you to dispute a charge?
 
My hubby buys all the laptops for the university department in which he works. They get Acers, and practically nothing but Acers, because 1) most of the Acers are just as good as Dell, but cheaper and 2) the difficulties with Dell's customer service. The products, he claims, are usually good, although the mileage may vary, but in the last three or four years, the service has become complete crap.

At least that is his experience. Just thought I'd pass that along.
 
I had to take my work Dell laptop apart this morning and re-seat the memory. It wouldn't boot up until I did as it was complaining during POST about a problem during the memory check.

Self Service IT. :mad:
 
I worked for Dell in the warranty division (specifically HDD replacement/software imaging). Believe me when I tell you I have no confidence in the brand.

J.

Have you worked in the warranty divisions of many other major computer manufacturers to make a useful comparison?

Excuse me? I only made my comment regarding Dell, hence "no confidence in the brand". I don't know where you got the idea I meant every manufacturer. I don't need to see other manufacturing facilities for other companies to know the fail rate for my own company's products. See how that works?


My hubby buys all the laptops for the university department in which he works. They get Acers, and practically nothing but Acers, because 1) most of the Acers are just as good as Dell, but cheaper and 2) the difficulties with Dell's customer service. The products, he claims, are usually good, although the mileage may vary, but in the last three or four years, the service has become complete crap.

At least that is his experience. Just thought I'd pass that along.

Dell and Acer are both offering netbooks with similar specs. When the choice came down to it for what I needed (reliability, portability, dependability, cost), the Acer AspireOne beat the Dell hands down every time. I saved $120 going with the AspireOne and I'm happy.

J.
 
I have a Dell laptop and i totally love the thing. No problems at all on my end.

Good! I hope it stays that way!
But if it doesn't, just keep an eye out on your hard drive, fan and LCD screen hinges. Those tend to go first.


J.
 
Can I ask a question?

No love for Toshibas?

They were the first real laptops I used and I found them pretty good for the times (late 90s). They certainly used to have a solid reputation. Has something gone wrong?
 
Can I ask a question?

No love for Toshibas?

They were the first real laptops I used and I found them pretty good for the times (late 90s). They certainly used to have a solid reputation. Has something gone wrong?

Unfortunately, they seem to have fallen off the radar (at least for me). I haven't heard anything innovative from them in a long time, although I do say their televisions are fantastic (we have one)! :D


J.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top