• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

SNW questions

iggyspock

Ensign
Newbie
Okay, so I have been watching SNW recently and have been slowly getting through it. I am only starting season 3 so no spoilers past that please!!!

Anyways, I just had a few questions for other people who have watched it.
Have you seen the 'musical' one, if so what did you think of it?
Have you finished it and was it worth watching?
What are your overall thoughts on the series?
Do you think it's well written or poorly written?
Do you like Spock's relationship with Chapel?
Do you like how Kirk is portrayed?
Would you rate this as one of the better Star Trek series, or one of the worst ones?

Overall for me, I do enjoy the series I will not lie, I do like Pike in this series I think he is portrayed really well, I think the script is written well in some aspects, although in others it's not written well at all, I found the 'musical' episode very funny yet making the series look a bit silly and having some series topics just messed up with the characters singing.
I also don't know how I feel about Spock with nurse Chapel. I did like Spock with T'Pring, I felt she was very patient with him and she understood alot of the times that he didn't know how to control his emotions or how he was even feeling at times. I disliked that Chapel wanted their relationship to be a secret, just to break out in song to tell Spock she is happily going to leave him, than Spock apologising for nothing he did wrong he was just trying to support her and she just threw it in her face. I'm not a huge fan of Spock written this way at all to be honest, but maybe he will get better within this next series, I hope Chapel leaves for the next season too, I really don't want her and Spock to get together again.
Again I haven't seen season three, just wanted to ramble a bit before I start watching it.

I am really looking forward to hearing other peoples opinions on this series, I know people either like it or dislike it, it's very split but I am very intrested in peoples sides of how they look at things.

Iggy Out.
 
Okay, so I have been watching SNW recently and have been slowly getting through it. I am only starting season 3 so no spoilers past that please!!!

Anyways, I just had a few questions for other people who have watched it.
Have you seen the 'musical' one, if so what did you think of it?
Have you finished it and was it worth watching?
What are your overall thoughts on the series?
Do you think it's well written or poorly written?
Do you like Spock's relationship with Chapel?
Do you like how Kirk is portrayed?
Would you rate this as one of the better Star Trek series, or one of the worst ones?

Overall for me, I do enjoy the series I will not lie, I do like Pike in this series I think he is portrayed really well, I think the script is written well in some aspects, although in others it's not written well at all, I found the 'musical' episode very funny yet making the series look a bit silly and having some series topics just messed up with the characters singing.
I also don't know how I feel about Spock with nurse Chapel. I did like Spock with T'Pring, I felt she was very patient with him and she understood alot of the times that he didn't know how to control his emotions or how he was even feeling at times. I disliked that Chapel wanted their relationship to be a secret, just to break out in song to tell Spock she is happily going to leave him, than Spock apologising for nothing he did wrong he was just trying to support her and she just threw it in her face. I'm not a huge fan of Spock written this way at all to be honest, but maybe he will get better within this next series, I hope Chapel leaves for the next season too, I really don't want her and Spock to get together again.
Again I haven't seen season three, just wanted to ramble a bit before I start watching it.

I am really looking forward to hearing other peoples opinions on this series, I know people either like it or dislike it, it's very split but I am very intrested in peoples sides of how they look at things.

Iggy Out.
I’ve been a Star Trek fan since I was a kid, which probably makes a difference, but here are my answers.
Have you seen the 'musical' one, if so what did you think of it? I’ve seen it and enjoyed it. The plot is a bit ridiculous and the lyrics are a touch New Age, but the performances were terrific. The actresses who play La’an and Uhura are obviously stage-trained singers. The singing Klingons alone made it worth it.
Have you finished it and was it worth watching? Yes, I’ve seen all of it and yes, I thought it was worth watching.
What are your overall thoughts on the series? Overall, one of my favorites.
Do you think it's well written or poorly written? Some episodes are better written than others. It suffers from having only 10 episodes a season. They had to cram a lot of plot into a short period.
Do you like Spock's relationship with Chapel? I liked it in the beginning. I wasn’t overly happy with the break up and rebound relationships.
Do you like how Kirk is portrayed? I think the Kirk actor has been doing a good job. There might be a little too much Kirk at this point in the series.
Would you rate this as one of the better Star Trek series, or one of the worst ones? One of the more entertaining of the new Trek series. It’s my favorite of the bunch.
 
Have you seen the 'musical' one, if so what did you think of it?
Loved it
Have you finished it and was it worth watching?
Yes
What are your overall thoughts on the series?
Excellent
Do you think it's well written or poorly written?
Well written
Do you like Spock's relationship with Chapel?
Yes
Do you like how Kirk is portrayed?
Yes
Would you rate this as one of the better Star Trek series, or one of the worst ones?
One of the better
 
Anyways, I just had a few questions for other people who have watched it.
I have watched it
Have you seen the 'musical' one, if so what did you think of it?
Yes. it's excellent.
Have you finished it and was it worth watching?
I have watched all three of the seasons available. It is well worth watching Looking forward to seasons four and five.
What are your overall thoughts on the series?
Great show. Great addition to the franchise.
Do you think it's well written or poorly written?
Well written for the most part.
Do you like Spock's relationship with Chapel?
I do.
Do you like how Kirk is portrayed?
Yes I do.
Would you rate this as one of the better Star Trek series, or one of the worst ones?
Easily in the top three.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top