I've always been a Chakotay fan, but felt that the series never really used him to his potential. Kirsten has done that with Full Circle and Unworthy, but Christie Golden did an ok job with him (and the rest of the crew) as well in the 4 books she did. I read the SW duology and liked it just fine, but FC and Unworthy really blew them out of the water in terms of quality. It's really a pale comparison...