SJA 2X05/06: Secrets of the Stars
- Thread starter Csalem
- Start date
Wow I was right. Lame trailer = good episode! 
Nice performances all around, though the actor playing Mr Truman got dangerously close to going OTT.
So who else was sitting through most of the episode with your fingers crossed going "Mandragora Helix. Oh please, oh please, oh please!"
Nice performances all around, though the actor playing Mr Truman got dangerously close to going OTT.
So who else was sitting through most of the episode with your fingers crossed going "Mandragora Helix. Oh please, oh please, oh please!"
Well I'll give a full report once we have pt 2 available, but on the whole a good solid episode. Russ Abbott was good in places but, as said above, dangerously OTT in others. I think what's great about this 'kids' show is that it doesn't talk down to kids.
One down point-Considering how good Clyde seems as an actor I thought his possessed Clyde was bad!
One down point-Considering how good Clyde seems as an actor I thought his possessed Clyde was bad!
I thought he danced a merry jig across the line a few times.Wow I was right. Lame trailer = good episode!
Nice performances all around, though the actor playing Mr Truman got dangerously close to going OTT.
Clyde has been fun this season. But the same thing happened with Micky and Yanto too. Boring nobs in season one reading for a renaissance in season two...
I do wish that the flash back been to the 70s or even the 5 doctors if they really wanted to over egg the pudding.
I do wish that the flash back been to the 70s or even the 5 doctors if they really wanted to over egg the pudding.
I must say I enjoyed the first part of this story. I was fairly impressed with Russ Abbott who played a rather sinister Mr. Truman, although I did roll my eyes when he started shouting and shooting the "ancient lights" at Sarah Jane and Rani, not very convincing at all.
The budding relationship between Rani and Sarah is also promising, as Truman noted, Rani is Sarah Jane's companion.
Sorry for the random thoughts, but I do think that next weeks solution has been pretty much spelled out. Truman takes over people through their star signs=Luke doesn't have a star sign. hmm
The budding relationship between Rani and Sarah is also promising, as Truman noted, Rani is Sarah Jane's companion.
Sorry for the random thoughts, but I do think that next weeks solution has been pretty much spelled out. Truman takes over people through their star signs=Luke doesn't have a star sign. hmm
I must say I enjoyed the first part of this story. I was fairly impressed with Russ Abbott who played a rather sinister Mr. Truman, although I did roll my eyes when he started shouting and shooting the "ancient lights" at Sarah Jane and Rani, not very convincing at all.
The budding relationship between Rani and Sarah is also promising, as Truman noted, Rani is Sarah Jane's companion.
Sorry for the random thoughts, but I do think that next weeks solution has been pretty much spelled out. Truman takes over people through their star signs=Luke doesn't have a star sign. hmm
aha, good point!
A fairly good episode, although not all the much better than last week's story. Russ Abbott was pretty good as Mr. Truman, I'll admit, so hopefully next week's will be a satisfying conclusion.
Oh, did anyone else catch the Frontier in Space reference?
Actually, I didn't. However, when Rani mentioned "another universe," I started chanting "E-Space! E-Space!"
Yeah, same here. Either all or nothing, although I don't think the flashback was all that necessary anyways.
Oh, did anyone else catch the Frontier in Space reference?
No, but that was a Katey Manning story...
The Star Ship Terminus is from the last universe, but that isn't a Sarah Jane Story either... Although the pilot was a huge Immortal man-Goat which seems terrible coincidental not to be a little astrologic.
The Star Ship Terminus is from the last universe, but that isn't a Sarah Jane Story either... Although the pilot was a huge Immortal man-Goat which seems terrible coincidental not to be a little astrologic.
at the half way point, waiting for episode 2 now, Rani is GOOD (think the bit where she works out at was from a time before the Big Bang, would like to know what Doctor Who has said about that previously)
and yeah the flashback to theDoctor should have been to either the 3rd or 4th, however dare I hope that, that is set up for his appearance in the 2nd part?
more later
and yeah the flashback to theDoctor should have been to either the 3rd or 4th, however dare I hope that, that is set up for his appearance in the 2nd part?
more later
ok Part 2, everyone turning into mindless zombies, um not to criticise the show, but that has been done to death already, sadly no sign of the Doctor, well none of the actual Doctor, but Luke does his best impression of him, joining the circle and breaking it like he did.
Mr Smith saying "nothing his happening" when something was, is actually a bit creepy.
however I would like to ask one question, if Trueman has taken over TV, how come the TV news channels were still on air?
Mr Smith saying "nothing his happening" when something was, is actually a bit creepy.
however I would like to ask one question, if Trueman has taken over TV, how come the TV news channels were still on air?
Internet streams?
possibly
I did think the same thing though.
im sure we are not the only ones
I wondered the same thing. But despite that, despite the reuse of the hypnotised masses from The Christmas Invasion, not to mention Truman doing an "Astrid" at the end, I liked it. Possibly that's for Clyde's imortal Aero will enter the Galaxy line.
I'm not sure if you have to be British to get that or not.
This does prove why Moffat needs to move Who away from the obsession with modern day Earth (or at least change the emphasis) The everyday mum and dad in peril is just becoming very repetetive now.
Again, another fairly good episode, but this season isn't quite up to par as the last season (except for the first serial). I really loved Clyde's astrological bullshitting. The reference to Planet of the Spiders and The Hand of Fear was great, too. 
Hopefully the next three stories will be better. I have a feeling the last one will be great.
Hopefully the next three stories will be better. I have a feeling the last one will be great.
