• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Season 5 the final episode. Too many happy endings epilogue for the Burnham clan

Status
Not open for further replies.

urrutiap

Captain
Captain
MIcheal being admiral and married to Book. then their son coming home to visit while he's in Starfleet Academy or him coming home from a ship he's on.

thats all you get to see in the series finale last episode. the show doesn't even hint at or even show Saru and his Vulcan wife's weird looking half breed children if they even had kids
 
i just frikkin said the son was visiting from EITHER the academy or from his ship or whatever. Pay attention next time before you reply to a topic thread


Leto isn't a cadet. He's an actual captain.

And apparently somebody in the Booker family is a fan of Dune... ;)
 
No, Leto is definitely a captain. He's on his way to his new command.

Although he did say that he FELT like a cadet again.
 
Last edited:
the show doesn't even hint at or even show Saru and his Vulcan wife's weird looking half breed children if they even had kids
tumblr_pdfnxkefna1svlvsyo2_r2_540.gif
 
What's wrong with happy endings? Each lead Trek character so far has arguably got a happy ending at the end of their respective franchises (if you consider Undiscovered Country as the end for Kirk's run opposed to Generations, but even with Generations, Kirk chose to come back to help Picard and died saving countless people, which was a pretty fitting end). Avery Brooks and the DS9 writers worked out a compromise to not kill off his character, to leave his fate in limbo, but with the promise he would be back...someday.

Why should Burnham not have a happy end? Throughout her life she lost her biological parents, was killed as a child, committed mutiny against Georgiou-another mother figure-and played a role in her death, was imprisoned (for mutiny and also helping instigate a war), and had to fight her way back to redemption. Then she left behind all she knew, including her beloved adopted family, to go into the future. From there, she fell in love with Book, who lost his entire planet and most of his family, and she also had to deal with that loss while trying to stop him from in Season 4 from acting on revenge. Burnham has experienced a lot of tragedy and turmoil in her life. Why doesn't she deserve a happy ending?

And considering the real world here, they were thankfully given more time to put together like a 15 or so minutes coda. I doubt they had the money or time to explore every other side character. Discovery was always about Burnham's journey, so it made sense that the series ended focused on her.

When I think about entertainment, genre, or otherwise, how many end with their protagonists having bad endings? I would argue-unscientifically of course-that most do not.
 
Last edited:
MIcheal being admiral and married to Book. then their son coming home to visit while he's in Starfleet Academy or him coming home from a ship he's on.

thats all you get to see in the series finale last episode. the show doesn't even hint at or even show Saru and his Vulcan wife's weird looking half breed children if they even had kids

i just frikkin said the son was visiting from EITHER the academy or from his ship or whatever. Pay attention next time before you reply to a topic thread

You are a definite ray of Sunshine.
 
The "red" planet where the Booker family lived...have we ever seen it before? It looked familiar. Wasn't it in one of the Abrams films?

And yeah, happy endings are still possible and entirely valid. Not every story has to end in bloodshed and misery. If Burnham and Book end up together with a happy family? What's wrong with that? :shrug:
 
Oh man, I didn’t consider that there would be fans so upset over Kirk’s fate that anyone else having a happily ever after ending is seen as the writers thumbing their nose at fans over what happened with Kirk.
 
Kirk? People are still complaining about that? :guffaw:

Kirk's death may not be a happy ending, but it was a meaningful ending. Kirk sacrificed his life to stop a dangerous enemy. Not happy of course, but nevertheless it was for a noble purpose.

And honestly, I think it was the way Kirk would have wanted to go.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top