When I assess an episode as being dark, I'm addressing the episode, not the series.
You still haven't told us what you think "dark" is...
When I assess an episode as being dark, I'm addressing the episode, not the series.
Missing key context hereNo, it hasn't.War with the Romulans led to the Federation, war with the Klingons in the 23rd century, the Enterprise-C had been destroyed by the Romulans, there'd been a war with the Cardassians, conflict with the Q and the Borg, the Federation is not a utopia, there is continuous conflict that continuously needs to be addressed.
But that misses context. People are not just watching a singular episode in a void but watching TNG in light of other TNG episodes. Up until that point the Federation was an evolved place that dealt with external conflicts. This episode is quite different because the conflict is internal. That's the key difference and creates a darker shadow on the Federation than before.When I assess an episode as being dark, I'm addressing the episode, not the series.
I had to look this episode up on Wikipedia as I don't remember it. Warp core problem looks like sabotage, retired Admiral is brought on to find the saboteur, the warp core part ended up being wear and tear, retired Admiral sticks around, obsessed with finding traitors. The episode is about yet another Admiral, this time retired, who'd gone looney tunes. Hardly a dark episode, and quite common on the show.But that misses context. People are not just watching a singular episode in a void but watching TNG in light of other TNG episodes. Up until that point the Federation was an evolved place that dealt with external conflicts. This episode is quite different because the conflict is internal. That's the key difference and creates a darker shadow on the Federation than before.
The episode is about yet another Admiral...
Dark is subjective.I had to look this episode up on Wikipedia as I don't remember it. Warp core problem looks like sabotage, retired Admiral is brought on to find the saboteur, the warp core part ended up being wear and tear, retired Admiral sticks around, obsessed with finding traitors. The episode is about yet another Admiral, this time retired, who'd gone looney tunes. Hardly a dark episode, and quite common on the show.
Indeed. Again, context of presentation is key here. In TNG at this point conflicts were largely external not internal. The Drumhead takes a much different tone of how Starfleet conducts itself to deal with internal threats.Off the top of my head, I'm thinking she's the first to actually go off the rails. Admiral Mark Jameson paid for the crimes of Captain Mark Jameson.
This is just regular drama. I don't find this dark at all.Dark is subjective.
A witch hunt using a Betazed for finding "traitors" is quite dark to my mind.
This is just regular drama. I don't find this dark at all.![]()
Hence the "subjective" part of my post.This is just regular drama. I don't find this dark at all.![]()
I just don't see it. Why do you think it's a dark episode? What about the crazy lady is so dark?For Trek at the time,in context, it was quite dark and sets a darker tone for what would come later on down the series and franchise.
I just don't see it. Why do you think it's a dark episode? What about the crazy lady is so dark?
Because she can make a person look guilty merely by having the incorrect thoughts. It hews very close to thought crime and is a disturbing use of a Betazoid's abilities.I just don't see it. Why do you think it's a dark episode? What about the crazy lady is so dark?
Angry Jean-Luc Picard doesn't seem to understand.Jesus Christ, people have already explained this to you. Over and over. It is like you can't comprehend what is being posted.
People do this all the time in the 2020's, trying to make people guilty for saying / thinking the "wrong thing." My reaction is simply, "Oh, TNG did this back in the 90's? Huh." I consulted with Perplexity. It suggested the episode could be dark due to betrayal of ideals, witch hunt, abuse of power, and erosion of civil liberties in the name of security. This is what I would call drama, not dark. When I think of a dark episode, I think of stuff like "Conspiracy," "Skin of Evil," "Yesterday's Enterprise," "Cause and Effect," and "Genesis."Because she can make a person look guilty merely by having the incorrect thoughts. It hews very close to thought crime and is a disturbing use of a Betazoid's abilities.
Understood, but considering how violent and rough life can be, this just isn't dark.She doesn't start off looking crazy. She comes across as reasonable and just looking in the name of "security." It's an internal leader against Picard and that's not how leadership has been presented.
When I think of a dark episode, I think of stuff like "Conspiracy," "Skin of Evil," "Yesterday's Enterprise," "Cause and Effect," and "Genesis."
When I think of a dark episode, I think of stuff like "Conspiracy," "Skin of Evil," "Yesterday's Enterprise," "Cause and Effect," and "Genesis."
And he won’t, because that defeats the purpose of using the BBS as his personal Memory Alpha and think tank instead of doing the work himself.You still haven't defined what you mean by "dark"...
Which is why context is key.People do this all the time in the 2020's, trying to make people guilty for saying / thinking the "wrong thing." My reaction is simply, "Oh, TNG did this back in the 90's? Huh."
But those are all external threats and dangers.When I think of a dark episode, I think of stuff like "Conspiracy," "Skin of Evil," "Yesterday's Enterprise," "Cause and Effect," and "Genesis."
Dark =/= violent or rough. Dark is showing something immoral, unethical, or abuse of power.Understood, but considering how violent and rough life can be, this just isn't dark.![]()
OK, nooooow we're on the same page. I do not consider those things remotely dark in any sense. To me, dark means violence, injury, death, grieving, war, natural disaster, freak accidents, stuff like that.Dark =/= violent or rough. Dark is showing something immoral, unethical, or abuse of power.
The Drumhead is text book definition, moving from a free place for human growth to thought crime was a dramatic shift.
Dark is so many things. Subverting freedoms is high on my list.OK, nooooow we're on the same page. I do not consider those things remotely dark in any sense. To me, dark means violence, injury, death, grieving, war, natural disaster, freak accidents, stuff like that.
To me, "The Drumhead" is just another Tuesday for the Enterprise.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.