I don't know what percentage of all critics liked it, but I do know that David Manninig of the Ridgefield (Connecticut) Press said the movie was an "astonishing film achievement" and Pine and Quinto were "outstanding"; "4 stars!" 
Rottentomatoes %
- Thread starter RobertScorpio
- Start date
Using a generous estimation, I'll say -47%. Also, one of the reviewers will be Gene Roddenberry, risen from the dead because he was so disgusted with the film and was sick of spinning in his grave (which he did so much that it created a micro-singularity.)
But the real question is whether the Shat's toupee gives it a good review. 'How can real hair out-act a toupee?' will be it's argument I imagine.
RobertScorpio
Pariah
the numbers at ROTTENTOMATOES are interesting...but I think 70% would have been fair for SUPERMAN RETURNS..I liked it.
Star Trek XI? If it gets below 60%? It might have trouble...
Rob
It seems from the majority of the wacky polls here on TBBS, that approximatelly 53% to 54% of the actual folks who vote, like what they've seen so far.
So I'm gonna use that number plus 30% for the general public who actually see it.
Going out on a limb here, but I'm gonna say 84%.
It's probably not logical, but it feels right to me.
So I'm gonna use that number plus 30% for the general public who actually see it.
Going out on a limb here, but I'm gonna say 84%.
It's probably not logical, but it feels right to me.
XI%? Well, actually, isn't kind of early to discuss rating the film, before it's even out there? But judging from the trailer, I think it might be a movie appealing to a large audience. Now that doesn't necessarily translate to good reviews from the critics, but still, let's say 80%?
Similar threads
