• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Retro Review: Jetrel

TrekToday

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
The inventor of the weapon that destroyed Neelix’s home planet seeks to cure a disease caused by exposure to the weapon. Plot Summary: Voyager is hailed by a ship carrying a doctor named Jetrel, whom a distraught Neelix identifies as the Haakonian scientist responsible for creating the deadly Metreon Cascade, which enveloped the Talaxian moon […]

More...
 
Not sure about this one. On the one hand, it's clearly a good episode and finally provides a platform for Ethan Phillips to explore a Neelix that isn't just the ships punch-able clown but on the other, i just don't find it that entertaining to watch.

James Sloyan is also very good as Jetrel (despite the fact that in my mind, i find it hard to see him as anyone other than Mora Pol). He does play guilty, tormented war criminal with a heart of gold extremely well but Jetrel and Mora Pol are a little too similar. Perhaps they were so impressed with Sloyan's ability to convey both confidence in his methods but also remorse for the consequences, that they hired him to do it again.

It's an interesting episode that gives Neelix some necessary back story but it's not one i look forward to watching that much. It just doesn't grab me to be honest.

It also doesn't help that they kinda regurgitated the story again with B'Elanna's war criminal holo-doctor, Crell Moset in Nothing Human. They changed enough for it to appear different but it's basically the same premise.

This is a resonably good episode but i think i prefer Nothing Human.
 
One of the best episodes in season 1.

Neelix's tragic background story is revealed here and he steps forward as a more interesting character than simply a clown character. In fact, some of Neelix's behavior can be explained as caused by this trauma.

The confrotation between Jetrel who was responsible for the terrible weapon which annihilated the people on Rinax and Neelix who lost his family because of that is brilliant and so is the inter-action between them.

I'll give it 5 points out of 5
 
A good first attempt at a "serious Neelix" episode, but I think "Mortal Coil" was his best because it doesn't depend on a guest star.
 
I think Janeway was convinced Jetrel was genuine and that Neelix has metremia from the after-effects of the planet-wide explosion. She also agreed to drive back to Rinax, the source of the atmosphere explosion,and is somewhat fascinated by letting him collect a sample from the transporter to help develop anti-bodies.
I studied how much interest Janeway had when she found out Jetrels idea of re-animating dead material from the planets atmosphere which was his ulterior motive. They tried to re-animate just one victim and the transporter buffer dispersal rate was too high and lacked the power for completion. Tuvok and Torres was at the controls and, given more time to learn Jetral's studies, they could have succeeded to return all the victims. How many- 3 million?
 
Even though there were important differences it reminded me a lot of DS9's Duet. I almost skipped it when I saw that it was a Neelix episode but I'm glad I watched it. It was a strong emotional episode and definitely one of the best of early Voyager.
 
Jetrel is one of the VOY episodes that i still rewatch regularly. The character Jetrel is loosely based on Robert Oppenheimer. It is emotional especially if you have seen the reels of the japanese victims of the two nukes. Neelix description of the effects of the Metreon cascade reminds you of those victims.


Jetrel just like Oppenheimer felt immense guilt for designing and building weapons of mass destruction. Guilt can wreck any man, great or small.

Jetrel, Nothing Human and Infinite Regress are great episodes where people confront their past crimes from past conflicts and their reaction accordingly. Star Trek excel in this type of story telling.
 
Last edited:
I'm really glad I rewatched this. As a teen I had zero interest. I saw Neelix and shut off the TV. I still think he doesn't really shine until Mortal Coil, however this one had an interesting dialog between the Jetrel and Neelix. And what I have to say about it has already been addressed.
 
I agree with most of the comments pointing to it as a definite highlight of the first season. I think what I found most impressive, in this, the first crack open of the door in revealing something substantive about what lay behind the facade of Neelix's personality, was the revelation of his vulnerability, weakness, and ultimately guilt. For the first time, he wasn't the hail-fellow-well-met whose equanimity was a constant in almost every situation (excepting The Cloud).

Anger was his justifiable reaction to the individual that was so responsible for the destruction of his family, the subjugation of his world, and his own seeming death sentence. But while warranted, we come to see the what and why that is behind the virulence of his implacable rage. That the shame of his own acts and decisions to have run, rather than join the fight in protecting Rinax that have haunted him for years, can no longer be hidden by a positive farcical facade. He is forced to voice truths that very few people alive are aware of, certainly not Kes. I don't recall if Neelix stated it directly, but I would have no doubt that he had felt that he should have been consumed along with his kin. Instead, he shut himself off in the solitary loneliness of a tinkerer's existence, probably without the ability to see himself worthy of anything more than simply surviving, no hope of redemption or the promise of anything transformative due him, at least until he found Kes.

I'm not sure I would rank it above Mortal Coil, but what is certain is that after this episode, any viewer that wasn't irrevocably predisposed to always dismissing him as a clown, could see clearly the outline of a multi-faceted personality whose compelling story had many more chapters yet to be told.
 
I like this episode just fine and do not skip it. It gives more depth to Neelix and I like the parallels to the H Bomb and Oppenheimer.

However as others have said I think Mortal Coil is a better Neelix episode (although my personal favorite is Fair Trade) and if I were to pick an episode that best deals with this issue I would go with Nothing Human.

And after having said that I agree that the reviewer at Sci-Fi debris makes some really good points.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top