Like I keep saying, I don't find Zombie's Michael Myers to be at all sympathetic. He's a terrifying, soulless killer and Zombie is able to portray that in a much more intense, unrelenting way than Carpenter can with his low-budget minimalism.
The problem is that Zombie tried- and ultimately failed- to make Myers sympathetic. He tried to explore the psychology of the character- that's why, I'm presuming, we got scenes of Myers as a child in a mental asylum with Loomis. I guess some people these days prefer over-the-top, relentless gore and violence over subtle minimalism- I'll take the minimalism over repetitive, in-your-face violence any day of the week.
I still don't agree with that interpretation. If anything, I think the asylum scenes are supposed to give us more insight into the mindset of Dr. Loomis; how burned out & terrified he is of Michael Myers.
Did you like the second one? I thought it was awful. First one was okay, for what it was. Devil's Rejects, on the other hand, I love that movie. I don't know why, it just speaks to me.