• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Rating for US Premiere

CBS and Netflix will have access to some incredibly detailed data aside from just how many watch the episode. How many times they rewatch it, and exactly who they are.

A shame we will never have access to those numbers, so any discussion on the ratings in the future will be pretty meaningless.

Personally I hope they take a good, hard look at The Orville ratings, dump STD after the first season, and come out with a new, different ST show with a different vibe, since the audience is there.

Definitely need to see at least a couple more weeks of ratings for The Orville in its current timeslot. It's already somewhat low for a show as expensive as it is.
 
So, butthurt Star Trek fans are giving Discovery bad reviews. What else is new? There's no way anyone can watch The Vulcan Hello/Battle at the Binary Stars and find them objectively inferior to Encounter at Farpoint.

I'd love to see what the "Rotten Tomatoes" numbers would have looked like in real time for each series after only 2 hours had been shown to the public.
 
So the ratings for Discovery have dropped off just a tad at Rotten Tomatoes, to 80% Fresh and 64% "Liked It."
 
The critics "Fresh" rating at Rotten Tomatoes has risen to 86%, while the viewer "Liked It" rating has fallen to 61%.
 
The ratings are good enough. I predict we will get at least 15 episodes.
There was a very recent interview in which one of the cast members mentioned that they were filming episode 15. I suspect you saw this or heard of it, and I call shenanigans on your powers of prediction. Nice try, though. :techman: :p
 
Didn't the critics get the first 4 eps to review? Maybe the next 2 will be better. It'll be nice to see the ship the show is named for at least.
 
As are user reviews in such small numbers, particularly when a riled-up portion of a fanbase is involved.
Not even just part of fanbase. Among the whole "This is not Star Trek", this or that room is to big, lens flare, etc.. you also have the insults toward SJWs in the mix. That's just people that even bother to comment anything. You have a bunch of ratings that are just half a star (didn't even realize that was a thing) and a lot of them. Which is pretty much in line with review bombing that takes place. That's why the user score is dropping the way it is. There is also nothing stopping someone from creating multiple accounts and continuing to do that. At that point when you see the actions like that you just have to discount that section like other user review sections on many sites.
 
Not even just part of fanbase. Among the whole "This is not Star Trek", this or that room is to big, lens flare, etc.. you also have the insults toward SJWs in the mix. That's just people that even bother to comment anything. You have a bunch of ratings that are just half a star (didn't even realize that was a thing) and a lot of them. Which is pretty much in line with review bombing that takes place. That's why the user score is dropping the way it is. There is also nothing stopping someone from creating multiple accounts and continuing to do. At that point when you see the actions like that you just have to discount that section like user review sections on many sites.

Which is why when people say "professional reviews mean nothing hue hue hue". I just shake my head. I would much rather take the opinion of someone who puts out their real name and picture and oh yeah THEIR LIVELY HOOD DEPENDS ON A WELL REASONED ARGUEMENT. Are their clickbait sites? Of course. But lets not be children about this we all know which sites have legitimacy and which to avoid. These reasons by the way are why professional reviews are important far and before their own expertise and experience in said field beyond that of a mouth breather disgruntled person hiding behind a keyboard.
 
Wasn't sure I should bother with a whole new thread just for the Canadian ratings, so I'll just mention them here.

Apparently, Discovery broke Canadian viewership records: it was the most-watched show ever on a Canadian specialty channel (on Space, episode 1 set the record initially with 1.17 million viewers, then episode 2 immediately broke that record, with 1.2 million viewers), and it was the largest ever debut on the CraveTV streaming service.

Including the CTV numbers (CTV simulcasted only episode 1), 2.2 million people in total watched the first episode.

This is apparently based on Live + 3 day numbers.

Source: Bell Media press release
 
Wasn't sure I should bother with a whole new thread just for the Canadian ratings, so I'll just mention them here.

Apparently, Discovery broke Canadian viewership records: it was the most-watched show ever on a Canadian specialty channel (on Space, episode 1 set the record initially with 1.17 million viewers, then episode 2 immediately broke that record, with 1.2 million viewers), and it was the largest ever debut on the CraveTV streaming service.

Including the CTV numbers (CTV simulcasted only episode 1), 2.2 million people in total watched the first episode.

This is apparently based on Live + 3 day numbers.

Source: Bell Media press release

NOOOOOOOEZ!!!!!1!! It can't be! TEH SHO IZ TEH SUX!!!1!!

:lol:;)
 
So, butthurt Star Trek fans are giving Discovery bad reviews. What else is new? There's no way anyone can watch The Vulcan Hello/Battle at the Binary Stars and find them objectively inferior to Encounter at Farpoint.

I prefer "Farpoint" to the Discovery episodes. There is heart and optimism to the "Farpoint" story that simply doesn't exist in the two Discovery episodes. "Farpoint" actually feels like it is about something.
 
It's not good, but I think that calling it a flop is a little premature at this point. The show moved nights. Its possible that audiences missed the advertising suggesting it was happening. I think we need to wait to see this week's episode's ratings to see if losing football as a lead-in is as big of a loss as it is.

The Orville fell again. Not quite as precipitously as in the previous two weeks, but it dropped from 4.05m to 3.7m. It's shedding viewers at a rate of knots.
 
Speaking of Live+3 does anyone know discoveries? Can't seem to find them anywhere.
 
I prefer "Farpoint" to the Discovery episodes. There is heart and optimism to the "Farpoint" story that simply doesn't exist in the two Discovery episodes. "Farpoint" actually feels like it is about something.
Honestly top me - Encounter At Farpoint was about 2 Hours, I was so unimpressed (and even more unimpressed when I was the first 'regular' episode was a piss poor remake of a truly classic TOS episode) - I ALMOST said, "I'm done". If TNG hadn't been the first new attempt at Live Action Star Trek in 18 years at that point - I would have probably treated in the way I did ST:VOY (IE stop watching).

At the time many of my group that also liked TOS didn't start watching TNG until Season 3 and "Yesterday's Enterprise". Everyone's 'milage' varies.

But TNG at the start always came across to me like: "This is what GR would have done to the original cast and ST Universe with ST: Phase II?? I'm glad that version never got made and we got the feature films like STII:TWoK."
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top