• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Pyramid Skyscraper To Orbit?

In all seriousness, an electromagnetic "railgun-style" orbital slingshot isn't a new idea. One shows up (on the moon) in Clarke's Time Odyssey trilogy.

Quite true. And the Orbital Elevator idea has been around quite a while as well (and also featured in detail in that book series).

Actually, that series used a LOT of current science ideas. Was watching a recent "plan for colonies on the moon and beyond" tv show recently, and was suprised by how much in that show was also featured in Clarke's work.
 
Taking Taccys original "Pyramid to Orbit" theme literally, with no magelv (as per the original post, ain't no maglev there!) and attempting to construct a pyramid at which the apex of would allow items to be placed in orbit, here's the deal:

The pyramid has to be the 22,500 miles required the orbital relocity to match the rotational rate of the structure.

Taccy says the pyramid needs to have a 45 degree slope, so the base of said pyramid would be 22,500 miles in width and depth.

What's the circumference of the planet?

Diagram the structure and the planet it rests upon. (hint, draw a circle, then draw an equilaterial triangle where each face is about 3x the diameter of the circle. Arrange the triangle so that the middle of one face is touching the edge of the circle in one spot.)
 
Never mind the other silly stuff... But I suspect a 75 mile high pyramid-ish building would have enough mass to seriously depress the planetary crust underneath it, potentially opening up a fault line. Not good. Unless you enjoy your building sinking into a lake of lava/magma.
 
Psstch, I say we just fix Lunar into a geosynchronous orbit with Terra, and make a giant cable from one to the other, and build stations, elevators and the whole whazoo on the joining cable. Let's be ambitous about this people ;) 'Aim for the moon, if you miss you'll still be among the stars' and all that jazz...though not literally with this hair-brained idea, you'll just have a cable leading to nowhere :p

Brilliant! All we need is a grappling hook with a really, really, really long rope attached!

I also suggest that the Earth end of the cable has a quick release, that way, we can throw the Moon at the invading aliens like a freaking huge bolas. Of course, the Earth would need to be fitted with spinner rockets so that we can build up enough speed and whatnot for the throw, but no expense can be spared for the defense of one's homeworld :techman:
 
Taccy says the pyramid needs to have a 45 degree slope, so the base of said pyramid would be 22,500 miles in width and depth.

What's the circumference of the planet?

According to Wolfram Alpha, 24901.47 miles.

I think I see a problem here.
 
Do these calculations include the fact that the curvature of the Earth would also mean that the sides would have farther to reach before hitting the surface?
 
Tachy does say in first post, however, that "orbit being in this case where the earth's atmosphere turns to vaccum" or words to that effect.

In otherwords, he doesn't want this hyper-pyramid to actually "put things in orbit" he just wants it tall enough to "be in space."

"Orbit", obviously, was poor, and foolish choice of words on his part.

He wants a pyramid to space, or the "edge of the atmosphere" (even though no such thing really exsists.)
 
Maybe he should call Bob Truax then. I don't think he's doing much since he worked with Knevil at Snake River.
 
at the size of the pyramid we're talking about (earth diameter), wouldn't it be more resource-conservative to just get giant space-bulldozers and try to reshape the planet itself into a pyramid?
 
Last edited:
Other problems to consider. The immense weight of the structure would need a solid foundation. How would the lifts handle the pressure changes as you approached space? What is the travel time of the lifts from base to top. Individual fire departments per floor nearer the base?

Excellent points. Would the lifts be effected by pressure changes if they only travelled so far each? meaning you change lifts multiple times on the way up so each lift notices only small changes in pressure each?

I am pretty sure the foundation problems are far beyond anything we can build. They say we could not even duplicate the great pyramid with today's tech primarily because of foundation issues, much less a pyramid that is 75 miles high.
 
Other problems to consider. The immense weight of the structure would need a solid foundation. How would the lifts handle the pressure changes as you approached space? What is the travel time of the lifts from base to top. Individual fire departments per floor nearer the base?

Excellent points. Would the lifts be effected by pressure changes if they only travelled so far each? meaning you change lifts multiple times on the way up so each lift notices only small changes in pressure each?

I am pretty sure the foundation problems are far beyond anything we can build. They say we could not even duplicate the great pyramid with today's tech primarily because of foundation issues, much less a pyramid that is 75 miles high.

I'm not sure I get the bolded part. Why not? Has the earth's surface become softer in the last 4000 years?:wtf: Surely a pyramid built to the size of the Great Pyramid using today's technology would use much less mass than the original solid stone one. The Luxor hotel in Vegas is 350 feet tall. Not as large as the 481 feet of the Great Pyramid, but it is getting in the neighborhood.
 
Tachy does say in first post, however, that "orbit being in this case where the earth's atmosphere turns to vaccum" or words to that effect.

In otherwords, he doesn't want this hyper-pyramid to actually "put things in orbit" he just wants it tall enough to "be in space."

"Orbit", obviously, was poor, and foolish choice of words on his part.

He wants a pyramid to space, or the "edge of the atmosphere" (even though no such thing really exsists.)

Well OK - to try and get some life out of the OPs slightly loopy idea let us consider how practical it would be to build a structure to 10,000 feet with useful internal space?

The new tower in Dubai looks set to finish short of 3,000ft (still enormous) so what chance for 3 times that?
 
at the size of the pyramid we're talking about (earth diameter),

Earths diameter is 75 miles? :cardie:

The pyramid we're talking about if you were not aware would be 75 miles high and would have a base area roughly equivalent to the area of the country of Togo.
This was made clear on page one of this thread.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top