I much preferred Pulaski - she reminded me a little of my Mum. Crusher was a boring character with an annoying son.
Pulaski Fans
- Thread starter Mike Have-Not
- Start date
A
Amaris
Guest
I prefer Pulaski.
Pulaski definitely. Far more interesting character than Crusher.
I would've been very interested to see what sort of storylines Pulaski would've had if she'd stayed longer.
I would've been very interested to see what sort of storylines Pulaski would've had if she'd stayed longer.
PULASKI.
The only thing I liked about Crusher was her hair.
PULASKI FTW!
The only thing I liked about Crusher was her hair.
PULASKI FTW!
I'm the same. I think Crusher is great but, that said, I don't dislike Pulaski.
When they let her actually do something, McFadden/Crusher could be an interesting character.
But Muldaur was "on" from the moment she appeared on screen in her first episode. I wonder if the writers gave that a little extra because they knew they were trying to shoehorn in a new character?
But Muldaur was "on" from the moment she appeared on screen in her first episode. I wonder if the writers gave that a little extra because they knew they were trying to shoehorn in a new character?
that could be . . .
I always felt that Pulaski was more of a scientist than Crusher . . . they seemed to give Muldaur more 'treknobabble' than to McFadden
even though it's boring at times it helped make Pulaski seem to actually be good at her job, whereas Crusher mostly said "you're going to be all right" *pats shoulder*
I liked 'her' better 23 years earlier, when 'she' was a 'he'; and was an original character, and not something ripped from an earlier (and better) version to try and shore up falling ratings at the time.
Dr. Leonard 'Bones' McCoy = Good original character (back in the day - reletive to TNG Season 2).
Dr. Katherine Pulaski = Pale imitation/blatent ripoff.
Dr. Leonard 'Bones' McCoy = Good original character (back in the day - reletive to TNG Season 2).
Dr. Katherine Pulaski = Pale imitation/blatent ripoff.
I found Pulaski to be much more cardboard. Crusher was a bit boring because she was a nice character without a lot of conflict, but to me Pulaski was just a wooden grump who snapped at everyone. But I didn't equate that to personality. Couldn't have been happier to see her go personally.
Perhaps in a homage to LA LAW, Pulaski plunges down a turbo-lift shaft to her death?... I actively hated Pulaski. In my mind I always imagine she suffered an off-screen fate so brutal and horrific that they never spoke of it on screen.
Maybe I could agree with you if I hadn't seen her before, but when I look at those pictures all I can see is Pulaski's old chicken face
Similar threads
